THE CALCULATION OF THE DOSAGE‐MORTALITY CURVE

C. I. BlissAnnals of Applied Biology 1935 · DOI

This 1935 landmark paper by C. I. Bliss revolutionized toxicology by introducing the probit transformation. By converting sigmoid (S-shaped) dosage-mortality curves into straight lines, Bliss provided a mathematically rigorous way to calculate lethal dosages and their associated errors, a method that remains a cornerstone of bioassay analysis today.

TL;DR

Bliss introduces the "probit" (probability unit) to linearize the sigmoid relationship between toxic dosage and organism mortality. This allows researchers to apply standard linear regression and R.A. Fisher’s maximum likelihood methods to determine toxicological potency with high statistical precision.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In toxicological studies, plotting the percentage of organisms killed against the dose typically results in a sigmoid curve. These "S-curves" are notoriously difficult to analyze: they are non-linear, and the change in mortality per unit of dose is inconsistent (smallest at the extremes and largest near 50% kill).

Before this paper, biologists struggled to accurately estimate the "median lethal dose" (LD50) or compare the effectiveness of different poisons. Bliss sought to move beyond "fitting by eye" to a standardized statistical framework that accounts for the varying reliability of data points across the dosage range.

Methods

The core of the paper is a two-step transformation:

  1. Logarithmic Scaling: The dosage is converted to its logarithm. Bliss argues that susceptibility often follows a geometric rather than arithmetic distribution, aligning with the Weber-Fechner law.
  2. Probit Transformation: Mortality percentages are converted into "probits." A probit is essentially the normal deviate ($z$-score) of the cumulative normal distribution, shifted by +5 to eliminate negative numbers.

![Fig.

  1. The theoretical normal curve of error, showing how a specific dose (x) splits a population into dead (p) and survivors (q).](/figures/art_c251a37285e14d05881b208f92d2d981)

Once linearized, Bliss applies a weighted linear regression. Because a 50% kill rate is statistically more "stable" than a 0% or 100% kill rate, he assigns higher weights to observations near the median. He also includes a specialized appendix by R.A. Fisher to handle the "zero survivor" problem, allowing 100% mortality data to be incorporated into the model via maximum likelihood estimation.

Datasets

Bliss demonstrates his method using experimental data from Strand (1930). The dataset tracks the mortality of the adult flour beetle (Tribolium confusum) after five hours of exposure to varying concentrations of gaseous carbon disulphide ($CS_2$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Susceptibility as a Distribution: Bliss treats the dosage-mortality curve as a cumulative normal frequency distribution. Each point on the curve represents the proportion of the population whose "individual lethal dose" is less than or equal to the applied dose.
  • Linearization is Power: By turning the curve into a line ($Y = a + b(X - \bar{x})$), researchers can easily calculate the slope ($b$), which measures how uniformly a population responds to a toxin.
  • The Weighting Coefficient: Bliss provides tables for a weighting coefficient ($z^2/pq$). This ensures that the regression line is influenced most by the most reliable data points, preventing outliers at the extreme ends of the scale from skewing the results.
  • Handling the Extremes: The paper provides a rigorous way to use 0% and 100% kill data, which were previously often discarded or handled inconsistently.

Key Results

The paper provides the famous Table I, a "cheat sheet" for researchers to convert mortality percentages directly into probits without performing complex calculus.

Table I.

Using the Tribolium data, Bliss shows that the probit-log(dose) plot yields a remarkably straight line. He calculates the regression equation and defines the "zone of error"—a hyperbolic confidence interval around the regression line that provides a 19-in-20 (95%) chance of enclosing the true mortality curve.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption of Normality: The method assumes that the distribution of susceptibility is normal (after log transformation). Bliss acknowledges that if the underlying distribution is skewed or follows a different law (like the $z$-distribution), the probit model might require adjustment.
  • Biological "Breaks": Bliss notes that some datasets show a "break" or change in slope at low dosages. He suggests this might not be a mathematical artifact but a biological reality, such as "protective stupefaction" where low doses trigger a physiological defense that changes the organism's susceptibility.
  • Future Directions: The author indicates that subsequent papers will apply these statistical methods to compare different sets of dosage-mortality data and analyze time-survival curves.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary. The sigmoid dosage‐mortality curve, secured so commonly in toxicity tests upon multicellular organisms, is interpreted as a cumulative normal frequency distribution of the variation among the individuals of a population in their susceptibility to a toxic agent, which susceptibility is inversely proportional to the logarithm of the dose applied. In support of this interpretation is the fact that when dosage is inferred from the observed mortality on the assumption that susceptibility is distributed normally, such inferred dosages, in terms of units called probits, give straight lines when plotted against the logarithm of their corresponding observed dosages. It is shown that this use of the logarithm of the dosage can be interpreted in terms either of the Weber‐Fechner law or of the amount of poison fixed by the tissues of the organism. How this transformation to a straight regression line facilitates the precise estimation of the dosage‐mortality relationship and its accuracy is considered in detail. Statistical methods are described for taking account of tests which result in 0 or 100 per cent, kill, for giving each determination a weight proportional to its reliability, for computing the position and slope of the transformed dosage‐mortality curve, for measuring the goodness of fit of the regression line to the observations by the X 2 test, and for calculating the error in position and in slope and their combined effect at any log. dosage. The terminology and procedures are consistent with those used by R. A. Fisher, who has contributed an appendix on the case of zero survivors. Except for a table of common logarithms, all the tables required to utilise the methods described are given either in the present paper or in Fisher's book. A numerical example selected from Strand's experiments upon Tribolium confusum with carbon disulphide has been worked out in detail.
BibTeX
@article{bliss1935calculation,
  author = {C. I. BLISS},
  title = {{THE CALCULATION OF THE DOSAGE‐MORTALITY CURVE}},
  journal = {Annals of Applied Biology},
  year = {1935},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1744-7348.1935.tb07713.x},
}
The error of determination of toxicityProceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Containing Papers of a Biological Character · 1927
On the Rate of Growth of the Population of the United States since 1790 and Its Mathematical RepresentationProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 1920
Interval estimation of excess risk related effective doses in tobit modelsOpen · 2009
A new function for drug combination dose finding trialsScientific · 2024
Psychophysical AnalysisThe American Journal of Psychology · 1927
REAP-2: An interactive quantitative tool for robust and efficient dose-response curve estimationJournal of Clinical and Translational Science · 2023
Figure