Abstract
Biomedical engineering (BME) is a profession with ethical responsibilities comparable to those in medicine, yet it has historically lacked a counterpart to the Hippocratic Oath. While professional societies have established codes of ethics, these documents often lack the symbolic and ceremonial significance of a formal pledge. To fill this gap, we introduce the "Biomedical Engineer’s Pledge," a 10-point ethical framework designed to inspire ethical awareness and establish a meaningful graduation tradition for the next generation of engineers.
Addressing the Ethical Gap in Engineering
Biomedical engineering is a high-stakes field where technical decisions directly impact patient safety, data privacy, and social equity. However, the discipline has historically lacked a "symbolic and ceremonial" anchor for its ethical responsibilities. While organizations like the IEEE or BMES provide codes of ethics, these are frequently viewed as dry, regulatory documents rather than personal commitments. Conversely, the medical "Physician’s Pledge" is too focused on clinical practice to be directly applicable to engineers. This paper seeks to bridge that gap by providing a formal, yet voluntary, oath tailored to the unique ethical landscape of BME.
Methodology and Philosophical Foundation
The "Biomedical Engineer’s Pledge" was developed through a collaborative process involving a diverse coalition of stakeholders, including students, academics, industry professionals, physicians, and ethicists. The authors modeled the pledge after the World Medical Association’s Declaration of Geneva (the modern Hippocratic Oath).
To ensure philosophical rigor, the pledge’s ten promises were mapped to the "Four Principles" framework of bioethics:
- Beneficence (acting in the patient's best interest)
- Non-maleficence (doing no harm)
- Justice (fairness and equity)
- Respect for autonomy (honoring patient choice)
The resulting text was translated into multiple languages—including English, Spanish, French, and Catalan—to facilitate international adoption. While this is a perspective piece, the authors have provided a public repository on Zenodo containing the collaborative drafting history and ethical case studies to help students practice applying the pledge to real-world scenarios.
Key Insights and Modern Relevance
- Safety as the Paramount Priority: The first promise explicitly prioritizes the safety and well-being of patients and the public. Placing safety first aligns with the classical aphorism Primum non nocere ("Above all, do no harm").
- Addressing 21st-Century Risks: Unlike older ethical codes, this pledge explicitly addresses modern challenges, such as data safeguarding (essential for AI and neurotechnology) and the avoidance of patient deception or fraud.
- Sustainability and Equity: The pledge breaks new ground by including commitments to environmental and economic sustainability and the promotion of universal health coverage. This shifts the engineer's focus from a single device to a broader collective ethical duty.
- The Power of Symbolism: The pledge is intended as a "rite of passage." By reciting it at graduation, students internalize ethical principles as a core part of their professional identity before entering the workforce.
Real-World Adoption and Impact
The paper reports successful early-stage implementation and high-level institutional support:
- Institutional Integration: The pledge has already been integrated into graduation ceremonies at Universitat Pompeu Fabra and Universidad Politécnica de Cartagena in Spain.
- Global Endorsements: It has received official endorsements from the Hippocratic Movement and the International Federation for Medical & Biological Engineering (IFMBE).
- Open Access: The pledge is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-ND 4.0), allowing any institution to adopt or recite it freely.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The primary limitation of the pledge is its voluntary and non-binding nature; its efficacy depends on the willingness of universities to adopt it and students to uphold it. However, it serves as a vital first step in addressing the "underemphasized" state of ethical training in BME curricula. Future work involves encouraging the use of the pledge across various educational levels (BSc, MSc, and PhD) and integrating associated case studies into standard bioethics coursework to ensure the "moral compass" of biomedical engineers remains calibrated throughout their careers.
Summary updated