The Beneficial Effects of Cognitive Walking Program on Improving Cognitive Function and Physical Fitness in Older Adults

Suh-Jung Kang, Byung-Hoon Kim, Hyo Lee, Jinsung WangHealthcare 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated a novel "cognitive walking program" (CWP) that combines physical exercise with cognitive training for older adults. The findings suggest that both CWP and traditional normal walking (NW) can improve cognitive function and physical fitness, with potentially greater benefits for those already physically active.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As people age, cognitive function and physical fitness naturally decline, increasing the risk of neurodegenerative diseases and reducing quality of life. While physical activity is known to benefit brain health, and cognitive training can also improve cognitive function, the optimal way to combine these for maximum benefit in older adults remains an area of exploration. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of whether a program that simultaneously integrates cognitive challenges with physical walking (CWP) offers advantages over standard walking or other interventions for improving cognitive function and physical fitness in the elderly.

Methods

The researchers designed a 6-month intervention study involving older adults (aged 65+). Participants were divided into three groups:

  • CWP-Active Group (CWPAG): Participants who already engaged in regular exercise were assigned to the CWP.
  • CWP-Sedentary Group (CWPSG): Sedentary participants were assigned to the CWP.
  • Normal Walking Sedentary Group (NWSG): Sedentary participants were assigned to a control group performing normal walking outdoors.

Both CWP and NW sessions were conducted for 60 minutes, three times a week. The CWP involved:

  • Cardiorespiratory Walking: Focused on improving cardiovascular health and lower body strength.
  • Dual-Task Walking: Required participants to perform physical movements of the upper and lower body concurrently, demanding attention and coordination.
  • Visual Memory Walking: Involved memorizing and recalling stepping patterns of increasing complexity.

Cognitive function (attention, visuospatial function, memory, frontal/executive function) and physical fitness (cardiorespiratory fitness, lower extremity muscular strength, active balance ability) were assessed at baseline, 3 months, and 6 months.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Movement and Cognition: The core idea is that combining physical activity with cognitive demands simultaneously might unlock greater benefits than either intervention alone. The CWP's design, incorporating dual-tasking and visual memory, aims to leverage this synergy.
  • Benefits for All, Greater for the Active? While both CWP and NW showed improvements, the CWP-active group (CWPAG) demonstrated improvements across all four cognitive function measures, suggesting that pre-existing physical activity might enhance the benefits of CWP.
  • Time-Dependent Improvements: Cognitive function and physical fitness improvements were not always immediate. Some cognitive functions and physical fitness measures showed significant changes only after 6 months, highlighting the importance of sustained engagement.
  • Walking is Still Great: The study reinforces that even simple normal walking (NW) outdoors provides significant benefits for cognitive function and physical fitness in older adults, underscoring its accessibility and effectiveness.

Key Results

  • Cognitive Function: All three groups showed improvements in cognitive function over time. Specifically, memory improved at 3 months in all groups, while frontal/executive function improvements took 6 months in CWPAG and NWSG. CWPAG showed improvements in all four cognitive factors.
  • Physical Fitness: All three groups showed improvements in cardiorespiratory fitness and active balance ability by 3 months, and in lower extremity muscular strength by 6 months.
  • No Significant Group Differences: Crucially, the study did not find statistically significant differences between the CWP groups (active and sedentary) and the NW group in terms of cognitive function improvements. This suggests that while CWP is beneficial, it may not be superior to NW for sedentary individuals, possibly due to limitations in statistical power.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Lack of a True Control Group: The study lacked a group that did not engage in any physical activity, making it difficult to definitively attribute all observed changes solely to the exercise programs.
  • Statistical Power: The relatively small sample size, particularly after dropouts, may have limited the ability to detect significant differences between groups.
  • Objective Measurement of Intensity: The study relied on self-reported exertion (RPE scale) rather than objective measures like heart rate monitors or accelerometers, which could provide more precise data on physical demands.
  • Learning Effects: Repeated cognitive testing might have introduced learning effects that influenced the results.

Future work could focus on:

  • Larger Sample Sizes: To increase statistical power and better differentiate the effects of CWP versus NW.
  • Investigating CWP in Specific Populations: Exploring the benefits of CWP in individuals with mild cognitive impairment or different age groups.
  • Objective Physiological Monitoring: Incorporating wearable devices to objectively measure exercise intensity and physiological responses.
  • Exploring Mechanisms: Delving deeper into the neurobiological mechanisms underlying the observed improvements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Exercise and cognitive training can improve the brain-related health of the elderly. We investigated the effects of a cognitive walking program (CWP) involving simultaneous performance of indoor walking and cognitive training on cognitive function and physical fitness compared to normal walking (NW) outdoors. Participants were grouped according to whether they performed regular exercise for at least 3 months prior to the participation in this study. Active participants were assigned to the CWP-active group (CWPAG). Sedentary participants were randomly assigned to the CWP (CWPSG) or NW group (NWSG). CWP and NW were performed for 60 min, 3 times a week, for 6 months. Cognitive function (attention, visuospatial function, memory, and frontal/executive function) and physical fitness (cardiorespiratory fitness, lower extremity muscular strength, and active balance ability) were measured at baseline, 3 months, and 6 months after the program onset. Cognitive function showed improvements over time in all three groups, especially in CWPAG. No clear difference was observed between CWPSG and NWSG. Improvements in all fitness measures were also observed in all three groups. These findings collectively indicate the beneficial effects of CWP, as well as NW, on improving cognitive function and physical fitness in older adults, especially those who are physically active.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kang2021beneficial,
  author = {Suh-Jung Kang and Byung-Hoon Kim and Hyo Lee and Jinsung Wang},
  title = {{The Beneficial Effects of Cognitive Walking Program on Improving Cognitive Function and Physical Fitness in Older Adults}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare9040419},
}
Figure