The Australian Traumatic Brain Injury Initiative: Review and Recommendations for Outcome Measures for Use With Adults and Children After Moderate-to-Severe Traumatic Brain Injury

Jennie Ponsford, Amelia J. Hicks, Matthew K. Bagg, Ruby K. Phyland, Sarah L. Carrier, Amelia C. James, Natasha A. Lannin, Nick Rushworth, Terence J. O’Brien, Peter Cameron, D. James Cooper, Regina Hill, Belinda J. Gabbe, Melinda FitzgeraldNeurotrauma 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for standardized outcome measures in moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) research in Australia. By employing a rigorous evidence-based consensus approach involving clinicians, researchers, and individuals with lived experience, the Australian Traumatic Brain Injury Initiative (AUS-TBI) has identified 11 core outcome measures to ensure consistent data collection and facilitate better understanding and comparison of TBI outcomes nationwide.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traumatic brain injury (TBI), particularly moderate-to-severe cases, is a leading cause of disability and mortality, with long-lasting effects on individuals. Despite significant contributions from Australian researchers, a lack of consistent outcome measurement across studies has hindered progress in understanding TBI trajectories and improving management. This inconsistency makes it difficult to compare findings, benchmark performance, and develop robust prognostic models. Furthermore, existing measures may not adequately capture the diverse needs and experiences of all Australian populations, including those in rural areas or from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. This paper tackles this challenge by proposing a standardized set of outcome measures to unify TBI research and clinical practice across Australia.

Methods

The AUS-TBI initiative employed a multi-stage, evidence-based consensus approach. This began with a comprehensive systematic review of existing systematic reviews (a "review of reviews") to identify relevant outcome measures. This was followed by a detailed extraction of characteristics for 75 outcome measures from 1485 primary studies. Crucially, this quantitative data was then integrated with qualitative input through consensus meetings involving an expert panel of TBI clinicians and researchers, as well as a dedicated Living Experience expert group (individuals with lived experience of TBI). This iterative process, guided by facilitators and informed by the World Health Organization's International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) framework, led to the refinement and selection of a final list of 11 core outcome measures.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it systematically reviewed and synthesized data from existing literature. The primary data sources were:

  • 1485 primary studies identified through a systematic review of reviews.
  • 5936 records initially identified in the literature search, from which 954 were reviewed in full text, leading to the selection of 520 eligible reviews.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Consensus: The study highlights the importance of a multi-stakeholder approach, integrating clinical expertise, research evidence, and the lived experiences of individuals affected by TBI. This ensures that the selected measures are not only scientifically sound but also relevant and practical.
  • Bridging the Gap: The initiative aims to bridge the gap between research and clinical practice by recommending measures that are already in routine use (like the FIM in Australian rehabilitation hospitals) or that can be administered efficiently.
  • Addressing Diverse Needs: The inclusion of input from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander representatives and the consideration of diverse demographic groups underscore the commitment to developing measures that are culturally appropriate and relevant across Australia.
  • Focus on Core Outcomes: The decision to narrow the focus from the broad ICF framework to mortality, everyday functional outcomes, and quality of life was a pragmatic step to create an achievable and impactful set of core measures.

Key Results

The AUS-TBI initiative identified and recommended 11 core outcome measures for use in adults and children with moderate-to-severe TBI. These measures cover critical aspects of recovery and life post-injury:

  • Mortality
  • Functional Independence Measure (FIM) (adult)
  • Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOS-E) (adult)
  • Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS) (adult)
  • EuroQol-5 Dimensions (EQ5D) (adult and pediatric)
  • Mayo-Portland Adaptability Inventory (MPAI) (adult)
  • Return to Work/Study (RTS/RTW) (adult and pediatric)
  • Functional Independence Measure for Children (WEEFIM) (pediatric)
  • Glasgow Outcome Scale Modified for Children (GOS-E PEDS) (pediatric)
  • Paediatric Quality of Life Scale (PEDS-QL) (pediatric)
  • Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) (pediatric)

These measures are intended to be included as common data elements in the AUS-TBI data dictionary, facilitating standardized data collection.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Scope of Review: Due to time and resource constraints, the review could not examine all systematic reviews or primary studies. The focus was narrowed from the broader ICF framework to mortality, functional outcomes, and quality of life.
  • Living Experience Panel Input: While the Living Experience panel provided valuable input on the nature of outcomes and data collection, they did not review every measure in detail.
  • Pediatric Measures: Some pediatric measures, while promising, had undocumented sensitivity to change over time.
  • Transition to Adulthood: The issue of collecting data during the transition from childhood to adulthood needs further consideration.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Piloting Data Collection: Testing the feasibility of administering these measures via telephone and gathering feedback from individuals.
  • Investigating Data Linkage: Exploring how existing data collection systems and data linkage can be leveraged.
  • Optimizing Time Points: Determining the optimal time points for data collection.
  • Developing Data Systems: Creating robust systems for data collection, linkage, storage, and analysis.
  • Addressing Other Factors: While not included in the core set due to scope, factors like cognitive function, fatigue, and sexual function were identified as important and may be addressed in future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Australian Traumatic Brain Injury Initiative (AUS-TBI) aims to select a set of measures to comprehensively predict and assess outcomes following moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) across Australia. The aim of this article was to report on the implementation and findings of an evidence-based consensus approach to develop AUS-TBI recommendations for outcome measures following adult and pediatric moderate-to-severe TBI. Following consultation with a panel of expert clinicians, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander representatives and a Living Experience group, and preliminary literature searches with a broader focus, a decision was made to focus on measures of mortality, everyday functional outcomes, and quality of life. Standardized searches of bibliographic databases were conducted through March 2022. Characteristics of 75 outcome measures were extracted from 1485 primary studies. Consensus meetings among the AUS-TBI Steering Committee, an expert panel of clinicians and researchers and a group of individuals with lived experience of TBI resulted in the production of a final list of 11 core outcome measures: the Functional Independence Measure (FIM); Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOS-E); Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS) (adult); mortality; EuroQol-5 Dimensions (EQ5D); Mayo-Portland Adaptability Inventory (MPAI); Return to Work /Study (adult and pediatric); Functional Independence Measure for Children (WEEFIM); Glasgow Outcome Scale Modified for Children (GOS-E PEDS); Paediatric Quality of Life Scale (PEDS-QL); and Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (pediatric). These 11 outcome measures will be included as common data elements in the AUS-TBI data dictionary. Review Registration PROSPERO (CRD42022290954).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ponsford2024australian,
  author = {Jennie Ponsford and Amelia J. Hicks and Matthew K. Bagg and Ruby K. Phyland and Sarah L. Carrier and Amelia C. James and Natasha A. Lannin and Nick Rushworth and Terence J. O’Brien and Peter Cameron and D. James Cooper and Regina Hill and Belinda J. Gabbe and Melinda Fitzgerald and Melinda Fitzgerald},
  title = {{The Australian Traumatic Brain Injury Initiative: Review and Recommendations for Outcome Measures for Use With Adults and Children After Moderate-to-Severe Traumatic Brain Injury}},
  booktitle = {Neurotrauma},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1089/neur.2023.0127},
}
Figure