The association between varus knee deformity and morphological changes in the foot and ankle in patients with end-stage varus knee osteoarthritis

Zhenchao Huang, Zian Zhang, Wenzhe Wang, Fan Chen, Haining ZhangJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Varus knee deformity was associated with morphological changes in the foot and ankle, and the incidence of ankle OA and hallux valgus deformity was significantly higher in patients with severe varus KOA. Patients with severe varus KOA were more prone to medial ankle pain, hindfoot pain, and multiple pain locations, which were associated with corresponding morphological changes.

Introduction

Knee osteoarthritis (KOA) is often treated as a localized joint issue. However, the lower limb operates as a linked mechanical system. When the knee develops a varus deformity (commonly known as "bow-leggedness"), the foot and ankle must undergo compensatory shifts to maintain a stable gait and keep the sole of the foot flat on the ground.

While clinical observations have long suggested a link between knee alignment and foot posture, many previous studies relied on observation rather than precise radiographic data. This research seeks to quantify these morphological changes across the entire foot—from the hindfoot to the toes—and determine if the severity of knee varus directly correlates with specific types of foot and ankle pain.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study of 213 patients (213 knees) undergoing primary Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) for end-stage varus KOA at the Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University.

Patient recruitment flowchart and exclusion criteria.

Patients were divided into two groups based on their Hip-Knee-Ankle (HKA) angle:

  • Severe Varus Group: HKA ≤ 170°
  • Mild Varus Group: HKA > 170°
Measurement of the Hip-Knee-Ankle (HKA) angle on a weight-bearing radiograph.

The team used weight-bearing X-rays to measure parameters including the tibial anterior surface angle (TAS) and talar tilt (TT) for the ankle, the hindfoot alignment angle (HA), and forefoot metrics like the hallux valgus angle (HVA). Clinical assessments recorded the presence and specific locations of preoperative pain during walking.

Key Results and Insights

The study demonstrated that severe knee malalignment triggers a compensatory "domino effect" down the leg:

  • The Compensatory Tilt: As the knee bows out, the hindfoot tends to tilt into valgus (outward) to compensate. The study found a strong correlation between the severity of the knee deformity and the degree of this hindfoot tilt ($P<0.001$).
  • Ankle Osteoarthritis: The incidence of ankle osteoarthritis (AOA) was significantly higher in the severe varus group ($P=0.005$). Severe varus changes the loading profile of the ankle, leading to medial joint space narrowing and localized pain.
  • Forefoot Connection: Surprisingly, the impact extends to the toes. Patients in the severe group had significantly higher incidences of hallux valgus (bunions) ($P=0.028$), suggesting proximal malalignment influences distal forefoot mechanics.
  • Pain Profiles: Medial ankle pain and hindfoot pain were significantly more common in the severe group. Furthermore, these patients were more likely to report pain in two or more areas of the foot and ankle ($P=0.015$).

Discussion and Limitations

Pearson’s tests confirmed that the HKA angle is significantly correlated with ankle morphology, hindfoot alignment, and forefoot deformity. This suggests that end-stage KOA should be viewed as a multi-segmental condition rather than an isolated knee issue.

However, as a retrospective study, it cannot definitively prove causality. The findings are also specific to an Asian cohort with end-stage disease and relied on 2D radiographs. Future longitudinal studies are needed to determine if correcting knee alignment via TKA can reverse or stabilize these secondary foot and ankle issues.

Conclusion

Severe varus knee deformity is significantly associated with morphological changes in the foot and ankle, leading to higher rates of ankle OA and hallux valgus. Clinicians should consider the entire lower limb kinetic chain when evaluating and treating patients with severe knee osteoarthritis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Varus knee deformity was associated with morphological changes in the foot and ankle, and the incidence of ankle OA and hallux valgus deformity was significantly higher in patients with severe varus KOA. Patients with severe varus KOA were more prone to medial ankle pain, hindfoot pain, and multiple pain locations, which were associated with corresponding morphological changes.
BibTeX
@article{huang2025association,
  author = {Zhenchao Huang and Zian Zhang and Wenzhe Wang and Fan Chen and Haining Zhang},
  title = {{The association between varus knee deformity and morphological changes in the foot and ankle in patients with end-stage varus knee osteoarthritis}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-024-05433-0},
}
Figure