Abstract
Background: Retired status has strong associations with mental health factors and involves gender disparities. However, while retirement is known to affect the mental health of the elderly, large-scale studies examining the impact on mental health by gender are scarce. Methods: This cross-sectional study examined the data of 1,664 participants aged over 65 years old who completed the economic status and mental health sections of the 6-7th Korean National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys (2013–2017). We adjusted for covariates (health behavior, sociodemographic factors) in regression analysis for complex sampling design to calculate regression coefficients and 95% confidence intervals of the link between retired status and mental health. We also assessed which covariates of chronic disease, health behavior, and sociodemographic factors weakened the correlation between retired status and mental health. Results: Retired status in Korean populations has persisted to negatively impact the incidence of depressive symptoms and thoughts of suicide, even after adjusting for confounding variables. Regarding mental health, women were affected by retired status to a greater extent than men. Among covariates, health behaviors and sociodemographic factors were most affected by retired status. Women were more affected by household income, and men were more affected by drinking behaviors. Conclusions: These results imply that chronic diseases and psychological factors should be managed delicately among the retired elderly, and that there may be gender differences in retirement adaptation.
Introduction
As life expectancy increases globally, the transition into retirement has become a critical focal point for public health. While often envisioned as a period of well-earned rest, retirement frequently signals a significant loss of social function, identity, and the "ego" derived from professional life. In the specific cultural and economic context of South Korea—characterized by a relatively young retirement age and a lack of robust social safety nets—this transition is often experienced as a "stressful crisis" rather than a continuous life phase.
Previous research has linked retirement to physical decline and depression, yet many studies have failed to account for the confounding influence of chronic diseases or gender-specific responses. This study, published in Research Square, investigates the complex relationship between retirement, chronic disease, and mental health among the Korean elderly, highlighting a significant gender disparity in how this transition is navigated.
Methods and Data
The researchers utilized data from the 6th and 7th Korean National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys (KNHANES VI-VII, 2013–2017), a nationally representative survey conducted by the Ministry of Health and Welfare. The initial pool of 39,225 respondents was narrowed to 1,664 participants aged 65 and older.
To address inherent biases—such as the fact that employed and retired individuals may differ significantly in age or baseline health—the authors employed Propensity Score Matching (PSM). This technique matched 95 retired individuals with 475 employed individuals (a 1:5 ratio) based on similar baseline characteristics, ensuring a balanced comparison group.
Complex sample design regression analysis was used to calculate Odds Ratios (OR) across three models: unadjusted, age-adjusted (Model 1), and fully adjusted for factors including smoking, drinking, education, household income, physical activity, and comorbidities (Model 2).
Key Results
The study found that retirement is a significant predictor of worsened mental health, particularly regarding suicidal ideation and depressive symptoms.
- Gender-Specific Impact: The most striking finding was the disproportionate impact on women. After full adjustment (Model 2), retired women exhibited an Odds Ratio of 6.39 for suicidal ideation compared to their employed peers. This indicates a massive increase in risk that persists even when accounting for health and income.
- Chronic Disease Correlation: Interestingly, when adjusted for age and sociodemographics, retirement was not significantly correlated with the incidence of most chronic diseases (e.g., hypertension or diabetes). This suggests that the mental health decline is a primary psychological phenomenon, not merely a secondary effect of failing physical health.
Discussion
The authors contrast two sociological views of retirement: the Western "continuous phase" versus the Korean "stressful crisis." For the generation of Korean women studied, who often overcame significant patriarchal barriers to establish careers, the loss of professional status may represent a more profound blow to self-identity.
The study also identified key mediators that influenced the strength of the association between retirement and mental health:
- Income Buffer for Women: Household income was the most significant covariate for women, reducing the negative mental health impact of retirement by 22.8%, suggesting financial security is a primary mediator of adaptation.
- Lifestyle Mediators for Men: For men, drinking behavior was the most significant factor, indicating that social or coping behaviors play a larger role in their transition.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that chronic diseases and psychological factors must be managed with sensitivity among the retired elderly, with particular attention to gender differences in retirement adaptation. While the cross-sectional nature of the study limits definitive causal claims, the strong associations highlight a critical need for public policy interventions. Future longitudinal research is necessary to track individuals through the transition to better understand the mechanisms of decline and identify protective factors.
Summary updated