The association between leisure activity and mental health in the older adults in China: amazing Guangchangwu

Jiajun Yu, Ya-Ling Chiu, Sy‐Ming Guu, Jying‐Nan WangFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study examines the link between leisure activities and mental health among 2,006 older adults in China, finding that while walking and hiking are beneficial, Guangchangwu (square dancing) stands out as a "universal" booster. It is particularly effective for high-risk groups, including those with chronic illnesses, those living alone, and rural residents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China is facing a demographic "silver tsunami," with the population aged 60+ expected to reach 480 million by 2050. This rapid aging puts immense pressure on healthcare systems and social structures. While physical health is a common focus, the mental health of seniors—often plagued by loneliness, depression, and cognitive decline—is frequently overlooked.

The researchers sought to move beyond the general advice that "leisure is good" to identify which specific activities provide the most benefit for different subgroups. They specifically looked at the impact of chronic disease, living arrangements (living alone vs. with family), and geography (urban vs. rural) to help healthcare planners allocate limited resources more effectively.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional questionnaire survey in Suzhou, China.

  • Assessment Tool: They used the Geriatric Depression Scale short form (GDS-15), a 15-item "Yes/No" tool specifically designed to screen for depression in older adults. For this study, scores were converted into a "Mental Health Score" (higher scores = better mental health).
  • Statistical Analysis: The team employed two-sample t-tests and one-way ANOVA to compare mental health scores across different demographics and leisure habits.
  • Activities Tracked: The survey focused on five popular leisure activities: playing chess, walking, Guangchangwu, going to the gym, and hiking.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset collected from a community college and activity centers in Suzhou City.

  • Sample Size: 2,006 valid participants (from an initial 3,746 respondents).
  • Demographics: The sample was 72% female and 28% male, with a mean age distribution fairly even across the 55–70+ range.
  • Context: Most participants were urban (94%) and lived with family (89%), which the authors acknowledge as a potential source of bias.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Guangchangwu as a Cultural Anchor: Unlike solo gym workouts, Guangchangwu (square dancing) is deeply rooted in China’s collectivist culture. It provides a "sense of safety and belonging" by following a leader in a group setting, which may be more psychologically restorative than the physical exercise alone.
  • The Rural Specificity: Interestingly, for rural older adults, only square dancing showed a significantly positive association with mental health. The authors speculate that activities like hiking or walking might feel too much like the daily physical labor already common in rural life, whereas dancing offers a distinct social and "fun" departure from routine.
  • Buffering Chronic Illness: For seniors suffering from chronic diseases, three activities—walking, square dancing, and hiking—were significantly associated with better mental health. This suggests that "outdoor exercise attributes" are crucial for those managing long-term physical ailments.
  • Social Support vs. Solitude: Seniors living alone benefited significantly from square dancing and hiking. The "social support attribute" of these activities helps mitigate the loneliness often associated with living solo in a family-oriented society.

Key Results

  • General Health Status: Seniors without chronic diseases had significantly higher mental health scores (13.28) compared to those with chronic diseases (12.97, p < 0.001).
  • Urban vs. Rural: Urban residents scored higher (13.18) than rural residents (12.59, p = 0.010).
  • Activity Impact:
    • Guangchangwu: Showed strong positive associations across almost all categories (Chronic: p < 0.001; Living with family: p < 0.001; Rural: p < 0.001).
  • Hiking: Highly effective for those living alone (p = 0.012) and urban dwellers (p < 0.001).
  • Chess & Gym: These showed no significant association with improved mental health in this specific cohort, suggesting that for this demographic, social/outdoor movement outweighs sedentary or indoor solo exercise.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several key limitations:

  1. Causality: As a cross-sectional study, it cannot prove that dancing causes better mental health; it could be that seniors with better mental health are simply more likely to go out and dance.
  2. Sample Bias: The data comes from Suzhou, a highly developed city. The results might not perfectly translate to less developed or more diverse regions of China.
  3. Measurement Granularity: The survey used binary (Yes/No) questions for participation. It did not track the frequency (e.g., once a week vs. daily) or duration of the activities.

Future Work: The researchers suggest longitudinal studies to track mental health changes over time and more diverse sampling to account for regional cultural differences across China.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on our results, the government and healthcare planners can better allocate limited resources under different conditions to promote certain leisure activities, which are helpful to enhance the mental health of older adults. Guangchangwu is an activity that meets the characteristics of Chinese culture, so we further conclude that it is significantly associated with the good mental health of older adults in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2024association,
  author = {Jiajun Yu and Ya-Ling Chiu and Sy‐Ming Guu and Jying‐Nan Wang},
  title = {{The association between leisure activity and mental health in the older adults in China: amazing Guangchangwu}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1291809},
}
Figure