The Assessment of Spirituality Between Cancer and Chronic Inpatients: A Cross-Sectional Study

Yalan Liu, Hao Xue, Yan Li, Yulin Xia, Yilin WangResearch 2021 · DOI

Introduction

In the evolution of modern medicine, the focus has increasingly shifted from purely biological interventions to a holistic model of care. A critical, yet often overlooked, component of this model is spiritual well-being. Defined not necessarily by religious affiliation but by a sense of meaning, internal peace, and faith, spirituality serves as a vital protective factor for the quality of life in patients facing life-threatening illnesses.

While extensive research exists on spirituality in Western and urban contexts, there is a significant data gap regarding rural, lower-income populations in China. This study addresses that gap by examining inpatients in the northeast Chongqing region, comparing the spiritual burden of cancer against that of other chronic diseases.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey of 630 inpatients at Chongqing University Three Gorges Hospital between January and December 2020. The cohort consisted of 571 cancer patients and 59 patients with chronic endocrine diseases.

To quantify spiritual well-being, the study utilized the Chinese version of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Spiritual Well-Being (FACIT-Sp-12). This validated instrument measures three distinct domains:

  1. Meaning: The sense of purpose and significance in life.
  2. Peace: A state of internal harmony and the absence of spiritual struggle.
  3. Faith: The comfort derived from spiritual or philosophical beliefs.

The demographic profile of the participants was notably rural and low-income, with approximately 90% having a junior high school education or less, and over 70% reporting a monthly household income below 3,000 RMB.

Comparative Findings: The "Cancer Tax" on Spirituality

The study’s primary finding was a significant divergence in spiritual well-being between the two patient groups. Cancer patients reported a total FACIT-Sp-12 score of 33.3 ± 10.35, which was significantly lower than the 38.61 ± 10.88 reported by patients with other chronic diseases ($P < 0.001$).

This "spiritual hit" was evident across all three domains, but most pronounced in the Peace domain. The researchers suggest that the rapid progression, high recurrence risk, and existential threat associated with a cancer diagnosis create a unique psychological and spiritual burden that chronic conditions like diabetes may not trigger as acutely.

Predictors of Spiritual Well-Being

Beyond the diagnosis itself, the study identified several key demographic and psychological factors that influenced spiritual scores through multiple regression analysis:

  • Gender Differences: Male patients exhibited higher spiritual well-being than female patients ($\beta = -2.406, P < 0.01$). In the socio-economic context of rural Chongqing, the authors hypothesize that men—often having worked as migrant laborers or farmers—may possess a different type of life experience that fosters resilience. Conversely, women in these regions often carry heavier traditional family burdens and emotional labor, which may deplete spiritual reserves.
  • Personality Traits: Extraversion was a strong independent predictor of higher scores ($\beta = -1.421, P < 0.01$). Extraverted individuals were found to be more capable of adjusting their perspectives to find meaning and maintain internal peace during the stresses of treatment.
  • The Marital Anchor: A positive relationship with a spouse was significantly correlated with the "Meaning" domain. This suggests that for many patients, spiritual purpose is not an isolated internal state but is co-constructed through primary social bonds.
  • Secular Faith: Interestingly, while "Faith" was a measured domain, 97.2% of the cancer patients identified as having no formal religious affiliation. This indicates that "faith" in this population likely refers to broader secular philosophies, traditional values, or a general trust in the order of life.

Clinical Recommendations and Conclusion

The findings underscore that spiritual well-being in this population is at a "medium" level, influenced heavily by lower economic and educational status. The study suggests that current nursing and palliative care models must evolve to include targeted spiritual support.

Specifically, healthcare providers should prioritize spiritual interventions for female patients, introverted individuals, and those with strained marital relationships. Creating a harmonious doctor-patient environment is essential to improving the spiritual well-being of oncology patients in county regions.

Limitations

As a single-center, cross-sectional study, the results may not be fully generalizable to urban China or other global regions. Furthermore, the study did not account for cancer staging or concurrent psychological conditions like clinical depression, which could interact with spiritual scores. Future longitudinal research is needed to track how spirituality fluctuates throughout the trajectory of cancer treatment and survivorship.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract PurposeSpiritual well-being had protective effect on quality of life in cancer, due to the cultural, regional and custom differences,it was rarely been discussed between cancer and chronic diseases in Chongqing,China. We aimed at comparing the level of spirituality in two groups, and discussing its factors of subjects with cancer at county regions.MethodsA cross-sectional questionnaire survey was distributed to 630 inpatients who received treatment between January and December 2020 in Chongqing University Three Gorges Hospital.In addition to basic demographic data,spirituality was measured using the Chinese version of Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Spiritual Well-Being (FACIT-Sp-12). The mean,standard deviation,independent t-tests, ANOVA and multiple regression were used for statistical description and analysis.ResultsSignificant differences were found between cancer and chronic diseases in total scores of FACIT-Sp-12 and each domain( P &lt;0.05).The meaning, peace, faith and total scores in cancer were 11.21±3.38,10.66±4.46,11.43±3.54,and 33.3±10.35,respectively.Which were lower than chronic diseases (13.00±3.21,12.95±4.76,12.66±3.64,38.61±10.88,respectively). The spiritual well-being had significant differences in gender,character,and emotional with spouse for cancer ( P &lt;0.05).The male and extravert character were significantly associated with a greater spiritual well-being.ConclusionThe study shows a medium level of spiritual well-being in cancer, which stands the population with lower economic and education in county regions. It suggests that under the current nursing mode, we should provide specifically spiritual care to the female,introvert and those with poor relationship with spouses, and create a harmonious doctor-patient environment to improve the spiritual well-being.Retrospectively registeredJSCC-D-21-01528,17 Sep 2021
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021assessment,
  author = {Yalan Liu and Hao Xue and Yan Li and Yulin Xia and Yilin Wang},
  title = {{The Assessment of Spirituality Between Cancer and Chronic Inpatients: A Cross-Sectional Study}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-919064/v1},
}
Figure