Abstract
In PBN flight procedure design, in order to ensure the design quality, we need to evaluation the error of route parameters. Actual test is a good way, but it often requires large amounts of human, financial and other resources. In this paper, we use ArcGIS which has powerful data analysis function to assess the route parameter error, by comparative analysis of reverser's data and design data. The results show that the error assessment methods and conclusions of the final assessment of the actual test error coincide, the method can be used to evaluation the error of route parameters in PBN flight procedure design.
Introduction
Modern aviation is undergoing a significant paradigm shift from traditional ground-based navigation to Performance-Based Navigation (PBN). In the traditional model, aircraft navigate between physical radio beacons on the ground. PBN, however, leverages high-precision geographic coordinates (waypoints) stored in an aircraft's Flight Management System, allowing for more flexible and efficient flight paths.
Despite its advantages, PBN introduces new complexities in procedure design. Because the Earth is an oblate spheroid rather than a perfect sphere, calculating the shortest distance (great circle) and the correct heading between waypoints requires sophisticated algorithms. Small discrepancies in these calculations, often caused by variations in latitude and longitude or different mathematical models, can lead to errors in the final route parameters. Historically, the only reliable way to validate these parameters was through actual flight tests—a process that consumes significant fuel, personnel time, and aircraft resources. This study proposes using ArcGIS as a robust, low-cost digital "audit" tool to verify PBN flight procedures.
Methodology
The researchers utilized ArcGIS, a standard Geographic Information System (GIS), focusing on the ArcMap component and its Coordinate Geometry (COGO) extension. The evaluation process followed a structured workflow:
- Data Preparation: Flight procedure waypoints are typically published in Degrees-Minutes-Seconds (DMS) format. To facilitate processing in ArcMap, the authors used Excel to batch-convert this coordinate data into decimal degrees.
- Mapping and Visualization: The converted coordinates for a specific approach procedure at an airport in Southwest China were imported into the GIS environment. Ten key waypoints, labeled A1 through A10, were mapped to define the flight path.
- Inverse Calculation via COGO: The core of the methodology involves using the COGO toolset to perform an "inverse" analysis. By interacting with the mapped waypoints, the software calculates the precise direction (azimuth) and distance (leg length) between points based on the underlying geographic model. This provides an independent set of "actual" values to compare against the design specifications.
Results and Comparative Analysis
The study applied this methodology to a real-world approach procedure. The "inverse" data generated by ArcGIS was compared against the original PBN design parameters to determine the variance.
The comparison demonstrated remarkably high precision. The difference in heading (azimuth) was found to be only 0.001 degrees, with a variance of 0.000002 degrees. Similarly, the leg length difference was approximately 0.1 meters, with a variance of 0.028163 meters. These results indicate that the software-based evaluation aligns closely with the design intent. The minor discrepancies observed are well within the safety requirements for aviation procedures, proving that the ArcGIS method is a valid tool for error assessment.
Discussion and Conclusion
The primary insight of this research is the utility of GIS as an independent auditor for aviation mathematics. While GIS is often viewed primarily as a mapping tool, its geometric engine is uniquely suited to verify the complex spherical trigonometry required for PBN. By demonstrating that ArcGIS results coincide with the conclusions of actual flight tests, the authors show that much of the safety validation process can be moved into a virtual environment.
There are limitations to the current study. The term "reverser's data" used in the original abstract appears to be a translation of "inverse calculation data," and future work should clarify the specific mathematical models used by COGO versus design software. Additionally, while this study focuses on geometric parameters, future iterations could incorporate 3D obstacle clearance and terrain analysis.
In conclusion, the application of ArcGIS for evaluating PBN route parameters offers a cost-effective and highly accurate alternative to traditional flight testing, ensuring design quality while significantly reducing resource expenditure.
Summary updated