Abstract
The purpose of this study is to identify and analyze the application barriers and internal mechanisms of BIM technology in green building projects. It is found that BIM technology can effectively integrate information and optimize management, but its application still faces economic externalities and requires government intervention to promote its development. Through the analysis of five aspects of technology, economy, management, policy and environment, we identified 16 influencing factors and focused on nine key factors, such as insufficient technology maturity and high-cost issues. Research shows that policy and management factors play a fundamental role in BIM adoption and influence economic effectiveness through complex interactions. Based on the ISM-ANP coupling model, we propose that the government should encourage technological innovation and personnel training to promote the effective application of BIM technology in green buildings. This study provides a theoretical reference for the application of BIM and green building on a global scale.
Introduction
Green building has become a critical component of global carbon neutrality goals. Building Information Modeling (BIM) serves as the ideal digital backbone for managing the complex data required for sustainable design and construction. However, in many major markets, BIM adoption remains in its infancy. The challenge is not merely that BIM is expensive or technically demanding; rather, the barriers—technological, economic, and regulatory—are deeply interconnected.
This study, originally published in Scientific Reports, moves beyond a simple list of problems to reveal the hidden causal chain preventing sustainable technology from going mainstream. By addressing the lack of a systematic, hierarchical understanding of these obstacles, the research identifies which barriers are "roots" and which are merely "leaves" in the complex ecosystem of green construction.
Methodology
The researchers employed a sophisticated three-stage methodology to map the relationships between 16 critical barriers identified through literature review and expert interviews.
- Factor Identification: 47 potential barriers were distilled to 16 through semi-structured interviews with 10 industry experts.
- DEMATEL-optimized ISM (Interpretive Structural Modeling): This approach quantified the strength of relationships between factors, allowing for the construction of a multi-level hierarchy or "structural map."
- ANP (Analytic Network Process): Unlike simpler models, ANP accounts for feedback loops between factors, enabling the calculation of precise importance weights.
The study utilized primary data from an expert panel and an industry survey of 179 professionals, providing a robust foundation for the direct impact matrices used in the modeling process.
Key Insights and Results
The analysis revealed a clear distinction between "symptoms" and "root causes." While high additional costs (S5) and low investment returns (S6) are the most visible obstacles, the model places them at the top level (L1) of the hierarchy. This indicates they are resultant factors—outcomes of deeper systemic failures.
The Foundational Layer
Policy-level factors, such as imperfect legal support (S12) and a lack of standards (S14), sit at the base of the hierarchy. These "root" factors exert a pervasive influence on all other barriers. The Policy incentive mechanism (S13) emerged with one of the highest importance weights (0.107), confirming that market forces alone are insufficient to drive adoption without external government "nudges."
The Talent Bottleneck
A critical finding is the role of the talent gap. The lack of interdisciplinary "composite" talents (S15) acts as a bridge between management and technology. Without professionals who understand both green building physics and BIM software, the theoretical economic benefits of the technology remain unrealized.
The Action Path
The research summarizes the failure chain as follows: Insufficient government intervention → Weak management support → Stagnant R&D → High costs → Blocked adoption.
Conclusion
The study concludes that targeted government intervention and interdisciplinary talent cultivation are essential to break the cycle of low ROI and stagnant innovation. While high costs are the primary concern for practitioners, they are a paradox that can only be resolved by removing foundational policy and management barriers.
While the data is rooted in the Chinese construction market, the ISM-ANP methodology is universally applicable. Future research should focus on cross-country comparisons and quantitative models to measure the specific impact of different policy instruments, such as tax breaks versus direct subsidies, on adoption rates over time.
Summary updated