The aporetic dialogs of Modena on gender differences: Is it all about testosterone? Episode III: Mathematics

Giulia Brigante, Francesco Costantino, Alessio Bellelli, Stefano Boni, Chiara Furini, Rita Cucchiara, Manuela SimoniAndrology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the long-standing question of whether testosterone is the primary driver of gender differences in mathematical abilities. Through a Socratic dialogue format, it presents evidence for and against this hypothesis, ultimately suggesting that socio-cultural factors and stereotypes play a more significant role than biological factors like testosterone.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the persistent observation of a gender gap in STEM fields, particularly in mathematics, where men are often perceived as having a natural advantage. While this perception is widespread, the paper questions its underlying causes, specifically investigating the extent to which testosterone, a key male sex hormone, contributes to these differences in mathematical aptitude. It aims to move beyond simplistic explanations by exploring a multidisciplinary perspective, considering both biological and socio-cultural influences.

Methods

The paper employs a unique "Socratic aporetic dialogue" format. This involves a structured discussion among experts where a central question is posed, and then debated from opposing viewpoints. The discussants present evidence and arguments to support their respective theses, leading to a state of "aporia" (puzzlement) rather than a definitive conclusion. An expert referee then attempts to synthesize the arguments. The evidence presented relies on a review of existing scientific literature, including meta-analyses, observational studies, and clinical trials.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on a review of existing literature and data from previously published studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "aporetic dialogue" as a research tool: This format effectively highlights the complexity and nuances of a scientific question by presenting contrasting viewpoints and challenging assumptions.
  • Testosterone's role is complex and not definitively causal: While some studies suggest a correlation between testosterone and certain cognitive functions (like spatial abilities), the evidence for a direct causal link to mathematical aptitude is inconsistent and often based on small sample sizes.
  • Socio-cultural factors are powerful influencers: The paper strongly emphasizes the impact of gender stereotypes, social norms, and educational environments in shaping beliefs about mathematical abilities and influencing career choices.
  • "Extreme male brain theory" and ASD: The discussion touches upon Baron-Cohen's theory linking higher testosterone levels to "systemizing" (a trait associated with mathematics) and its potential role in autism spectrum disorders, but notes this is a complex area with ongoing research.
  • The "scissors trend" in STEM careers: Data shows that while women are well-represented in STEM education, their progression into senior academic and professional roles significantly lags behind men, suggesting systemic barriers beyond innate ability.

Key Results

  • Mathematical abilities are multifaceted: The paper defines mathematical abilities as a combination of innate and acquired skills, including subitizing, estimation, symbolic representation, mental number line, enumeration, and arithmetic.
  • Gender gap in STEM participation: Data indicates a clear male predominance in STEM education and careers, particularly at advanced levels. For instance, in the Italian Mathematics Olympics, only 4 women won out of 120 participants in recent years.
  • Inconsistent findings on testosterone: Studies on individuals with conditions like congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) and testosterone replacement therapy in older men yielded mixed results regarding the impact of androgens on spatial and mathematical abilities. Some showed no improvement or even poorer performance in certain groups.
  • Stereotypes are deeply ingrained: Research on how language and social cues influence perceptions of gender and ability suggests that even subtle phrasing can perpetuate the stereotype that boys are naturally more skilled in mathematics.
  • No clear winner declared: The referee concludes that the arguments for socio-cultural factors and stereotypes being more persuasive in explaining gender differences in mathematics than testosterone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small sample sizes in some studies: The paper acknowledges the limitation of studies with small participant numbers, which can affect the statistical robustness of findings.
  • Social bias in historical data: The referee points out that older studies, like Benbow's (1988), may be influenced by the social biases prevalent at the time.
  • Difficulty in designing controlled experiments: The paper notes the challenge of designing definitive experiments to prove a causal link between testosterone and cognitive abilities due to ethical and practical constraints.
  • Need for larger, longitudinal studies: The authors implicitly suggest the need for more extensive research to confirm or refute the proposed hypotheses.
  • Further exploration of socio-cultural impacts: The paper highlights the importance of continued research into how stereotypes and educational environments shape gender differences in STEM.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report is the transcript of what was discussed in a convention at the Endocrinology Unit in Modena, Italy, in the form of the aporetic dialogs of ancient Greece. It is the third episode of a series of four discussions on the differences between males and females, with a multidisciplinary approach. In this work, the role of testosterone in gender differences in the aptitude for mathematics is explored. First, the definitions of mathematical abilities were provided together with any gender difference in the distribution of females and males in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics subjects. A clear predominance of males is evident at most science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education levels, especially in advanced academic careers. Then, the discussants were divided into two groups: group 1, which illustrated the thesis that testosterone promotes the development of logical‒mathematical skills, and group 2, which, in contrast, asserted the inconsistency of a direct role of testosterone in improving cognitive abilities and that socio-cultural factors should be considered on the basis of this gender gap. In the end, an expert referee (a female engineer) tried to resolve the aporia: are the two theories equivalent or is one superior?
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brigante2025aporetic,
  author = {Giulia Brigante and Francesco Costantino and Alessio Bellelli and Stefano Boni and Chiara Furini and Rita Cucchiara and Manuela Simoni},
  title = {{The aporetic dialogs of Modena on gender differences: Is it all about testosterone? Episode III: Mathematics}},
  booktitle = {Andrology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1111/andr.70104},
}
Figure