The Analysis of Carbon Emission’s Characteristics and Dynamic Evolution Based on the Strategy of Unbalanced Regional Economic Development in China

Quan Guo, Zijing Liang, Xiang Bai, Mengnan Lv, Anying ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the complex interplay between China's regional economic development strategies and carbon emissions. It reveals distinct regional patterns in carbon emission evolution, highlighting the significant role of education in mitigation and the concerning "deterioration" of industrial structure in driving emissions. These findings are crucial for developing targeted, region-specific emission reduction policies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, as a major global emitter and rapidly developing economy, faces immense pressure to reduce its carbon footprint. However, its long-standing strategy of unbalanced regional economic development has created significant disparities across its eastern, central, and western regions. This paper aims to untangle how these regional development strategies influence carbon emission patterns and identify the key drivers behind these differences. Understanding these dynamics is essential for crafting effective, nuanced policies that address the unique challenges and opportunities within each region, moving beyond a one-size-fits-all approach to emission reduction.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted methodological approach:

  • Spatial Panel Model: Used to investigate the causes of differences in carbon emissions across regions, accounting for spatial dependencies.
  • Non-parametric Models: Applied to analyze the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) for per capita carbon emissions, revealing regional variations in the relationship between economic growth and emissions.
  • Logarithmic Mean Divisia Index (LMDI) Model: Utilized to decompose the influencing factors of carbon emissions, allowing for a detailed analysis of how different drivers contribute to emission changes.
  • Extended STIRPAT Model: Employed to examine the impact of population-related factors (scale, age structure, household quantity, education level) on carbon emissions.
  • Threshold Panel Model: Investigated the non-linear relationship between energy efficiency and carbon emissions, identifying potential thresholds for economic growth and technology investment.
  • 3E Coordination Evaluation System: Developed to assess the integrated development of Energy, Economy, and Environment, providing a framework for regional classification.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 2007 to 2020, primarily sourced from:

  • China Energy Statistics Yearbook
  • China Statistical Yearbook
  • China Labor Statistics Yearbook
  • China Science and Technology Statistics Yearbook
  • China Population and Employment Statistics Yearbook
  • China Foreign Economic Statistics Yearbook
  • Statistical yearbooks of corresponding years in 30 provinces, municipalities, and autonomous regions.

The data included energy consumption, economic indicators (GDP, industrial structure), population statistics, and environmental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regional EKC Divergence: While the eastern region mirrors the national "N"-shaped EKC, the central and western regions exhibit an "upside-down U" pattern. This suggests that while these regions are industrializing, they are also effectively managing high energy consumption and emissions, potentially due to government intervention.
  • Education as a Powerful Reducer: Higher education levels consistently and significantly suppress carbon emissions across all regions. This underscores the importance of human capital development in climate mitigation efforts.
  • Industrial Structure "Deterioration": A surprising finding is the positive correlation between the tertiary industry structure and carbon emissions. This indicates a trend of "deterioration," where the shift towards services might be accompanied by an increase in energy-intensive activities or a decline in the efficiency of the industrial sector.
  • 3E Coordination Imbalance: The environmental subsystem shows the lowest degree of coordination, indicating that environmental protection is not keeping pace with economic development, particularly in the western regions.

Key Results

  • A 1% increase in the proportion of educated individuals (college and above) leads to emission reductions of 0.22% (east), 0.51% (central), and 0.44% (west).
  • The study found that the tertiary industry structure has a positive effect on carbon emissions, suggesting a worsening trend.
  • The spatial econometric model indicated that industrial structure has a significant direct and general effect (10%) on carbon emissions, with rising weights of high energy-consumption industries.
  • Population growth, age structure, and household quantity positively contribute to CO2 emissions, while education level has a significantly inhibitory effect.
  • Energy efficiency, coupled with economic growth and technological improvement, can gradually suppress carbon emissions, but this relationship is not always linear and can be influenced by thresholds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Double Carbon" Target Omission: The study acknowledges that China's current approach to reducing emissions is heavily influenced by the "double carbon" target (peak carbon by 2030, carbon neutrality by 2060), which was not extensively discussed in this paper. This limits the policy recommendations' direct alignment with this overarching national strategy.
  • Policy Recommendation Direction: The authors note that the policy recommendations lack some direction due to the omission of the "double carbon" target discussion.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that future studies should focus on the achievement of the carbon peak target and its impact on the economy and social welfare under total control measures. They also propose further investigation into the dynamic evolution of carbon emissions and the effectiveness of various policy interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Analyzing the evolution law of carbon emissions is particularly important for the designation of policies on energy conservation and emission reduction. Based on the regional division of China, this paper uses a spatial panel model to find the causes of the differences in carbon emission, and the non-parametric model, logarithmic mean Divisia index (LMDI) model and the extended STIRPAT model to analyze the relevant influencing factors in detail. From the studies in this paper, there come the following conclusions: (1) The environmental Kuznets curve (EKC) in the eastern region resembles the national EKC, demonstrating the same “N” pattern. However, the “upside-down U” pattern in the middle and western regions not only confirms the assumption of EKC in some Chinese regions but also demonstrates the effective restraint in high energy consumption and high emission levels when narrowing down the gaps between the central and western regions and the eastern regions. (2) In addition, good education can effectively suppress the increase in carbon emission, and every 1% increase in the proportion of educated people (college and above) results in emission reduction, respectively, by 0.22%, 0.51% and 0.44% in the eastern, central and western regions of China. (3) Significantly, the effect of tertiary industry structure on carbon emissions is positive, reflecting the trend of “deterioration” of China’s industrial structure over long time scales. This study functions positively in understanding the evolutionary pattern of regional carbon emissions and proposing differentiated policies on emission reduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022analysis,
  author = {Quan Guo and Zijing Liang and Xiang Bai and Mengnan Lv and Anying Zhang},
  title = {{The Analysis of Carbon Emission’s Characteristics and Dynamic Evolution Based on the Strategy of Unbalanced Regional Economic Development in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14148417},
}
Figure