The Air Products Vattenfall Oxyfuel CO2 Compression and Purification Pilot Plant at Schwarze Pumpe

Vince White, Andrew D. Wright, Stephanie Tappe, Jinyue YanEnergy 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the initial results from the world's first pilot plant for oxyfuel CO2 compression and purification, a crucial step towards cost-effective carbon capture from coal-fired power plants. The pilot successfully demonstrated key technologies like "sour compression" and auto-refrigeration, showing promising SO2 and NOx removal efficiencies and paving the way for larger-scale demonstration plants.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Capturing CO2 from industrial processes, particularly coal-fired power plants, is essential for mitigating climate change. Oxyfuel combustion, which burns fuel in pure oxygen instead of air, produces a flue gas with a much higher concentration of CO2, simplifying capture. However, this flue gas also contains impurities like sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) that can be corrosive and problematic for downstream CO2 purification and compression. Existing flue gas treatment methods can be expensive and energy-intensive. This paper addresses the challenge of efficiently and cost-effectively removing these impurities from the raw CO2 stream generated by an oxyfuel boiler, specifically at the Schwarze Pumpe pilot plant.

Methods

The core of the Air Products-Vattenfall Oxyfuel CO2 Compression and Purification Pilot Plant (ACPP) utilizes three key technologies:

  • Sour Compression: This novel process integrates SO2 and NOx removal directly into the compression stages. The theory is that during compression, SO2 and NOx react to form acids, which can then be managed and removed. This approach aims to reduce the need for separate, expensive upstream flue gas cleaning. The process involves a two-stage diaphragm compressor with interstage cooling and condensate knockout, followed by two packed columns for acid removal and further compression to 30 bar.
  • Auto-Refrigerated Partial Condensation: After compression and drying, the CO2 is purified at low temperatures. This process uses the CO2 product itself as a refrigerant, a significant innovation for oxyfuel plants that promises substantial power savings compared to conventional refrigeration cycles. This step aims to separate atmospheric gases like nitrogen, oxygen, and argon.
  • Membrane Recovery: A PRISM® membrane system is employed to recover CO2 from the inert vent stream, further increasing overall CO2 capture efficiency. A beneficial side effect is the co-recovery of oxygen, which can be returned to the boiler, reducing the demand on the air separation unit.

The experimental program was divided into phases, with Phase 3 focusing on parametric testing of the "warm-end" (flue gas cooler/condenser and SO2/NOx removal columns). This involved varying gas and liquid flows, feed SO2 concentration, temperatures, and pressures to map system performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental results from a pilot plant.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sour Compression's Effectiveness: The pilot plant demonstrated that the "sour compression" process is effective in removing significant amounts of SO2 and NOx, validating the underlying theory. This integrated approach has the potential to simplify and reduce the cost of CO2 capture.
  • Importance of NOx for SO2 Removal: The results highlight that NOx plays a crucial role in the removal of SO2 during the sour compression process. An over-emphasis on NOx reduction during combustion could negatively impact the efficiency of this CO2 capture technology.
  • Pressure Sensitivity: SO2 removal is significantly influenced by pressure. Lower pressures in the 15-bar column led to reduced SO2 removal, underscoring the importance of maintaining optimal operating pressures.
  • Residence Time Matters: Increasing the residence time in the 15-bar column, achieved by reducing flow rate, directly correlates with higher SO2 conversion, demonstrating the kinetic nature of the reactions.
  • Water as a Reactant: Make-up water is a reactant in the sour compression process, and increasing its flow rate, especially under high sulfur conditions, significantly improves SO2 removal. This suggests a complex interplay of dissolution and chemical reaction.
  • NOx to N2O Conversion: A concerning finding is the potential for NOx to convert into N2O under certain conditions, particularly at high SO2/NOx ratios. This requires further investigation.

Key Results

  • SO2 Removal: Significant SO2 removal was observed across the sour compression process, with an initial 10-20% reduction in the flue gas cooler condenser. Further removal occurred in the 15-bar compressor and column.
  • NOx Removal: Approximately 80% of NOx was removed by the exit of the 15-bar column, with the remainder eliminated in the 30-bar column.
  • Parametric Testing:
    • SO2 removal decreased with an increasing SO2/NOx ratio in the feed.
  • Lower pressure in the 15-bar column resulted in reduced SO2 removal.
  • Doubling the residence time in the 15-bar column roughly doubled SO2 removal.
  • Increasing make-up water flowrate significantly improved SO2 removal, especially at high SO2 concentrations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Operation: The paper notes that only limited operation of the pilot plant had occurred at the time of writing, and further testing is planned.
  • NOx to N2O Conversion: The conversion of NOx to N2O under specific conditions is a significant area for future research and understanding.
  • Further Parametric Testing: The authors plan to continue parametric testing on the "warm-end" of the pilot plant to gain a deeper understanding of SO2 and NOx chemistry and to support process modeling.
  • Demonstration Plant Design: The data collected from this pilot plant is crucial for the design and optimization of future demonstration plants.

The results are described as "very encouraging" and supportive of the sour compression theory, indicating a positive step towards more efficient and cost-effective CO2 capture technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Air Products has in the last couple of years been working with Vattenfall to realise the ambition of building the world's frist coplete pilot of the technology that would be use to purify the raw CO2 from a commercial-scale coal-fired oxyfuel boiler. The pilot demonstrates three concepts that will together lead to an optimised, lowest cost, highest efficiency oxyfuel CO2 capture plant: sour compression, auto-refrigeration and membrane recovery of CO2 and O2 from the vent stream. This pilot plant will allow important data to be collected to assist in the design and optimisation of the next step: a demonstration plant. The technology supplied by Air Products was one of several technologies being evaluated by Vattenfall for the oxyfuel demonstration project that had been proposed in Jänschwalde, Germany. The agreed test program between Vattenfall and Air Products contains a number of identified R&D topics. The main results from the first tests will be presented in this paper. These initial tests involve establishing material and energy balances over the different main plant components as a first step. This will be continued by parametric testing on the warm-end of the pilot plant over the flue gas cooler/condenser and acid removal columns with the main goal of understanding the influence of these parameters on the SO2 and NOx chemistry and support process modelling activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{white2013air,
  author = {Vince White and Andrew D. Wright and Stephanie Tappe and Jinyue Yan},
  title = {{The Air Products Vattenfall Oxyfuel CO2 Compression and Purification Pilot Plant at Schwarze Pumpe}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1016/j.egypro.2013.06.024},
}
Figure