The Aestheticization of the Politics of Landscape Preservation

James S. Duncan, Nancy DuncanAnnals 2001 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that in affluent suburban communities like Bedford, New York, the aestheticization of landscape preservation, driven by romantic ideals and a desire for social distinction, functions as a subtle yet powerful mechanism for social exclusion. By framing land use decisions around "beauty" and "nature," these communities mask underlying class-based power dynamics and limit opportunities for affordable housing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the question of how seemingly benign aesthetic preferences and environmentalist concerns in affluent suburban communities can mask and perpetuate social and economic exclusion. They observe that in places like Bedford, New York, the preservation of landscapes and the creation of nature preserves are not merely about protecting nature but are deeply intertwined with the performance of elite social identities and the maintenance of class distinctions. This aestheticization of place mystifies class relations, reducing them to matters of taste and lifestyle, and diverts attention from issues of social justice, particularly the scarcity of affordable housing. The paper aims to "repoliticize" these naturalized categories and reveal how aesthetic discourse can serve hegemonic interests.

Methods

The research employs a qualitative, hermeneutic approach, drawing on a combination of methods:

  • In-depth Interviews: Over two hundred structured and semi-structured interviews were conducted with a diverse socioeconomic cross-section of residents in Bedford and surrounding towns, including long-term and recent arrivals, town officials, members of town organizations, and real estate agents. Questions focused on residents' values, perceptions of change, reasons for moving, views on land development and preservation, and the impact of zoning.
  • Textual Analysis: A variety of written materials were analyzed, including town histories, planning texts, real estate advertisements, and newspaper articles.
  • Landscape Analysis: The physical landscape itself was treated as a text, interpreted as a site where social and political meanings are inscribed and read by residents.

The authors emphasize their focus on "everyday ideological practices and taken-for-granted ideas" that support existing power structures, rather than solely on overt strategizing or coercion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research relies on primary data collected through interviews and analysis of local texts and landscapes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aestheticization as Mystification: The paper's central argument is that the focus on aesthetics in landscape preservation (e.g., "beauty," "picturesque views") serves to obscure and mystify class relations and power dynamics.
  • Landscapes as Cultural Capital: Landscapes in places like Bedford are not just backdrops but become "possessions" and "scarce positional goods" that are actively used to perform and maintain elite social identities.
  • Exclusionary Zoning as Preservation: Highly restrictive zoning and the creation of nature preserves, while framed as environmental protection, are effectively mechanisms for social exclusion, limiting housing options and reinforcing existing class structures.
  • Romantic Ideology and Anti-Urbanism: The paper highlights the role of romantic ideology, localism, antiurbanism, and a class-based aesthetic in constructing the idea of "wild" nature and justifying preservation efforts.
  • "Sense of Place" as a Tool: The concept of a "unique sense of place" is presented as a positive goal that can mask exclusionary practices and "spatial purification."
  • Alienation from Social Justice: The authors argue that the aesthetic appreciation of nature can lead to an alienation from social justice issues, as the focus shifts to the perceived inherent value of natural landscapes rather than their role in broader social and economic systems.
  • The "New American Garden" and "Wild Gardens": The paper connects the aestheticization of nature to contemporary trends like the "new American garden" and the concept of "wild gardens" at a larger scale, suggesting these are managed spaces reflecting specific aesthetic and class values.

Key Results

The study reveals that in Bedford, the dominant discourse surrounding landscape preservation is deeply aestheticized and serves to reinforce elite social identities and exclusionary practices.

  • Dominance of Aesthetic Values: Residents overwhelmingly prioritize aesthetic concerns (e.g., preserving views, maintaining a "look of the land") over other considerations, including social justice or affordable housing.
  • Zoning as a Barrier: The town's highly restrictive zoning, requiring large lot sizes (minimum four acres) and making development prohibitively expensive, effectively prevents the construction of affordable housing.
  • Nature Preserves as Visual Barriers: While some see preserves as places for recreation, many view them instrumentally as visual barriers that restrict development and maintain property values and the town's aesthetic character.
  • "Wilderness" as a Class-Based Construct: The concept of "wilderness" in Bedford is not a purely natural phenomenon but a class-based aesthetic construct, often applied to land that is less economically valuable or has been managed for centuries.
  • Mystification of Interdependencies: Residents tend to compartmentalize issues, believing their town's actions have few consequences for surrounding areas, thus overlooking the broader social and economic implications of their exclusionary practices.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Elite Communities: The authors acknowledge that their study primarily focuses on elite communities, which may influence the findings regarding the pervasiveness of aestheticized exclusion. They suggest that standpoint theory might reveal different perspectives from more oppressed groups.
  • Complexity of Hegemony: While the paper argues for the effectiveness of hegemonic ideas, it also notes that hegemony is "fragile, fragmented, and occasional superficiality," and the extent to which dominant ideas go unquestioned is an empirical question.
  • Future Directions: The paper implicitly calls for a more critical engagement with concepts like "place," "locality," and "localism" to understand how they are being refortified as conservative forces in the face of globalization. It also suggests the need to move beyond a purely aesthetic appreciation of nature towards a more thorough understanding of biophysical-human networks and the interconnectedness of social justice and environmental issues.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article examines the aestheticization of the politics of exclusion in a suburban American community. The research for this study focuses on the relationships among landscapes, social identity, exclusion, and the aesthetic attitudes of residents of Bedford, New York. By being thoroughly aestheticized, class relations are mystified and reduced to questions of lifestyle, consumption patterns, taste, and visual pleasure. Landscapes become possessions that play an active role in the performance of elite social identities. As such, social distinction is achieved and maintained by preserving and enhancing the beauty of places such as Bedford. This aestheticizing of place is managed through highly restrictive zoning policies for residential land and by “protecting” hundreds of acres of undeveloped land as nature preserves. This article explores the role of romantic ideology, localism, antiurbanism, antimodernism, and a class-based aesthetic in the construction of “wild” nature in these preserves. We argue that, in places such as Bedford, the celebration of localism, environmental beauty, and preservation mask the interrelatedness of issues of aesthetics and class identity on the one hand and residential land shortages in the New York metropolitan region on the other. The seemingly innocent pleasure in the aesthetic appreciation of landscapes and the desire to protect nature can act as a subtle but highly effective mechanism of social exclusion and the reaffirmation of elite class identities.
BibTeX
@article{duncan2001aestheticization,
  author = {James S. Duncan and Nancy Duncan},
  title = {{The Aestheticization of the Politics of Landscape Preservation}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1111/0004-5608.00250},
}
Figure