The adhesion of clots in wounds contributes to hemostasis and can be enhanced by coagulation factor XIII

Karen Y. T. Chan, Alyssa S. M. Yong, Xu Wang, Kristyn M. Ringgold, Alexander E. St. John, James R. Baylis, Nathan J. White, Christian J. KastrupScientific 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the adhesive failure of blood clots is a significant contributor to rebleeding and reduced survival in wound healing. They demonstrate that coagulation factor XIII (FXIII) plays a crucial role in enhancing clot adhesion to wound tissues, suggesting FXIII as a potential therapeutic target for improving hemostasis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving hemostasis, the process of stopping bleeding, relies on blood clots forming a seal over injured blood vessels. While we understand that clots can fail internally (cohesive failure), it's less clear how effectively they adhere to the wound site and what happens when this adhesion fails (adhesive failure). This adhesive failure can lead to rebleeding, especially under increased blood pressure (e.g., during fluid resuscitation in trauma patients), exacerbating blood loss and negatively impacting survival. The authors aimed to quantify the contribution of adhesive failure to rebleeding and identify the underlying mechanisms that govern clot adhesion to wound tissues.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Rat Femoral Artery Injury Model: This in vivo model simulated severe hemorrhage by incising a rat's femoral artery. They then monitored clot formation, rebleeding events (categorized as adhesive or cohesive failure), blood loss, and survival time. Topical FXIII was administered to assess its impact on these outcomes.
  • Lap-Shear Test (in vitro): This mechanical test was used to quantify the adhesive strength of blood clots to collagen-coated surfaces, mimicking a wound bed. They systematically varied the concentrations of key blood components like platelets, fibrinogen, and FXIII to understand their influence on adhesion.
  • Thrombelastography (TEG): This standard clinical technique was used to measure clot stiffness (shear elastic modulus), providing a measure of cohesive strength.
  • Transmission Spectrometry: Used to assess clot lysis kinetics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on experimental data generated from animal models and in vitro assays.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adhesive Failure is a Major Player: Contrary to assumptions, adhesive failure wasn't a minor issue; it accounted for a substantial portion (51 ± 14%) of rebleeding events in their rat model. This highlights a critical vulnerability in clot sealing.
  • FXIII is Key for Adhesion, Not Just Cohesion: While FXIII is known to strengthen clots (cohesion), this study strongly implicates it in enhancing the adhesion of clots to wound surfaces. This is a novel insight into FXIII's multifaceted role.
  • Stiffness ≠ Adhesion: The study demonstrates that clot stiffness (cohesive strength) and adhesive strength are not directly correlated. Platelets, for instance, dramatically increase stiffness but have a more modest impact on adhesion, while FXIII significantly boosts adhesion with only moderate increases in stiffness. This decouples two important aspects of clot function.
  • Substrate Matters: Whole blood clots adhered better to extracellular matrix proteins like collagen, fibronectin, and laminin compared to plain glass, underscoring the importance of the wound environment in clot integration.

Key Results

  • In the rat model, the frequency of rebleeding events correlated negatively with survival time (R = -0.89) and positively with cumulative blood loss (R = 0.81).
  • Adhesive failures constituted 51 ± 14% of rebleeds in untreated rats.
  • In vitro, clot adhesion to collagen was significantly enhanced by increasing concentrations of fibrinogen and FXIII.
  • Supraphysiological concentrations of FXIII led to a 3-fold increase in adhesive strength compared to a lower physiological concentration.
  • Topical FXIII administration in rats reduced the incidence of adhesive failures (11 vs. 17 in controls) and tended to decrease cumulative blood loss and increase survival, though these differences did not reach statistical significance in this sample size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size in vivo: The authors acknowledge that the in vivo study with topical FXIII had a small sample size (n=8 per group), leading to non-statistically significant differences. They suggest larger sample sizes and studies using FXIII knockout models for future investigations.
  • Static vs. Dynamic Conditions: The in vitro adhesion tests were performed in a static system. The authors note that platelets might play a more significant role in mediating initial attachment and clot formation under flow conditions, which was not tested here.
  • Clot Contraction: While clot contraction is likely important for adhesion, it was not directly tested in this study. Future work could explore this aspect.
  • Therapeutic Potential: The findings strongly suggest FXIII as a therapeutic target for hemorrhage. Future research could focus on optimizing FXIII delivery and dosage for clinical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The adhesion of blood clots to wounds is necessary to seal injured vasculature and achieve hemostasis. However, it has not been specifically tested if adhesive failure of clots is a major contributor to rebleeding and what mechanisms prevent clot delamination. Here, we quantified the contribution of adhesive and cohesive failure to rebleeding in a rat model of femoral artery injury, and identified mechanisms that contribute to the adhesive strength of bulk clots in a lap-shear test in vitro. In the rat bleeding model, the frequency of clot failures correlated positively with blood loss (R = 0.81, p = 0.014) and negatively with survival time (R = - 0.89, p = 0.0030), with adhesive failures accounting for 51 ± 14% of rebleeds. In vitro, adhesion depended on fibrinogen and coagulation factor XIII (FXIII), and supraphysiological FXIII improved adhesive strength. Furthermore, when exogenous FXIII was topically applied into the wound pocket of rats, eleven adhesive failures occurred between eight rats, compared to seventeen adhesive failures between eight untreated rats, whereas the number of cohesive failures remained the same at sixteen in both groups. In conclusion, rebleeding from both adhesive and cohesive failure of clots decreases survival from hemorrhage in vivo. Both endogenous and exogenous FXIII improves the adhesive strength of clots.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chan2020adhesion,
  author = {Karen Y. T. Chan and Alyssa S. M. Yong and Xu Wang and Kristyn M. Ringgold and Alexander E. St. John and James R. Baylis and Nathan J. White and Christian J. Kastrup},
  title = {{The adhesion of clots in wounds contributes to hemostasis and can be enhanced by coagulation factor XIII}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-76782-z},
}
Figure