The acoustics of mangetti dune !xung clicks

Amanda Miller, Sheena ShahInterspeech 2009

TL;DR

This paper investigates the acoustic properties of the four coronal clicks in Mangetti Dune !Xung, a Khoisan language. By analyzing burst duration, amplitude, and spectral characteristics, the researchers reveal inter-speaker variations, particularly in the palatal click, and establish correlations between these acoustic features, offering insights into the articulatory dynamics of these complex sounds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clicks are a fascinating class of consonants found in several Southern African languages, but their acoustic and articulatory mechanisms are complex and not fully understood. While the International Phonetic Association (IPA) recognizes four basic coronal click types (dental, alveolar, lateral alveolar, and palatal), there's ongoing research into their precise acoustic realization and how these realizations vary across speakers and languages. This paper specifically addresses the acoustic characteristics of these four clicks in Mangetti Dune !Xung, a dialect of !Xung, aiming to document these sounds and explore variations in their production, particularly the palatal click, which has shown significant inter-speaker variability in previous studies. The authors also seek to understand the relationships between different acoustic measures (like burst duration, amplitude, and rise time) and how these might reflect underlying articulatory differences.

Methods

The researchers employed standard phonetic recording and analysis techniques. Fifteen repetitions of a wordlist containing the four M. D. !Xung clicks were recorded from four native speakers (two male, two female) using a high-quality microphone and recording setup. The audio data was then analyzed using the Praat software. Key acoustic parameters were meticulously labeled and measured:

  • Burst Duration: The time from the beginning to the end of the click burst.
  • Rise Time: The time it takes for the burst amplitude to reach its peak.
  • Burst Amplitude: The intensity of the click burst, often normalized relative to the following vowel.
  • Center of Gravity (COG): A spectral measure indicating the distribution of energy across frequencies in the click burst, which is thought to correlate with lingual cavity volume.

The study also involved comparing these acoustic findings with existing literature on other click languages like !Xóõ, Ju'hoansi, Naro, IsiXhosa, and Nuu to contextualize the M. D. !Xung data.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study consists of audio recordings of a wordlist containing the four coronal clicks in Mangetti Dune !Xung, produced by four native speakers. This dataset was collected specifically for this research and is a new contribution to the documentation of M. D. !Xung phonetics. The paper also references and compares its findings with acoustic data from previously published studies on other click languages, serving as comparative datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inter-Speaker Variation in Palatal Clicks: A significant finding is the notable variation in the burst duration of the palatal click ([+]) across speakers. For some, it's shorter, resembling the dental click, while for others, it's longer, suggesting differences in release dynamics. This highlights that even within a single dialect, phonetic realization can be quite diverse.
  • Correlations Between Acoustic Features: The study reveals strong correlations between temporal and amplitude features. Shorter rise times are associated with higher burst amplitudes, and burst duration shows an exponential relationship with rise time. This suggests that these acoustic cues are not independent but rather co-vary, likely reflecting underlying articulatory constraints.
  • COG Reflects Lingual Cavity Volume: The Center of Gravity (COG) of the click bursts generally aligns with expectations based on lingual cavity volume. Dental clicks, with potentially smaller anterior cavities, have higher COGs, while alveolar clicks, with larger cavities, have lower COGs. This provides a spectral correlate for articulatory configurations.
  • "Noisy" Clicks and Frication: The dental ([|]) and lateral alveolar ([9||]) clicks consistently exhibit longer burst durations, longer rise times, and lower amplitudes compared to the central alveolar ([9!]) and palatal ([+]) clicks. These characteristics are attributed to more "fricated" or noisy bursts, likely due to the specific articulatory gestures involved in their release.

Key Results

  • Burst Duration: Dental ([|]) and lateral alveolar ([9||]) clicks generally have longer burst durations than central alveolar ([9!]) and palatal ([+]) clicks. The palatal click shows significant inter-speaker variation in duration.
  • Burst Amplitude: The dental click ([|]) has the lowest relative burst amplitude among the four clicks for all speakers. Other clicks are generally similar in amplitude relative to the following vowel.
  • Rise Time: Rise time is strongly correlated with burst amplitude (shorter rise time = higher amplitude) and burst duration (rise time increases with burst duration, often exponentially).
  • Center of Gravity (COG): Dental ([|]) and palatal ([+]) clicks have the highest COGs, followed by the lateral alveolar ([9||]), and then the central alveolar ([9!]) click, which has the lowest COG. This pattern is consistent with expected lingual cavity volumes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Speakers: While four speakers were studied, the authors acknowledge that this is a small sample size, especially given the observed inter-speaker variation. Future work should include more speakers to fully capture the range of phonetic variation.
  • Perception Study Needed: The strong relationships found between burst duration, rise time, and amplitude highlight the need for a perception experiment to determine how listeners weigh these acoustic cues when distinguishing between click types.
  • Articulatory Dynamics: The paper suggests that the observed acoustic variations, particularly in the palatal click, are due to differences in release dynamics. Future research using high-speed ultrasound imaging is proposed to directly investigate these articulatory differences and their impact on acoustic output.
  • Forward Released Lateral Click: The study found no evidence for a forward-released denti-lateral click, which had been previously described for one speaker. The authors speculate this might have been a socially motivated production, underscoring the importance of studying multiple speakers.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{miller2009acoustics,
  author = {Amanda Miller and Sheena Shah},
  title = {{The acoustics of mangetti dune !xung clicks}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2009},
}
Figure