The Accumulation of Toxic Elements (Pb, Hg, Cd, As, and Cu) in Red Swamp Crayfish (Procambarus clarkii) in Qianjiang and the Associated Risks to Human Health

Lang Zhang, Ziwei Song, Yuntao Zhou, Shan Zhong, Yali Yu, Ting Liu, Xiaoping Gao, Lekang Li, Chiping Kong, Xinshuo Wang, Li He, Jinhua GanToxics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the accumulation of five heavy metals (Pb, Hg, Cd, As, and Cu) in red swamp crayfish from Qianjiang, China, a major global producer. The findings indicate that while crayfish muscle generally poses no significant health risk, elevated arsenic levels in the hepatopancreas in certain regions warrant caution for excessive consumption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global demand for red swamp crayfish (Procambarus clarkii) has surged, raising concerns about the safety of this popular food source, particularly regarding the potential accumulation of toxic heavy metals. China is a leading producer and consumer of crayfish, and it's crucial to understand if major production areas meet safety standards. This paper specifically addresses the lack of comprehensive risk assessment for heavy metal contamination in crayfish from Qianjiang, a city renowned for its crayfish exports, to inform safe dietary practices.

Methods

The researchers collected red swamp crayfish samples from 38 sites across Qianjiang. They analyzed the concentrations of five heavy metals (Pb, Hg, Cd, As, and Cu) in four different tissues: head capsule, hepatopancreas, gills, and abdominal muscles. Standard analytical techniques, including graphite furnace atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) and hydride generation AAS, were employed. To assess human health risks, they calculated:

  • Estimated Daily Intake (EDI): The amount of a metal an individual consumes daily.
  • Target Hazard Quotient (THQ): A measure of the non-carcinogenic risk associated with consuming contaminated food. A THQ > 1 suggests a potential health risk.
  • Carcinogenic Risk (CR): The probability of developing cancer from exposure to a carcinogen.
  • Maximum Allowable Consumption Rates (CR<sub>mm</sub>): The safest number of crayfish meals per month.

Datasets

The study utilized crayfish samples collected from 38 sampling sites in Qianjiang city, Hubei Province, China, between July and August 2019. A total of 1140 crayfish samples were analyzed. The paper also references various national and international food safety standards (e.g., Chinese National Food Safety Standard GB 2762-2017, WHO, USEPA) for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tissue-Specific Accumulation: Heavy metals don't distribute evenly. The hepatopancreas appears to be a primary organ for storing trace metals, while muscles accumulate Hg.
  • Regional Variation Matters: While overall levels might be safe, specific regions within Qianjiang showed higher arsenic concentrations in the hepatopancreas, highlighting the importance of localized risk assessment.
  • Muscle is Generally Safe: The abdominal muscle, the most commonly consumed part, consistently showed metal concentrations below national safety standards.
  • Correlation is Key: Significant correlations were found between metal concentrations in different tissues, suggesting potential pathways for bioaccumulation and offering insights for predictive modeling.
  • Hepatopancreas Caution: Despite the overall safety of muscle tissue, the hepatopancreas warrants more careful consideration due to higher metal concentrations and potential risks, especially with arsenic.

Key Results

  • Muscle Safety: Concentrations of Pb, Hg, Cd, and As in crayfish abdominal muscle were below Chinese national safety levels.
  • THQ Values: THQ values for all five metals in both abdominal muscle and hepatopancreas were less than 1, indicating no significant non-carcinogenic health risk from consumption.
  • Carcinogenic Risk: The CR values for As and Pb were below 10<sup>-6</sup>, suggesting no carcinogenic risk from consuming crayfish from Qianjiang.
  • Maximum Allowable Consumption: For adults, the maximum safe consumption rate (CR<sub>mm</sub>) was determined to be 17.2 meals per month. However, for the hepatopancreas, consumption should be limited, especially in areas with elevated arsenic.
  • Arsenic Anomaly: Certain sampling sites showed elevated arsenic levels in the head capsule, hepatopancreas, and gills, exceeding national standards in some cases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Metals: The study focused on five specific heavy metals. Future research could expand to include other potentially toxic elements.
  • Hepatopancreas Consumption: While the study advises against excessive hepatopancreas consumption, it acknowledges that some consumers prefer it. Further research could explore methods to reduce metal content in this tissue or provide more precise consumption guidelines.
  • Regional Specificity: While the study covered 38 sites, a more granular spatial analysis could pinpoint specific high-risk areas more precisely.
  • Combined Toxicity: The study acknowledges that multiple heavy metals can have combined toxic effects, but this aspect was not deeply explored. Future work could investigate synergistic or antagonistic effects of these metals in crayfish and their impact on human health.
  • Dietary Habits: The study used average consumption rates. Future research could incorporate more detailed dietary surveys to refine risk assessments for different population groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to rapidly expanding crayfish consumption worldwide, the food safety of red swamp crayfish (<i>Procambarus clarkii</i>) is of great concern. China is the largest consumer and producer of crayfish globally. As of yet, it is unknown whether the main crayfish production cities in China are within safe levels of toxic heavy metals and metalloids. For 16 consecutive years, Qianjiang city ranked first in China in processing export volumes of red swamp crayfish. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of the enrichment levels and associated health risks of the species in Qianjiang. In our research, samples of four crayfish tissues, including the head, hepatopancreas, gills, and muscles, were collected from 38 sampling sites distributed in Qianjiang to evaluate the concentration levels of five heavy metals (Pb, Hg, Cd, As, and Cu). The concentration levels of all five metals in muscle did not surpass the national standard. Furthermore, eight significant correlations have been found. For further in-depth assess risk of crayfish in Qianjiang, estimated daily intake (EDI), target hazard quotient (THQ), carcinogenic risk (CR), and estimated maximum allowable consumption rates (CR<sub>mm</sub>) were evaluated in the abdomen muscle and hepatopancreas. The THQ values for each metal were found to be less than 1, while the CR values were below 10<sup>-6</sup>. Additionally, the CR<sub>mm</sub> for adults was determined to be 17.2 meals per month. These findings, based on the analysis of five metallic elements included in this study, suggest that the consumption of crayfish abdomen muscle in Qianjiang does not pose any significant health risks. However, it is noteworthy that certain regions exhibit elevated levels of arsenic in the hepatopancreas, surpassing the national standard, thereby rendering them unsuitable for excessive consumption. In general, the findings can be used to provide guidance for safe dietary practices in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023accumulation,
  author = {Lang Zhang and Ziwei Song and Yuntao Zhou and Shan Zhong and Yali Yu and Ting Liu and Xiaoping Gao and Lekang Li and Chiping Kong and Xinshuo Wang and Li He and Jinhua Gan},
  title = {{The Accumulation of Toxic Elements (Pb, Hg, Cd, As, and Cu) in Red Swamp Crayfish (Procambarus clarkii) in Qianjiang and the Associated Risks to Human Health}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics11070635},
}
Figure