The acceleration and storage of radioactive ions for a neutrino factory

B. Autin, Michael Benedikt, M. Grieser, S. Hancock, H. Haseroth, Andreas Jansson, U. Ko ̈ster, M. Lindroos, Stephan Russenschuck, F. WenanderJournal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics 2003 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The term beta-beam has been coined for the production of a pure beam of electron neutrinos or their antiparticles through the decay of radioactive ions circulating in a storage ring. This concept requires radioactive ions to be accelerated to a Lorentz gamma of 150 for $^6$He and 60 for $^{18}$Ne. The neutrino source itself consists of a storage ring for this energy range, with long straight sections in line with the experiment(s). Such a decay ring does not exist at CERN today, nor does a high-intensity proton source for the production of the radioactive ions. Nevertheless, the existing CERN accelerator infrastructure could be used as this would still represent an important saving for a beta-beam facility. This paper outlines the first study, while some of the more speculative ideas will need further investigations.

Introduction

Neutrino oscillation experiments require intense, collimated, and "clean" neutrino sources. Traditional methods—typically involving the decay of pions produced by hitting a target with protons—result in beams containing a mix of neutrino flavors and a wide energy spread, which complicates data analysis. The "beta-beam" concept offers a solution by using the beta decay of radioactive isotopes to produce pure electron neutrino or anti-neutrino beams with precisely known energy spectra.

The Beta-Beam Facility Concept

The core idea of a beta-beam facility is to produce radioactive ions, accelerate them to high Lorentz factors ($\gamma$), and store them in a decay ring with long straight sections. As these ions circulate and decay, they emit neutrinos in a narrow cone along the straightaways toward distant detectors. This study focuses on the technical feasibility of implementing such a facility by leveraging existing infrastructure at CERN.

Schematic layout of the proposed beta-beam facility at CERN, showing the integration of the SPL, PS, SPS, and the new Decay Ring.

Technical Implementation and Accelerator Chain

The proposed "baseline scenario" involves a multi-stage lifecycle for the ions. It begins with production using an Isotope Separator On-Line (ISOL) system driven by a proposed Superconducting Proton Linac (SPL). The ions are then prepared, ionized, and accelerated through a series of cyclotrons and synchrotrons.

The acceleration chain utilizes the Proton Synchrotron (PS) and the Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) to reach the required energies. Finally, the ions are injected into a large decay ring. A key innovation in this design is Bunch Rotation Stacking, an RF manipulation technique used to merge fresh bunches into the stored beam, maintaining high intensity despite the short half-lives of the isotopes. Simulations showed that this merging technique could reach a steady-state intensity within 20% of a theoretical 100% efficient system.

Isotope Selection

The choice of radioactive isotopes is critical. Ideal candidates must have half-lives long enough to survive the acceleration process but short enough to provide a high neutrino flux in the decay ring. The study identifies $^6$He (for anti-neutrinos) and $^{18}$Ne (for neutrinos) as primary candidates.

Table of candidate isotopes for beta-beam production, including half-lives, decay energies, and expected rates.

As shown in the data, isotopes like $^6$He and $^8$Li offer favorable decay rates and energy profiles. The $Q$-values and average beta/neutrino energies are essential parameters for predicting the resulting neutrino beam's characteristics. $^6$He and $^{18}$Ne are considered "Goldilocks" candidates because their half-lives (~0.8s to 1.7s at rest) balance survival during acceleration with high decay rates in the ring.

Challenges and Future Outlook

While the study confirms that a beta-beam facility is technically plausible using modified CERN infrastructure, several "bottlenecks" remain. The required beam intensity at the SPS injection stage is 13 to 130 times higher than current space-charge limits allow. Additionally, the production rates needed ($10^{13}$ ions per second) exceed the capabilities of current ISOLDE-style targets, necessitating new target designs.

Furthermore, the high radiation load in the decay ring—calculated at approximately 1.2 W/m in the PS—might necessitate specific management of "hot spots" and could impact the use of superconducting magnets. Despite these challenges, repurposing the PS and SPS provides a massive head start in terms of cost and engineering for a future neutrino factory.

Summary updated

Abstract

The term beta-beam has been coined for the production of a pure beam of electron neutrinos or their antiparticles through the decay of radioactive ions circulating in a storage ring. This concept requires radioactive ions to be accelerated to a Lorentz gamma of 150 for 6He and 60 for 18Ne. The neutrino source itself consists of a storage ring for this energy range, with long straight sections in line with the experiment(s). Such a decay ring does not exist at CERN today, nor does a high-intensity proton source for the production of the radioactive ions. Nevertheless, the existing CERN accelerator infrastructure could be used as this would still represent an important saving for a beta-beam facility. This paper outlines the first study, while some of the more speculative ideas will need further investigations.
BibTeX
@article{autin2003acceleration,
  author = {B. Autin and Michael Benedikt and M. Grieser and S. Hancock and H. Haseroth and Andreas Jansson and U. Ko ̈ster and M. Lindroos and Stephan Russenschuck and F. Wenander},
  title = {{The acceleration and storage of radioactive ions for a neutrino factory}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1088/0954-3899/29/8/349},
}

Loading related content...

Figure