The 2-center problem in three dimensions

Pankaj K. Agarwal, Rinat Ben Avraham, Micha SharirScg 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents two new randomized algorithms for the 2-center problem in 3D, aiming to find two balls of minimum radius that cover a given set of points. The algorithms achieve near-cubic and near-quadratic expected running times, offering significant improvements over previous methods, especially when the two optimal covering balls are not too close to each other.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The 2-center problem in 3D asks: given a set of $n$ points in 3-dimensional space, find two congruent balls of the smallest possible radius whose union covers all the points. This is a fundamental problem in computational geometry with applications in facility location, clustering, and data analysis. While the 1-center problem (finding a single ball to cover all points) is efficiently solvable, and the 2-center problem in 2D has seen significant algorithmic progress, the 3D version has remained more challenging. The best previous algorithm for the 3D 2-center problem had a running time of $O(n^{3+\epsilon})$, which is quite slow for larger datasets. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing more efficient algorithms.

Methods

The paper introduces two randomized algorithms:

  1. Near-Cubic Algorithm: This algorithm is a more direct generalization of existing 2D algorithms. It involves constructing a complex arrangement of dual planes and traversing it. The core idea is to reduce the problem to checking intersections of spherical polytopes. This algorithm achieves an expected running time of $O(n^3 \log n)$.
  2. Improved Near-Quadratic Algorithm: This algorithm offers a significant speedup, especially when the optimal covering balls are not too close. It builds upon techniques used for the planar 2-center problem and introduces new geometric insights to handle the 3D case. The key idea is to reduce the problem to a 2D search by guessing separating planes and then efficiently searching for the optimal ball centers. This algorithm achieves an expected running time of $O((n^2 \log n) / (1 - r^*/r_0)^3)$, where $r^*$ is the optimal radius and $r_0$ is the radius of the smallest enclosing ball of the point set. The $(1 - r^*/r_0)^3$ term in the denominator means the algorithm is much faster when $r^*$ is significantly larger than $r_0$, which corresponds to the centers of the two covering balls being far apart.

Both algorithms rely on a sophisticated subroutine for efficiently testing the emptiness (and non-degeneracy) of the intersection of spherical polytopes. This subroutine uses a combination of multi-dimensional parametric searching and geometric data structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The algorithms are general and operate on arbitrary sets of points in $\mathbb{R}^3$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Duality and Arrangements: The use of point-plane duality in 3D is crucial for transforming the geometric problem into an arrangement of planes, which can then be analyzed.
  • Spherical Polytopes: The concept of spherical polytopes (intersections of balls) and efficient methods for testing their intersection emptiness are central to both algorithms.
  • Reducing Dimensionality: The improved algorithm cleverly reduces the 3D problem to a series of 2D subproblems by guessing separating planes.
  • Geometric Constraints for Speedup: The key insight for the near-quadratic algorithm is that when the optimal covering balls are far apart (i.e., $r^*$ is much larger than $r_0$), specific geometric properties emerge that allow for a more efficient search. This is captured by the $(1 - r^*/r_0)^3$ term in the running time.
  • Parametric Search and Randomization: The algorithms leverage randomized techniques and parametric search to achieve their expected time bounds.

Key Results

  • Algorithm 1: An $O(n^3 \log n)$ expected time randomized algorithm for the 3D 2-center problem.
  • Algorithm 2: An $O((n^2 \log n) / (1 - r^*/r_0)^3)$ expected time randomized algorithm, which is near-quadratic when the optimal centers are well-separated.
  • Subroutine: An efficient procedure for testing the emptiness of the intersection of spherical polytopes in $O(\log n)$ time after preprocessing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Near-Quadratic Bottleneck: The authors acknowledge that their second algorithm's speedup is conditional on the optimal centers being sufficiently far apart. A truly near-quadratic algorithm for all point sets remains an open problem.
  • 3SUM-Hardness: The paper poses the question of whether the 3D 2-center problem is 3SUM-hard, which would imply that a near-quadratic algorithm is likely the best possible.
  • Approximation: The paper briefly mentions how the second algorithm can be adapted to provide an $\epsilon$-approximate solution in $O(\epsilon^{-3} n^2 \log n)$ time.

This work represents a significant step forward in solving the 2-center problem in three dimensions, offering more practical algorithms for this challenging geometric task.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{agarwal2010center,
  author = {Pankaj K. Agarwal and Rinat Ben Avraham and Micha Sharir},
  title = {{The 2-center problem in three dimensions}},
  booktitle = {Scg},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1145/1810959.1810974},
}
Figure