TeXP: Deconvolving the effects of pervasive and autonomous transcription of transposable elements

Fábio C. P. Navarro, Jacob Hoops, Lauren Bellfy, Eliza Cerveira, Qihui Zhu, Chengsheng Zhang, Charles Lee, Mark GersteinbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new computational method called TeXP to accurately measure the activity of LINE-1, a highly repetitive and abundant element in our genome. This method disentangles "pervasive transcription" (background genomic noise) from "autonomous transcription" (actual LINE-1 activity), revealing that LINE-1 is surprisingly active in many healthy human tissues, particularly those with high cell turnover.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human genome is packed with repetitive sequences, making it incredibly challenging to study their activity using standard RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) techniques. Long interspersed nuclear element 1 (LINE-1) elements, which make up a significant portion of our genome, are particularly difficult to quantify due to their repetitive nature. This makes it hard to understand their role in genetic variation and disease. A major hurdle is distinguishing true LINE-1 transcriptional activity from "pervasive transcription," which is essentially background transcriptional noise that can swamp the signal from actual LINE-1 elements. Previous methods struggled to separate these two signals, leading to an underestimation or misinterpretation of LINE-1 activity.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the development of TeXP (Transposable Element eXpression Profiler). TeXP is a computational pipeline designed to deconvolve pervasive transcription from autonomous LINE-1 activity. It achieves this by:

  • Building mappability signatures: TeXP uses information about how reads from different LINE-1 subfamilies can map to the genome. This helps to distinguish reads originating from specific LINE-1 elements.
  • Modeling pervasive transcription: The method estimates the contribution of pervasive transcription by considering the broad distribution of LINE-1 elements across the genome and their correlation with genomic annotations.
  • Deconvolving signals: By combining mappability signatures and pervasive transcription estimates, TeXP can then accurately quantify the autonomous transcription of LINE-1.
  • Validation: The authors validated TeXP using droplet digital PCR (ddPCR), a highly sensitive method for quantifying nucleic acid levels, and compared its performance to existing methods.

Datasets

The study utilized several large-scale RNA sequencing datasets:

  • GTEx (Genotype-Tissue Expression) project: This dataset provided RNA-seq data from thousands of healthy human tissue samples, allowing for the analysis of LINE-1 activity across a wide range of tissues.
  • ENCODE (Encyclopedia of DNA Elements) project: This dataset provided RNA-seq data from various human cell lines, enabling the study of LINE-1 activity in different cellular contexts.
  • Simulated datasets: The authors generated simulated RNA-seq data to test and validate the performance of TeXP under controlled conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pervasive transcription is a major confounder: The study found that, on average, over 90% of RNA-seq reads overlapping LINE-1 elements are actually derived from pervasive transcription, not true LINE-1 activity. This highlights the critical need for methods like TeXP.
  • LINE-1 is surprisingly active in healthy tissues: Contrary to previous assumptions of LINE-1 being largely silenced in most somatic cells, TeXP revealed that LINE-1 is broadly expressed in many healthy human tissues.
  • Cell turnover is linked to LINE-1 activity: A fascinating finding is the correlation between LINE-1 activity and cell turnover rate. Tissues with high cell turnover (e.g., skin, reproductive organs) show higher LINE-1 activity, while tissues with low turnover (e.g., the adult brain) show lower activity. This suggests a potential role for LINE-1 in tissue maintenance or adaptation.
  • Brain LINE-1 activity is complex: While overall brain tissue shows low LINE-1 activity, specific regions like the basal ganglia exhibit higher levels, suggesting regional differences within the brain.

Key Results

  • TeXP accurately deconvolves pervasive and autonomous transcription signals, as validated by ddPCR with high concordance (Spearman correlation of 0.99).
  • Approximately 91.7% of transcriptome reads overlapping LINE-1 in cell lines and healthy tissues are attributed to pervasive transcription.
  • LINE-1 autonomous transcription was detected in a broad range of healthy somatic tissues, challenging the notion of widespread silencing.
  • A significant inverse correlation was found between LINE-1 autonomous transcription and cell turnover rate (Pearson correlation: cor=-0.6668968, p-value=0.04).
  • Specific brain regions, particularly the basal ganglia, showed higher LINE-1 activity compared to other brain tissues.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensitivity to low signal: The authors acknowledge that TeXP may underestimate LINE-1 transcription levels when the signal-to-noise ratio is very small, meaning it might miss very low levels of autonomous transcription.
  • Improving quantification: They suggest that using unique regions of LINE-1 instances after removing the pervasive transcription signal could further improve transcriptional quantification.
  • Broader applications: The authors propose that TeXP could be extended to study other transposable elements, pseudogenes, and repetitive regions, as well as applied to model organisms and pathological tissues like tumors.
  • Investigating biases: Future work could also involve using TeXP to investigate biases in LINE-1 transcription related to ancestral backgrounds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Long interspersed nuclear element 1 (LINE-1) is a primary source of genetic variation in humans and other mammals. Despite its importance, LINE-1 activity remains difficult to study because of its highly repetitive nature. Here, we developed and validated a method called TeXP to gauge LINE-1 activity accurately. TeXP builds mappability signatures from LINE-1 subfamilies to deconvolve the effect of pervasive transcription from autonomous LINE-1 activity. In particular, it apportions the multiple reads aligned to the many LINE-1 instances in the genome into these two categories. Using our method, we evaluated well-established cell lines, cell-line compartments and healthy tissues and found that the vast majority (91.7%) of transcriptome reads overlapping LINE-1 derive from pervasive transcription. We validated TeXP by independently estimating the levels of LINE-1 autonomous transcription using ddPCR, finding high concordance. Next, we applied our method to comprehensively measure LINE-1 activity across healthy somatic cells, while backing out the effect of pervasive transcription. Unexpectedly, we found that LINE-1 activity is present in many normal somatic cells. This finding contrasts with earlier studies showing that LINE-1 has limited activity in healthy somatic tissues, except for neuroprogenitor cells. Interestingly, we found that the amount of LINE-1 activity was associated with the with the amount of cell turnover, with tissues with low cell turnover rates (e.g. the adult central nervous system) showing lower LINE-1 activity. Altogether, our results show how accounting for pervasive transcription is critical to accurately quantify the activity of highly repetitive regions of the human genome. Author Summary Repetitive sequences, such as LINEs, comprise more than half of the human genome. Due to their repetitive nature, LINEs are hard to grasp. In particular, we find that pervasive transcription is a major confounding factor in transcriptome data. We observe that, on average, more than 90% of LINE signal derives from pervasive transcription. To investigate this issue, we developed and validated a new method called TeXP. TeXP accounts and removes the effects of pervasive transcription when quantifying LINE activity. Our method uses the broad distribution of LINEs to estimate the effects of pervasive transcription. Using TeXP, we processed thousands of transcriptome datasets to uniformly, and unbiasedly measure LINE-1 activity across healthy somatic cells. By removing the pervasive transcription component, we find that (1) LINE-1 is broadly expressed in healthy somatic tissues; (2) Adult brain show small levels of LINE transcription and; (3) LINE-1 transcription level is correlated with tissue cell turnover. Our method thus offers insights into how repetitive sequences and influenced by pervasive transcription. Moreover, we uncover the activity of LINE-1 in somatic tissues at an unmatched scale.
BibTeX
@misc{navarro2019texp,
  author = {Fábio C. P. Navarro and Jacob Hoops and Lauren Bellfy and Eliza Cerveira and Qihui Zhu and Chengsheng Zhang and Charles Lee and Mark Gerstein},
  title = {{TeXP: Deconvolving the effects of pervasive and autonomous transcription of transposable elements}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/648667},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure