Tethered UAV Deployment Strategies: The Coverage and Energy Efficiency Trade-Off

Safa Khemiri, Mustafa A. Kishk, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Open J. Commun. Soc 2023 · DOI

Introduction

As 6G networks evolve, Unmanned Aerial Vehicle-mounted Base Stations (UAV-BSs) have emerged as a flexible solution for offloading traffic and providing on-demand coverage. However, the limited battery life of traditional UAVs remains a significant hurdle. Tethered UAVs (TUAVs) address this by receiving continuous power and data through a cable from a ground station (GS), offering virtually "infinite" endurance.

Despite this advantage, the tether restricts mobility to a specific "hover region" around the GS. Furthermore, urban traffic is inherently dynamic, with user densities shifting between residential and commercial areas throughout the day. This paper explores optimal deployment strategies for TUAVs that balance the physical constraints of the tether with the need to follow mobile user populations.

Deployment Scenarios

To address the dynamic nature of user traffic, the study evaluates three distinct deployment strategies using a stochastic geometry framework:

  1. Dedicated TUAVs (Scenario 1): Every user cluster (e.g., a residential block or office park) is assigned its own dedicated TUAV. While providing the highest coverage, this is the most resource-intensive approach.
  2. Shared Fixed TUAVs (Scenario 2): A single TUAV is shared between a pair of clusters but remains fixed to a single optimal GS location between them.
  3. Intermittently Tethered UAVs (Scenario 3): A single TUAV is shared between a pair of clusters but has the capability to detach, relocate, and re-attach to a different GS to follow shifting user density.
System model illustrating various TUAV deployment scenarios and user clusters.

Modeling and Optimization

The researchers utilized a Poisson Bipolar Process (PBP) to model cluster pairs where user density fluctuates inversely (e.g., morning vs. night). To make the optimization of tether length and inclination angle mathematically tractable, the space around potential GS locations was discretized into concentric rings and angular slices. This approach accounts for the reality that GSs must be placed on existing buildings, which may not align perfectly with theoretical optima.

Geometric representation of the discretized hover region and cluster arrangement.

The optimization objective was to minimize average pathloss for users while considering the "accessibility factor" ($\kappa_b$)—the fraction of buildings capable of hosting a GS. Analytical results were validated through 10,000 Monte-Carlo simulation iterations.

Key Insights and Results

The Coverage vs. Energy Trade-off

Scenario 1 achieved the highest coverage probability (~0.75), but at the cost of doubling the required fleet and energy consumption. Scenario 3 (Intermittently Tethered) emerged as the most balanced strategy, providing coverage performance close to Scenario 1 while maintaining significantly higher energy efficiency (EE). Scenario 2 performed the worst in terms of coverage (~0.4), as the fixed GS location often represented a poor compromise for both clusters.

Impact of Tether Length and Building Density

Increasing the maximum tether length ($T_{max}$) from 50m to 150m significantly improved coverage in Scenarios 1 and 3. However, it had negligible impact on Scenario 2, suggesting that mobility around a mediocre center point is less effective than moving the center point itself. Additionally, the study found that building accessibility is a critical bottleneck; if few buildings can host GSs, coverage drops sharply regardless of UAV capabilities.

Conclusion

The concept of Intermittently Tethered UAVs (iTUAVs) offers a powerful middle ground for 6G operators. By allowing drones to move between ground stations to "follow the crowd," networks can achieve high reliability without the massive capital and energy expenditure of a fully dedicated aerial fleet. Future research will look to incorporate more fluid user mobility models and 3D terrestrial environments with varying building heights.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{khemiri2023tethered,
  author = {Safa Khemiri and Mustafa A. Kishk and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Tethered UAV Deployment Strategies: The Coverage and Energy Efficiency Trade-Off}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/ojcoms.2023.3323676},
}
Figure