Testing two competing hypotheses for Eurasian jays’ caching for the future

Piero Amodio, Johanni Brea, Benjamin Farrar, Ljerka Ostojić, Nicola S. ClaytonScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Previous research reported that corvids preferentially cache food in a location where no food will be available or cache more of a specific food in a location where this food will not be available. Here, we consider possible explanations for these prospective caching behaviours and directly compare two competing hypotheses. The Compensatory Caching Hypothesis suggests that birds learn to cache more of a particular food in places where that food was less frequently available in the past. In contrast, the Future Planning Hypothesis suggests that birds recall the 'what-when-where' features of specific past events to predict the future availability of food. We designed a protocol in which the two hypotheses predict different caching patterns across different caching locations such that the two explanations can be disambiguated. We formalised the hypotheses in a Bayesian model comparison and tested this protocol in two experiments with one of the previously tested species, namely Eurasian jays. Consistently across the two experiments, the observed caching pattern did not support either hypothesis; rather it was best explained by a uniform distribution of caches over the different caching locations. Future research is needed to gain more insight into the cognitive mechanism underpinning corvids' caching for the future.

Introduction

Corvids, often referred to as "feathered apes," are renowned for their sophisticated cognitive abilities, including the capacity to plan for the future. Landmark studies have suggested that Eurasian jays (Garrulus glandarius) exhibit "episodic-like memory," allowing them to remember the what, where, and when of past events to inform future actions. Specifically, jays have been observed caching food in locations where they anticipate a future shortage.

However, a critical debate persists regarding the underlying mechanism: are these birds truly engaging in mental time travel, or are they following simpler associative rules? This study evaluates two primary explanations:

  1. Future Planning Hypothesis (FPH): Birds use episodic-like memory to predict future needs.
  2. Compensatory Caching Hypothesis (CCH): Birds follow a simpler rule, caching more of a specific resource in locations where that resource was scarce in the past to "balance the books."

Methods

The researchers conducted two experiments with nine Eurasian jays to disambiguate these hypotheses. The experimental design relied on a "de-synchronization" of food availability and location.

The three-compartment experimental setup (A, B, C) used for testing caching preferences.

The setup involved three distinct compartments (A, B, and C). In Experiment 1, birds were presented with two food types (peanuts and macadamias), while Experiment 2 focused on a simplified "Food vs. No Food" scenario. To separate the predictions of FPH and CCH, the researchers implemented a staggered schedule: a 3-day cycle for compartment access and a 2-day cycle for food conditions.

The 9-day experimental schedule designed to de-synchronize food availability and location.

By the end of a 9-day "experience phase," the FPH and CCH predicted distinct caching distributions for the final test day. The results were analyzed using Bayesian model comparison, testing 13 different behavioral models to determine which best fit the observed caching data.

Results

The results across both experiments failed to support either the FPH or the CCH. Instead, the data suggested that jays do not follow complex prospective strategies in this context.

In Experiment 1, the model with the highest posterior probability (0.997) indicated that caching behavior was driven by individual bird identity and food preference, rather than the history of the compartment. The FPH and CCH performed poorly, with posterior probabilities of 0.0014 and 0.00001, respectively.

In Experiment 2, despite the reduced cognitive load of a "Food vs. No Food" choice, the "compartment-independent" (uniform caching) model remained the most likely (0.72). While CCH (0.16) showed more support than FPH (0.002), it was not the dominant strategy.

Discussion

The findings challenge the prevailing canon of corvid future planning. The jays' tendency toward uniform caching suggests they may default to a "spread the risk" strategy when faced with complex environmental patterns.

Several factors may explain the lack of prospective caching:

  • Cognitive Load: The 3-day/2-day staggered schedule may have been too complex for the birds to track, leading them to abandon specific planning in favor of a simpler uniform distribution.
  • Ecological Validity: The strict cyclic nature of the experiment may not mirror natural food fluctuations, potentially making the patterns harder for the birds to learn.
  • Social Context: Unlike previous studies where birds were isolated, these jays were tested within a social group. This environment might prioritize rapid caching to prevent theft over long-term planning.

Future research should explore whether increasing the duration of the experience phase or simplifying the temporal patterns allows birds to better demonstrate prospective abilities. This study highlights the importance of rigorous model comparison in animal cognition to distinguish between complex planning and simpler behavioral heuristics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous research reported that corvids preferentially cache food in a location where no food will be available or cache more of a specific food in a location where this food will not be available. Here, we consider possible explanations for these prospective caching behaviours and directly compare two competing hypotheses. The Compensatory Caching Hypothesis suggests that birds learn to cache more of a particular food in places where that food was less frequently available in the past. In contrast, the Future Planning Hypothesis suggests that birds recall the 'what-when-where' features of specific past events to predict the future availability of food. We designed a protocol in which the two hypotheses predict different caching patterns across different caching locations such that the two explanations can be disambiguated. We formalised the hypotheses in a Bayesian model comparison and tested this protocol in two experiments with one of the previously tested species, namely Eurasian jays. Consistently across the two experiments, the observed caching pattern did not support either hypothesis; rather it was best explained by a uniform distribution of caches over the different caching locations. Future research is needed to gain more insight into the cognitive mechanism underpinning corvids' caching for the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{amodio2021testing,
  author = {Piero Amodio and Johanni Brea and Benjamin Farrar and Ljerka Ostojić and Nicola S. Clayton},
  title = {{Testing two competing hypotheses for Eurasian jays’ caching for the future}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-80515-7},
}
Figure