Testing the Use of Advanced Upper Limb Prostheses: Towards Quantifying the Movement Quality with Inertial-Magnetic Measurement Units

Andreas Franzke, Morten Kristoffersen, Dario Farina, Corry K. van der Sluis, Raoul M. Bongers, Alessio MurgiaProsthesis 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, portable assessment method using inertial-magnetic measurement units (IMMU) to quantify the movement quality of upper limb prosthesis users during a daily activity. The findings reveal that prosthesis users exhibit compensatory movements, take longer to complete tasks, and demonstrate less smooth and coordinated movements compared to able-bodied individuals, highlighting the need for better clinical assessment tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite significant advancements in upper limb prosthetics, there's a notable gap between lab-developed technologies and their actual adoption and benefit in users' daily lives. A key reason for this is the lack of robust, clinically feasible assessment methods that can accurately capture the nuances of prosthesis use in real-world scenarios. Existing clinical tests are often too simplistic to evaluate the sophisticated capabilities of modern prostheses, while advanced motion-capture systems are typically too complex and expensive for routine clinical use. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a new assessment procedure that combines the practicality of clinical tests with the analytical depth of motion capture.

Methods

The researchers developed a "tray-task," a simulated daily activity designed to challenge prosthesis users by requiring a wide range of arm orientations, prehensile and supporting actions, and bimanual coordination. To capture movement quality, they employed Inertial-Magnetic Measurement Units (IMMU) attached to the thorax and humerus of participants. This system allows for motion capture that is more portable and easier to set up than traditional optical systems.

Key outcome measures derived from the IMMU data included:

  • Time to Completion: Measuring how long it takes to perform the task.
  • Range of Motion (ROM): Quantifying the extent of thoracic flexion and humeral elevation.
  • Smoothness: Assessed by calculating the "jerk" (rate of change of acceleration) of the humeral movement, with a focus on the prominence of peaks in the jerk data.
  • Stability of Coordination: Analyzed using angle-angle plots, which visualize the relative motion between thoracic flexion and humeral elevation across multiple repetitions to assess movement consistency.

Datasets

The study involved two groups of participants:

  • Prosthesis Users: Six individuals with upper limb amputations.
  • Able-Bodied Participants: Ten individuals without limb impairments.

The data collected was from these participants performing the "tray-task" in either a laboratory, clinic, or home environment. No pre-existing datasets were used; the study generated its own data for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Tray-Task" as a Realistic Benchmark: Designing a task that mimics real-life activities is crucial for assessing prosthesis utility beyond controlled lab settings. The tray-task effectively elicited compensatory movements.
  • IMMU as a Practical Motion Capture Solution: The use of IMMUs offers a promising pathway for bringing advanced motion analysis into more accessible clinical settings due to their portability and ease of use.
  • Compensatory Movements are Key: Prosthesis users rely heavily on trunk movements (thoracic flexion) to compensate for the limited degrees of freedom in their upper limb prostheses, a finding that aligns with previous research.
  • Smoothness is More Than Just Average Jerk: The study highlights that the nature of movement irregularities (sharp, abrupt changes in acceleration) is more indicative of prosthesis use quality than just the average acceleration. This suggests that prosthesis users make significant, sudden adjustments.
  • Coordination Variability Matters: The inconsistency in angle-angle plots for prosthesis users suggests they employ less stable and more variable strategies to coordinate their movements, potentially due to the unpredictable nature of myoelectric prostheses.

Key Results

  • Time to Completion: Prosthesis users took significantly longer to complete the tray-task (median 12.6 s) compared to able-bodied participants (median 6.9 s).
  • Range of Motion:
    • Prosthesis users exhibited greater thoracic flexion (median 44.05 degrees) than able-bodied participants (median 19.41 degrees).
  • Conversely, prosthesis users showed less humeral elevation (median 55.36 degrees) compared to able-bodied participants (median 80.66 degrees).
  • Smoothness: Prosthesis users displayed less smooth movements, indicated by a higher peak prominence in humeral jerk (median 0.98) compared to able-bodied participants (median 0.9).
  • Coordination: Angle-angle plots revealed that able-bodied participants had highly consistent coordination patterns, while prosthesis users showed more variability between individuals and even between repetitions for some users.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study acknowledges that a larger group of prosthesis users would strengthen the findings.
  • Homogeneity of Prosthesis Users: The sample was relatively homogenous (primarily myoelectric users), limiting the ability to statistically compare different prosthesis types.
  • Task Specificity: While the "tray-task" was designed to be representative, the authors suggest future work should test the proposed measures across a broader range of tasks to assess their activity-independent applicability.
  • Subjectivity in Coordination Analysis: The interpretation of angle-angle plots was largely visual. Future research should explore more objective methods for quantifying coordination stability.
  • Potential for Larger Loads: The task's weight and arm orientation range could be increased to further stress prosthetic control systems, though pilot tests indicated potential fatigue issues.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose integrating IMMU data with direct prosthetic sensor readings (e.g., motor commands) to gain a more comprehensive understanding of how prosthetic functions influence movement quality. They also envision future iterations of the test being self-administered by users in their homes, potentially through embedded sensors. The ultimate goal is to refine assessment procedures to better inform the development and transfer of advanced prosthetic technologies into daily life.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: A thorough assessment of upper limb prostheses could help facilitate their transfer from scientific developments into the daily lives of users. Ideally, routine clinical testing would include assessments of upper limb function using motion-capturing technology. This is particularly relevant for the state-of-the-art upper limb prostheses. Methods: We designed a test based on an activity of daily life (“tray-task”) which could be completed outside the laboratory, and developed a set of outcome measures aimed at characterizing the movement quality. For this purpose, kinematics of the thorax and the humerus were captured with an inertial–magnetic measurement unit (IMMU) motion-capture system. Six prosthesis users and ten able-bodied participants were recruited to test the feasibility of the proposed assessment procedure and to evaluate the outcome variables. Results: All participants completed the test either at home or in our lab. The prosthesis users needed more time to complete the task and showed a larger range of motion in the thoracic flexion and a smaller range of motion in the humeral elevation, compared to the able-bodied participants. Furthermore, the prosthesis users’ movements were less smooth and characterized by less stable coordination patterns between the humerus and thorax. Conclusion: A new test method and associated outcome variables have been proposed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{franzke2023testing,
  author = {Andreas Franzke and Morten Kristoffersen and Dario Farina and Corry K. van der Sluis and Raoul M. Bongers and Alessio Murgia},
  title = {{Testing the Use of Advanced Upper Limb Prostheses: Towards Quantifying the Movement Quality with Inertial-Magnetic Measurement Units}},
  booktitle = {Prosthesis},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/prosthesis5010020},
}
Figure