Testing the limits of logical reasoning in neural and hybrid models

Manuel Vargas Guzmán, Jakub Szymanik, Maciej MalickiNAACL 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how well neural and hybrid models can generalize logical reasoning, specifically syllogistic logic. Despite achieving high overall accuracy, the models struggle to generalize to more complex or unseen reasoning patterns, suggesting they grasp surface-level correlations rather than true logical structure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep learning models have shown remarkable success in various natural language processing tasks. However, a fundamental question remains: to what extent do these models truly "understand" the underlying structure and rules of the data they process, particularly in the realm of logical reasoning? Generalization, the ability to perform on unseen data, is a key indicator of this understanding. While language has well-defined grammatical and semantic structures, and logic has formal systems, the methodology for testing generalization in neural models for reasoning tasks is still developing. This paper aims to address this by systematically evaluating the logical reasoning capabilities of neural and hybrid models, focusing on compositionality and recursiveness within syllogistic logic, a well-understood fragment of natural language logic.

Methods

The authors developed a novel testing framework for evaluating logical reasoning generalization. Their approach involves presenting neural models with a knowledge base (KB) – a set of premises – and a hypothesis. The models' task is to identify the minimal set of premises required to logically derive the hypothesis. This frames the models as "hybrid" components assisting a logical prover.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Synthetic Data Generation: To control for confounding factors and ensure non-redundant knowledge bases, they generated synthetic syllogistic corpora. These bases are represented as graphs, with constants as vertices and quantifiers as edges.
  • Focus on Generalization: The core of the evaluation lies in testing generalization across different dimensions:
  • Unseen Lengths: Models are trained on inferences of certain lengths (e.g., number of A-chains) and tested on shorter or longer inferences not seen during training. This probes compositionality (ability to combine smaller parts) and recursiveness (ability to extend patterns).
  • Unseen Inference Types: Entire categories of syllogistic inferences are removed from the training set and then tested.
  • Unseen Combinations of Premises: Models are trained on inferences where premises are not combined in certain ways and then tested on those unseen combinations, assessing systematicity.
  • Testing on New Knowledge Bases: Models are trained on one set of KBs and tested on entirely new ones to assess robustness and prevent memorization.
  • Architectures Tested: The study evaluates several common neural network architectures: Multilayer Perceptron (MLP), Recurrent Neural Network (RNN), Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), and Transformers (TRA).

Datasets

The paper utilizes synthetically generated syllogistic knowledge bases and inference tasks. These datasets are designed to be consistent and non-redundant, allowing for controlled experiments on generalization. The authors generated multiple such knowledge bases for training and testing to ensure robustness and prevent overfitting to specific data instances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Overall Accuracy Masks Deeper Issues: While models achieve high accuracy on standard evaluation metrics, this masks a significant failure to generalize logical reasoning. The "generalization gap" is not a sufficient measure for assessing true logical understanding.
  • Lack of Compositionality: Models struggle to generalize to inferences with lengths or combinations of premises not seen during training. This suggests they don't break down complex inferences into their constituent parts, a hallmark of compositionality. For instance, a model might infer "All A are C" from "All A are B" and "All B are C," but fail to infer "All A are B" from the same premises if it was trained on longer chains.
  • Limited Recursiveness: While some evidence for recursiveness (extending patterns) is observed, it's not robust. Models can perform inferences slightly longer than those seen in training, but performance drops sharply with greater length differences.
  • Surface-Level Understanding: The models appear to learn correlations and superficial patterns rather than the underlying logical rules. They grasp elementary aspects like the Principle of Contradiction or symmetry of quantifiers but fail to assimilate the recursive and compositional nature of logic.
  • Transformer Superiority Not Universal: Contrary to some expectations, Transformers did not show a consistent qualitative superiority across all reasoning tasks, particularly in compositionality tests.

Key Results

  • Overall Accuracy: Models achieved high overall accuracy (e.g., TRA models reaching ~96% on average), indicating a low generalization gap in the traditional sense.
  • Compositionality Test: Performance dropped sharply when testing on unseen inference lengths, with accuracies falling significantly below training performance. For example, testing on lengths 5 and less after training on longer inferences resulted in a substantial performance decrease.
  • Recursiveness Test: Similar to compositionality, performance degraded when models were tested on inferences significantly longer than those seen during training.
  • Unseen Inference Types: Models were largely incapable of finding inferences of types not present in the training data, suggesting a lack of abstract reasoning.
  • Testing on New Knowledge Bases: Performance on entirely new knowledge bases was poor, with valid hypothesis accuracy often dropping to zero. This highlights a tendency for models to memorize training data rather than learn generalizable logical rules.
  • Specific Strengths: CNNs showed surprisingly strong performance on invalid hypotheses, suggesting they might have learned to recognize consistency of logical formulas beyond the training setup. RNNs struggled to generalize the Principle of Contradiction on new KBs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Syllogistic Logic: The study focuses on a small fragment of natural language logic. Findings may not directly apply to more complex reasoning systems or broader natural language understanding.
  • Synthetic Data and Encodings: The use of synthetic data and specific encodings (one-hot) might not fully reflect the complexities of natural language and real-world reasoning.
  • Training Regimes: The authors acknowledge that other training methods might yield better compositional and recursive generalization.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the proposed methodology can be adapted to other reasoning fragments or even non-logical sequence-to-sequence tasks. Further research into different training regimes and more sophisticated encodings could potentially improve generalization. The authors also point to the need for further study into the distinctive features of CNNs' performance on invalid hypotheses.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{guzman2024testing,
  author = {Manuel Vargas Guzmán and Jakub Szymanik and Maciej Malicki},
  title = {{Testing the limits of logical reasoning in neural and hybrid models}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18653/v1/2024.findings-naacl.147},
}
Figure