Testing the basin-centered gas accumulation model using fluid inclusion observations: Southern Piceance Basin, Colorado

András Fall, Peter Eichhubl, Stephen P. Cumella, Robert J. Bodnar, Stephen E. Laubach, Stephen BeckerAAPG 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses fluid inclusions in fracture cements from the Piceance Basin, Colorado, to test the basin-centered gas accumulation model. The findings suggest that natural fractures formed concurrently with gas generation and charge under near-lithostatic pressures, supporting the idea that fractures are an intrinsic component of these reservoirs, not merely incidental.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Piceance Basin in Colorado hosts significant tight-gas sandstone reservoirs, often described as "basin-centered gas accumulations." A key debate in understanding these reservoirs revolves around the role of natural fractures. One model proposes that gas accumulates in conventional traps driven by buoyancy, with fractures playing a secondary role. In contrast, the basin-centered gas accumulation model suggests that gas generation within or near the reservoir creates high pore pressures, leading to the formation of pervasive fracture networks that facilitate gas migration and accumulation. This study aims to resolve this by investigating the timing of fracture formation relative to burial and gas generation, and the pressure conditions under which these fractures formed, using fluid inclusion analysis.

Methods

The researchers employed microthermometry and Raman microspectrometry to analyze fluid inclusions trapped within quartz cements that filled natural fractures. These techniques allowed them to determine:

  • Trapping temperatures (Th): By measuring the temperature at which the vapor and liquid phases within an inclusion homogenize.
  • Fluid composition: Specifically identifying methane-rich hydrocarbon fluids alongside aqueous fluids.
  • Trapping pressures (P): Calculated using Raman spectroscopy to determine methane concentration and then applying thermodynamic models.

The textural analysis of the fracture cements using scanning electron microscopy-cathodoluminescence (SEM-CL) was crucial for establishing the relative timing of different cementation stages and, consequently, the sequence of fluid inclusion entrapment. This allowed for the reconstruction of a history of temperature, pressure, and fluid composition during fracture opening and growth.

Datasets

The study utilized core samples from several wells in the southern Piceance Basin, Colorado, including:

  • Grand Valley (GV2)
  • Rulison (MWX1, SHCT1)
  • Mamm Creek (Core A)

These samples provided the natural quartz-cemented fractures from which fluid inclusions were extracted and analyzed. The data was then compared with existing burial history, thermal maturity, and basin models for the region.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fractures are intrinsic, not incidental: The evidence strongly supports the basin-centered gas accumulation model, where pervasive natural fractures are integral to gas migration and reservoir formation, rather than being a secondary feature.
  • Fracture growth and gas charge are coeval: The timing of fracture opening and cementation, as revealed by fluid inclusions, closely aligns with peak burial temperatures and inferred active gas generation and migration.
  • Near-lithostatic pressures drove fracture formation: The calculated pore-fluid pressures during fracture opening were exceptionally high, approaching lithostatic conditions, which is consistent with overpressuring caused by active gas generation.
  • Dynamic pressure fluctuations: The variability in trapping pressures, even within the same fracture cement stage, suggests a dynamic system with episodic gas charge and release, rather than a static pressure regime.
  • Methane-rich environment: The consistent presence of both aqueous and methane-rich hydrocarbon fluid inclusions indicates that the pore fluids were saturated with methane, and a separate hydrocarbon phase was present during fracture formation.

Key Results

  • Temperature Trends: Trapping temperatures show a systematic trend, increasing from approximately 140°C to 185°C and then decreasing to around 158°C, interpreted as fracture growth during maximum burial.
  • Pressure Estimates: Calculated pore-fluid pressures range from 55 to 110 MPa (7977–15,954 psi), indicating fracture growth under near-lithostatic conditions.
  • Timing of Fracture Growth: Fracture opening and growth are inferred to have occurred over a 35-million-year period, starting around 41 Ma and ending approximately 6 Ma, coinciding with peak burial and the onset of uplift.
  • Gas Generation: The observed temperatures are within the hydrocarbon gas generation window, consistent with gas originating from coals within the Mesaverde Group.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Pressure Trends: While temperature trends were observed, systematic trends in trapping pressure over time were not consistently found, suggesting dynamic conditions that are difficult to fully resolve with static inclusion data alone.
  • Regional Applicability: While the study focuses on the southern Piceance Basin, the authors suggest that the observed pattern of fracture formation concurrent with gas maturation and charge likely applies to tight-gas sandstone reservoirs beyond this specific area.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further detailed analysis of pressure variations and their correlation with specific geological events (like episodic gas release) could refine our understanding of these dynamic systems. Investigating other basins with similar basin-centered gas accumulation characteristics would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Upper Cretaceous Mesaverde Group in the Piceance Basin, Colorado, is considered a continuous basin-centered gas accumulation in which gas charge of the low-permeability sandstone occurs under high pore-fluid pressure in response to gas generation. High gas pressure favors formation of pervasive systems of opening-mode fractures. This view contrasts with thatofothermodelsoflow-permeabilitygasreservoirsinwhich gas migrates by buoyant drive and accumulates in conventional traps, with fractures an incidental attribute of these reservoirs. We tested the aspects of the basin-centered gas accumulation model as it applies to the Piceance Basin by determining the timing of fracturegrowth and associated temperature,pressure, and fluid-composition conditions using microthermometry and Raman microspectrometry of fluid inclusions trapped in fracture cement that formed during fracture growth. Trapping temperatures of methane-saturated aqueous fluid inclusions record systematic temperature trends that increase from approximately 140 to 185°C and then decrease to approximately 158°C over time, which indicates fracture growth during maximum burial conditions. Calculated pore-fluid pressures for methanerich aqueous inclusions of 55 to 110 MPa (7977–15,954 psi) indicate fracture growth under near-lithostatic pressure conditions consistent with fracture growth during active gas maturation and charge. Lack of systematic pore-fluid–pressure trends
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fall2012testing,
  author = {András Fall and Peter Eichhubl and Stephen P. Cumella and Robert J. Bodnar and Stephen E. Laubach and Stephen Becker},
  title = {{Testing the basin-centered gas accumulation model using fluid inclusion observations: Southern Piceance Basin, Colorado}},
  booktitle = {AAPG},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1306/05171211149},
}
Figure