Testing Gravity Using Type Ia Supernovae Discovered by Next-Generation Wide-Field Imaging Surveys

G. Aldering, P. Antilogus, A Bhamanyar, S. BenZvi, H. Courtois, T. M. Davis, Hume A. Feldman, S. Ferraro, Satya Gontcho A Gontcho, Or Graur, Romain Graziani, J. Guy, Charlie Harper, Renée Hložek, Cullan Howlett, Dragan Huterer, Chen Ju, P.-f. Léget, E. Linder, P. McDonald, J. Nordin, P. Nugent, S. Perlmutter, N. Regnault, M. Rigault, Shafieloo, A., Slosar, A., Tully, R. B., Wang, L., White, M., Wood-Vasey, M.arXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In the upcoming decade cadenced wide-field imaging surveys will increase the number of identified $z<0.3$ Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) from the hundreds to the hundreds of thousands. The increase in the number density and solid-angle coverage of SNe Ia, in parallel with improvements in the standardization of their absolute magnitudes, now make them competitive probes of the growth of structure and hence of gravity. The peculiar velocity power spectrum is sensitive to the growth index $\gamma$, which captures the effect of gravity on the linear growth of structure through the relation $f=\Omega_M^\gamma$. We present the first projections for the precision in $\gamma$ for a range of realistic SN peculiar-velocity survey scenarios. In the next decade the peculiar velocities of SNe Ia in the local $z<0.3$ Universe will provide a measure of $\gamma$ to $\pm 0.01$ precision that can definitively distinguish between General Relativity and leading models of alternative gravity.

Introduction: The Nature of Cosmic Acceleration

Modern cosmology is at a crossroads regarding the cause of the universe's accelerated expansion. The central question is whether this acceleration is driven by a "dark energy" component or if Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) requires modification at cosmological scales. To distinguish between these possibilities, researchers study the growth of structure—the rate at which matter clumps together. This growth is highly sensitive to the underlying theory of gravity.

While expansion history is well-constrained, measuring the inhomogeneous motions of matter, known as peculiar velocities, remains challenging. These velocities are the result of the gravitational "tug" from surrounding large-scale structures. Current surveys using galaxies as tracers are often limited by high "shot noise" or sample variance, hindering their ability to differentiate between GR and alternative models like $f(R)$ or DGP gravity.

Methodology: Measuring the Peculiar Velocity Power Spectrum

The authors employ a Fisher Matrix analysis to forecast the constraints next-generation surveys can place on the gravitational growth index, $\gamma$. A key innovation is the use of Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) as precision distance indicators. Unlike galaxies, which have distance uncertainties of $\sim 20\%$, SNe Ia can achieve $\sim 4\%$ precision.

The analysis focuses on the peculiar velocity power spectrum, $P_{vv}(k)$, which models how velocities correlate across different spatial scales. By incorporating the cross-correlation between SN Ia positions (density) and their velocities—a "multi-tracer" approach—the authors can effectively cancel out sample variance. Furthermore, the study assumes improvements in SN Ia standardization (reducing intrinsic magnitude dispersion from $\sim 0.12$ to $\sim 0.08$ mag) will significantly enhance their utility.

Figure 1: Comparison of the peculiar velocity power spectrum signal (solid lines) against the shot noise for various survey scenarios (dashed/dotted lines). A 10-year survey with improved standardization significantly reduces noise levels.

Forecasted Survey Scenarios

The study primarily evaluates the impact of the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), which is expected to discover approximately 150,000 SNe Ia at $z < 0.2$ and over 500,000 at $z < 0.3$ over a ten-year period. These projections are compared against current efforts like the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) and galaxy-based surveys such as TAIPAN, WALLABY, and DESI. The low-redshift regime ($z < 0.3$) is particularly advantageous for peculiar velocity measurements, where SNe Ia are poised to become the most competitive probes of structural growth.

Results: Precision Constraints on Gravity

The analysis demonstrates that a 10-year LSST survey can achieve a 29-fold reduction in shot noise compared to current state-of-the-art galaxy surveys. This dramatic improvement allows for a constraint on the growth index $\gamma$ of $\pm 0.01$.

Figure 2: Projected constraints on the growth index $\gamma$ as a function of maximum redshift $z_{max}$. The solid black line represents the most optimistic 10-year cross-correlated survey, reaching a precision of ~0.01.

This level of precision is sufficient to definitively distinguish between GR ($\gamma \approx 0.55$) and leading alternatives like DGP gravity ($\gamma \approx 0.68$) or $f(R)$ models ($\gamma \approx 0.42$). The "probative power" of these surveys is found to plateau around $z \sim 0.2$, highlighting the critical importance of the local universe in testing fundamental physics.

Discussion: Limitations and Future Outlook

Realizing these projections requires overcoming several challenges. First, precise host-galaxy redshifts are necessary to convert imaging discoveries into velocity measurements, necessitating significant spectroscopic follow-up resources. Second, the assumed improvement in SN Ia distance precision to $0.08$ mag depends on the development of more sophisticated light-curve models and a deeper understanding of environmental correlations.

Despite these hurdles, the potential for SNe Ia to provide a definitive test of gravity is immense. The authors have released their analysis code to facilitate community testing of various survey strategies, ensuring that the next generation of wide-field surveys can be optimized for this fundamental scientific goal.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the upcoming decade cadenced wide-field imaging surveys will increase the number of identified $z&lt;0.3$ Type~Ia supernovae (SNe~Ia) from the hundreds to the hundreds of thousands. The increase in the number density and solid-angle coverage of SNe~Ia, in parallel with improvements in the standardization of their absolute magnitudes, now make them competitive probes of the growth of structure and hence of gravity. The peculiar velocity power spectrum is sensitive to the growth index $γ$, which captures the effect of gravity on the linear growth of structure through the relation $f=Ω_M^γ$. We present the first projections for the precision in $γ$ for a range of realistic SN peculiar-velocity survey scenarios. In the next decade the peculiar velocities of SNe~Ia in the local $z&lt;0.3$ Universe will provide a measure of $γ$ to $\pm 0.01$ precision that can definitively distinguish between General Relativity and leading models of alternative gravity.
BibTeX
@misc{aldering2019testing,
  author = {G. Aldering and P. Antilogus and A Bhamanyar and S. BenZvi and H. Courtois and T. M. Davis and Hume A. Feldman and S. Ferraro and Satya Gontcho A Gontcho and A. Gontcho and Or Graur and Romain Graziani and J. Guy and Charlie Harper and Renée Hložek and Cullan Howlett and Dragan Huterer and Chen Ju and P.-F. Léget and E. Linder and P. McDonald and J. Nordin and P. Nugent and S. Perlmutter and N. Regnault and M. Rigault and Shafieloo, A. and Slosar, A. and Tully, R. B. and Wang, L. and White, M. and Wood-Vasey, M.},
  title = {{Testing Gravity Using Type Ia Supernovae Discovered by Next-Generation Wide-Field Imaging Surveys}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1903.07652},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.07652},
}
Figure