Testing for synchrony in recruitment among four Lake Michigan fish species

David B. Bunnell, Tomas O. Höök, Cary D. Troy, Wentao Liu, Charles P. Madenjian, Jean V. AdamsCanadian 2016 · DOI

Abstract In the Great Lakes region, multiple fish species display intraspecific spatial synchrony in recruitment success, with interannual climate variation hypothesized as the most likely driver. In Lake Michigan, we evaluated whether climatic or other physical variables could also induce spatial synchrony across multiple species, including bloater (Coregonus hoyi), rainbow smelt (Osmerus mordax), yellow perch (Perca flavescens), and alewife (Alosa pseudoharengus). The residuals from stock–recruitment relationships revealed yellow perch recruitment to be correlated with recruitment of both rainbow smelt ($r = 0.37$) and alewife ($r = 0.36$). Across all four species, higher than expected recruitment occurred in 5 years between 1978 and 1987 and then switched to lower than expected recruitment in 5 years between 1996 and 2004. Generalized additive models revealed warmer spring and summer water temperatures and lower wind speeds corresponded to higher than expected recruitment for the nearshore-spawning species, and overall variance explained ranged from 14% (yellow perch) to 61% (alewife). For all species but rainbow smelt, higher recruitment also occurred in extremely high or low years of the North Atlantic Oscillation index. Future development of indices that describe the physical Great Lakes environment could improve understanding of how climate can synchronize fish populations within and across species.

Introduction

In fisheries biology, "recruitment"—the number of young fish that survive to join the adult population—is often considered the most critical metric for sustainable management. While scientists have long observed the "Moran effect," where regional climate synchronizes the populations of a single species across disparate geographic locations, the extent to which climate synchronizes different species within the same ecosystem remains a complex question. This study investigates whether four major fish species in Lake Michigan—alewife, bloater, rainbow smelt, and yellow perch—exhibit synchronous recruitment driven by broad climatic shifts and local physical variables.

Methodology

To isolate the influence of environmental factors from parental stock size, the researchers employed a multi-step statistical framework:

  1. Stock-Recruit Modeling: Ricker and Beverton-Holt models were used to account for the "parent effect." By calculating the residuals (the variation remaining after accounting for egg production), the team isolated the "environmental noise" affecting larval and juvenile survival.
  2. Synchrony Analysis: Pearson correlations and randomization tests were applied to these residuals to determine if recruitment moved in tandem across the four species.
  3. Generalized Additive Models (GAMs): To identify specific drivers, GAMs were utilized to detect potentially non-linear relationships, such as species thriving at specific temperature thresholds.
  4. Periodicity: Power Spectral Density (PSD) analysis was used to identify cyclical patterns in recruitment over a 39-year time series (1973–2011).

Data was sourced from the USGS Great Lakes Science Center annual autumn bottom trawl surveys, alongside lake-wide physical data (ice cover, lake levels, wind speed, surface temperature) and regional climate indices (NAO, ENSO, and PDO).

Key Insights and Results

The Nearshore Spawner Guild

The study identified a clear "Nearshore Spawner Guild" consisting of yellow perch, alewife, and rainbow smelt. These species showed the strongest recruitment synchrony, likely because they spawn in nearshore waters or tributaries where larvae are highly vulnerable to coastal temperature fluctuations and wind-driven currents. Yellow perch recruitment was significantly correlated with both rainbow smelt ($r = 0.37$) and alewife ($r = 0.36$).

Decadal Regime Shifts

A striking temporal shift was observed in the data. Between 1978 and 1987, all four species experienced higher-than-expected recruitment in five separate years. This period of productivity was followed by a significant decline; between 1996 and 2004, the species shared five years of lower-than-expected recruitment. This suggests a large-scale regime shift in the Lake Michigan ecosystem, where the environmental "window" for successful recruitment has narrowed or shifted.

Climatic Drivers and Teleconnections

Warmer spring and summer water temperatures combined with lower wind speeds were the most consistent predictors of high recruitment for the nearshore species. Interestingly, the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO)—a climate index based on atmospheric pressure in the North Atlantic—showed a "U-shaped" relationship with recruitment for three of the four species. Extreme phases of the NAO (either strongly positive or negative) were associated with better recruitment than neutral years, likely due to the index's influence on winter severity and the timing of spring warming in the Great Lakes region.

The Deep-Water Exception

Bloater served as the primary outlier in the study. Spawning in deep offshore waters, bloater recruitment was the least synchronized with the other three species. This suggests that the deep-water environment provides a buffer, insulating these populations from the surface-level climatic drivers that dictate the success of nearshore-spawning species.

Discussion and Future Directions

While physical drivers explained a significant portion of recruitment variance—up to 61% for alewife—the models for yellow perch (14%) suggest that other factors are at play. The researchers noted that Lake Michigan has undergone profound biological changes during the study period, including the invasion of dreissenid mussels and shifts in top-predator densities (e.g., Pacific salmon). These biotic factors likely interact with physical drivers to influence survival.

The study concludes that while global indices like the NAO are valuable, there is a pressing need for Great Lakes-specific physical indices. Developing metrics for upwelling frequency, precise thermal phenology, and plankton bloom timing will be essential for predicting how fish populations will respond to future climate instability.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the Great Lakes region, multiple fish species display intraspecific spatial synchrony in recruitment success, with interannual climate variation hypothesized as the most likely driver. In Lake Michigan, we evaluated whether climatic or other physical variables could also induce spatial synchrony across multiple species, including bloater (Coregonus hoyi), rainbow smelt (Osmerus mordax), yellow perch (Perca flavescens), and alewife (Alosa pseudoharengus). The residuals from stock–recruitment relationships revealed yellow perch recruitment to be correlated with recruitment of both rainbow smelt (r = 0.37) and alewife (r = 0.36). Across all four species, higher than expected recruitment occurred in 5 years between 1978 and 1987 and then switched to lower than expected recruitment in 5 years between 1996 and 2004. Generalized additive models revealed warmer spring and summer water temperatures and lower wind speeds corresponded to higher than expected recruitment for the nearshore-spawning species, and overall variance explained ranged from 14% (yellow perch) to 61% (alewife). For all species but rainbow smelt, higher recruitment also occurred in extremely high or low years of the North Atlantic Oscillation index. Future development of indices that describe the physical Great Lakes environment could improve understanding of how climate can synchronize fish populations within and across species.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bunnell2016testing,
  author = {David B. Bunnell and Tomas O. Höök and Cary D. Troy and Wentao Liu and Charles P. Madenjian and Jean V. Adams},
  title = {{Testing for synchrony in recruitment among four Lake Michigan fish species}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1139/cjfas-2015-0534},
}
Figure