Test-Time Communication in Trading Agent Swarms

Avid Fayaz, Harry Zhang, Håvard Alstadheim, Erik Nordlöf, Vilhelm Karlin, André SilvaarXiv 2026 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates how test-time communication affects a "swarm" of 200 independent LLM trading agents operating in a noisy, delayed-feedback environment. The authors find that while communication facilitates the rapid spread of social conventions and wording, it also significantly increases "herding" behavior—leading agents to hold identical, risky portfolios—and often results in the loss of critical nuances as information is relayed between peers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Most research on multi-agent communication focuses on "team" tasks with shared goals and immediate feedback (like coding or games). Trading is different: it’s a zero-sum environment where agents manage independent accounts, and the "correctness" of a decision is only revealed by the market much later and with significant noise.

The authors tackle the reflection problem: if two agents buy the same stock, did they copy each other (peer influence), or did they just read the same news (common inputs)? In a trading swarm, convergence isn't necessarily a success—it’s a systemic risk. If every agent "herds" into the same position, they all fail together.

Methods

The researchers deployed 200 trading agents (called "managers") from four model families (Opus 5.5, GPT-6.1 Sol, Grok 4.6, and DeepSeek V4 Pro) over seven US trading days in October 2026.

They tested five communication regimes to see how different "social" structures affected behavior:

  1. Isolated: No communication (the baseline).
  2. Competitive Board: A shared message board where agents see individual ranks and relative scores.
  3. Collaborative Board: Shared board with a team-wide score.
  4. Board with Pings: Collaborative board plus the ability to "wake" a peer with a direct request.
  5. Peer Memory: Agents can read each other's published notes but cannot message directly.
The five communication regimes tested in the study.

To isolate peer influence from common inputs, they used a "morning queue" natural experiment. By comparing pairs of agents that started their work cycles at the exact same time (and thus couldn't see each other's fresh posts) against pairs that started far apart, they could statistically measure the "excess" similarity caused specifically by reading a peer's message.

Datasets

The study used live US market data from October 1 to 9, 2026. Each of the 200 agents started with a paper trading account of USD 100,000. The primary benchmark for evaluation was SPY (an ETF tracking the S&P 500). Unlike many AI finance papers that use historical backtesting, this study ran in real-time against live prices, though orders were "paper" (simulated) to avoid moving actual market prices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Herding is the Default: Even without talking, isolated agents often converged on the same stocks (like TSM) simply because they were using similar models and reading the same news. This highlights the necessity of a "no-peer baseline" in agent research; without it, you might mistake common sense for peer influence.
  • Wording Spreads Faster than Actions: Agents are highly susceptible to "social contagion" in their language. Seeing a peer's post made an agent 7 percentage points more likely to reuse specific eight-word phrases (like "verify before use" or "not a trade instruction").
  • The "Telephone Game" Effect: As claims passed through the swarm, they suffered from qualification loss. A nuanced research finding ("yields might stay in this range today") often became a certain fact ("yields are in this range") when relayed by a second or third agent.
  • Framing Matters: Competitive framing (showing individual ranks) caused some models, particularly Opus, to withhold information about their positions to protect their "edge."
A visualization of how wording and phrases spread through the different agent groups.

Key Results

  • Increased Overlap: In two of the four model families, communication significantly boosted portfolio overlap. For DeepSeek, overlap jumped from 14% in isolation to 30-40% in communicating groups.
  • Synchronized Selling: Communicating groups were much more likely to "exit" positions in lockstep. Between 40% and 91% of sales in communicating groups happened within 30 minutes of a groupmate's sale, compared to just 14-53% in isolated groups.
  • Performance: Most accounts underperformed the SPY benchmark. Groups that converged heavily on semiconductor stocks (like TSM and MU) suffered large collective losses when those stocks dipped.
Returns for every account across the different regimes, showing how groups tended to perform similarly.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short Duration: Seven trading days is a small window for evaluating investment performance.
  • Single-Group Confound: Each model/regime combination was only run once, meaning a single "influential" agent could skew the results for an entire group.
  • Framing Dampeners: The experiment explicitly told agents that peer content was "untrusted social information," which may have suppressed even higher levels of cooperation or copying.

Future work could explore explicit task allocation (e.g., "Agent A researches tech, Agent B researches energy") to see if swarms can move beyond simple herding toward a more efficient division of labor.

Summary updated

Abstract

Communication between agents has mostly been studied on tasks with a shared objective and fast, clear feedback. Trading has neither: each agent manages its own account, with decisions being scored by markets late and noisily. A trading swarm is thus a population of independent decision-makers rather than a team, for which convergence is a risk and not the goal. We ran 200 agents from four model families in groups of ten under five communication regimes, from isolation to message boards and shared notes, over seven US trading days (1 to 9 October 2026), logging everything each agent read before every decision. In two of the four families, communicating groups came to hold far more of the same stocks than the isolated group. A group's return was largely the return on what its members held in common. Seeing a post from a groupmate made an agent 7 percentage points more likely to reuse an eight-word phrase from it. Agents that started too close together to see each other's posts shared such a phrase in 14% of cases, the rate that common inputs produce. Seeing the post did not detectably change that morning's trades. Case studies traced the adoption of positions and decision rules over subsequent days, and communicating groups sold in step more often than isolated ones. Because isolated groups also converged on the same stocks, sometimes completely, assessments of herding need to measure excess convergence relative to a no-peer baseline.
BibTeX
@misc{fayaz2026test,
  author = {Avid Fayaz and Harry Zhang and Håvard Alstadheim and Erik Nordlöf and Vilhelm Karlin and André Silva},
  title = {{Test-Time Communication in Trading Agent Swarms}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2610.37448},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.37448},
}
Figure