Tertiary lymphoid structures accompanied by fibrillary matrix morphology impact anti-tumor immunity in basal cell carcinomas

Candice Byers, Melissa Gill, Nicholas R. Kurtansky, Christi Alessi‐Fox, Maggie Harman, Miguel Córdova, Salvador González, Pascale Guitera, Veronica Rotemberg, Ashfaq A. Marghoob, Chih-Shan Jason Chen, Jennifer Dy, Kıvanç Köse, Milind Rajadhyaksha, Aditi SahuFrontiers in Medicine 2022 · DOI

This research paper, published in Frontiers in Medicine, investigates the microenvironmental factors that dictate immune response in Basal Cell Carcinoma (BCC). The authors demonstrate that the presence of mature immune "hubs" called Tertiary Lymphoid Structures (TLS) and the specific physical architecture of the surrounding collagen matrix are critical determinants of how many T-cells actually reach the tumor.

TL;DR

This study reveals that in Basal Cell Carcinoma, the effectiveness of the immune system depends not just on the presence of Tertiary Lymphoid Structures (TLS), but on the "permissiveness" of the surrounding fibrillary matrix. Mature TLS and a matrix characterized by longer fibers and more "gaps" (high lacunarity) are significantly associated with higher counts of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Basal Cell Carcinoma (BCC) is the most common cancer globally. While generally slow-growing, some cases require advanced treatment like immunotherapy. In many other cancers, the presence of TLS—ectopic lymphoid organs that form at sites of chronic inflammation—is a strong predictor of a good response to therapy.

However, the role of TLS in BCC was previously unstudied. Furthermore, researchers have often noticed a "heterogeneity" problem: even when TLS are present, the number of lymphocytes that actually infiltrate the tumor (TILs) varies wildly. This paper addresses whether the extracellular matrix (ECM)—the physical scaffolding surrounding the tumor—acts as a gatekeeper that either facilitates or hinders immune cell migration from the TLS to the tumor.

Methods

The researchers analyzed 30 distinct BCC lesions from 22 patients. They employed a multi-modal imaging and computational approach:

  • Dual Immunohistochemistry (IHC): Used to label CD3+ (T-cells) and CD20+ (B-cells) to identify and stage TLS maturation (categorized as "Aggregate" or the more mature "Primary" stage).
  • Matrix Quantification: Using H&E stained sections, they used the Twombli plugin (for Fiji/ImageJ) to quantify 13 different morphological features of the fibrillary matrix, such as fiber length, alignment, density, and lacunarity (a measure of "gaps" or space within the matrix).
  • Computational Clustering: They used Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Hierarchical Clustering on Principal Components (HCPC) to group tumors based on their matrix patterns rather than just their clinical diagnosis.

Datasets

The study utilized a specialized dataset of primary BCC biopsies (untreated and unbiopsied) recruited from the Dermatology Service at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC). The dataset included various BCC subtypes: nodular, infiltrative, and superficial.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nodular BCCs are Immune "Hotspots": TLS were significantly enriched in tumors with a nodular component (10.29 times higher odds).
  • Maturation is Key: Not all TLS are equal. "Primary" TLS (which are more organized and contain follicular dendritic cells) were associated with significantly higher TIL counts than simple "Aggregate" TLS.
  • The Matrix as a Gatekeeper: The researchers identified two distinct matrix "clusters."
    • Cluster 1 (Permissive): Characterized by increased fiber length and high lacunarity (more gaps). This environment was associated with high TIL counts.
  • Cluster 2 (Restrictive): Characterized by high density and high alignment of fibers. This dense "wall" appeared to impede the ability of lymphocytes to move from the TLS into the tumor nest.
  • Matrix Overrides TLS Stage: Interestingly, a "permissive" matrix could lead to high TIL counts even if the nearby TLS was less mature, suggesting the physical environment is a critical independent variable in anti-tumor immunity.

Key Results

  • TLS Prevalence: TLS were found in 19 out of 30 (63%) BCC lesions.
  • TIL Counts: Tumors proximal to Primary TLS had a mean TIL count of 38.1, compared to 17.6 for Aggregate TLS and only 7.98 for tumors with no TLS evidence (p < 0.001).
  • Matrix Impact: Tumors in "Fibrillary Cluster 1" (permissive) showed significantly higher TIL counts than Cluster 2 (p < 0.0001).
  • Tumor Killing: The presence of mature TLS and high TIL counts correlated with "tumor killing" (active regression), providing a functional link between these structural features and clinical outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The study was limited to 30 lesions, which may not capture the full diversity of BCC.
  • 2D vs. 3D: The analysis was performed on single 2D tissue sections. The authors note that 3D spatial organization might provide a more accurate picture of how TLS and matrix interact.
  • Marker Depth: The study only used CD3 and CD20. Future work should look at specific immune subsets (like T-regulatory cells or plasma cells) and use spatial transcriptomics to understand the signaling pathways involved.
  • Clinical Application: While these findings highlight the matrix as a potential therapeutic target (e.g., "softening" the stroma to allow immune access), more research is needed to see if this can be translated into clinical practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tertiary lymphoid structures (TLS) are specialized lymphoid formations that serve as local repertoire of T- and B-cells at sites of chronic inflammation, autoimmunity, and cancer. While presence of TLS has been associated with improved response to immune checkpoint blockade therapies and overall outcomes in several cancers, its prognostic value in basal cell carcinoma (BCC) has not been investigated. Herein, we determined the prognostic impact of TLS by relating its prevalence and maturation with outcome measures of anti-tumor immunity, namely tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) and tumor killing. In 30 distinct BCCs, we show the presence of TLS was significantly enriched in tumors harboring a nodular component and more mature primary TLS was associated with TIL counts. Moreover, assessment of the fibrillary matrix surrounding tumors showed discrete morphologies significantly associated with higher TIL counts, critically accounting for heterogeneity in TIL count distribution within TLS maturation stages. Specifically, increased length of fibers and lacunarity of the matrix with concomitant reduction in density and alignment of fibers were present surrounding tumors displaying high TIL counts. Given the interest in inducing TLS formation as a therapeutic intervention as well as its documented prognostic value, elucidating potential impediments to the ability of TLS in driving anti-tumor immunity within the tumor microenvironment warrants further investigation. These results begin to address and highlight the need to integrate stromal features which may present a hindrance to TLS formation and/or effective function as a mediator of immunotherapy response.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{byers2022tertiary,
  author = {Candice Byers and Melissa Gill and Nicholas R. Kurtansky and Christi Alessi‐Fox and Maggie Harman and Miguel Córdova and Salvador González and Pascale Guitera and Veronica Rotemberg and Ashfaq A. Marghoob and Chih-Shan Jason Chen and Jennifer Dy and Kıvanç Köse and Milind Rajadhyaksha and Aditi Sahu},
  title = {{Tertiary lymphoid structures accompanied by fibrillary matrix morphology impact anti-tumor immunity in basal cell carcinomas}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2022.981074},
}
Figure