Ternary superhydrides for high-temperature superconductivity at low pressures

Pengfei Shan, Liang Ma, Jinguang ChengNational 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers are exploring ternary superhydrides as a promising pathway to achieving room-temperature superconductivity (RTSC) at more accessible pressures. This perspective highlights recent experimental successes and theoretical advancements in this field, while also outlining the significant challenges that remain in designing and stabilizing these exotic materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The dream of room-temperature superconductivity (RTSC) has captivated physicists since the discovery of superconductivity in 1911. While pure metallic hydrogen was once considered the most promising candidate, achieving its metallized state requires pressures exceeding 400 GPa, far beyond current experimental capabilities. In 2004, Ashcroft proposed a paradigm shift: instead of pure hydrogen, focus on hydrogen-rich materials (hydrides) that can achieve high critical temperatures ($T_c$) at lower, more attainable pressures due to a "chemical precompression" effect. This paper reviews the progress in this area, specifically focusing on ternary superhydrides, which offer even greater structural diversity and potential for higher $T_c$ values at reduced pressures compared to their binary counterparts.

Methods

This paper is a perspective piece, summarizing existing research rather than presenting new experimental or computational methods. It discusses:

  • Theoretical Predictions: Computational algorithms are crucial for guiding the search for new ternary superhydrides by predicting stable structures and their superconducting properties.
  • Experimental Synthesis: High-pressure techniques, particularly those utilizing diamond anvil cells, are employed to synthesize these materials. The use of solid hydrogen sources like BH3NH3 has been instrumental in enabling the synthesis of complex hydrides.
  • Characterization: Techniques like resistance measurements are used to determine the superconducting critical temperature ($T_c$). However, the paper notes significant challenges in definitively proving superconductivity (zero resistance and Meissner effect) due to multiphase samples and limitations in structural characterization under extreme pressures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ternary Hydrides as the Next Frontier: While binary hydrides like LaH$_{10}$ have achieved impressive $T_c$ values (up to 250 K), ternary superhydrides are expected to offer a richer landscape of structural possibilities and potentially higher $T_c$ values at even lower pressures.
  • Chemical Precompression is Key: The concept of using surrounding elements to effectively "precompress" hydrogen within a hydride structure is the fundamental principle enabling high $T_c$ at pressures significantly lower than those required for pure hydrogen metallization.
  • Disordered vs. Ordered Ternaries: The paper distinguishes between "pseudo-ternary" hydrides where different metal cations are randomly distributed (e.g., (La, Ce)H$_9$) and "true" stoichiometric ternary hydrides with ordered structures (e.g., LaBeH$_8$). Both approaches show promise.
  • Precursor Synthesis is Critical: The success of synthesizing ternary hydrides hinges on the careful selection and preparation of precursors, often involving disordered alloys created through melting or sputtering, or ordered intermetallic compounds.
  • Significant Challenges Remain: Despite progress, definitively proving superconductivity in these materials under extreme pressure is difficult due to multiphase samples and limitations in in-situ structural and property characterization.

Key Results

The paper highlights several key experimental and theoretical results:

  • Binary Hydride Milestones: It references binary hydrides like LaH$_{10}$ (250 K at 170 GPa), YH$_9$ (243 K at 201 GPa), and CaH$_6$ (215 K at 172 GPa) as benchmarks.
  • Ternary Alloy Successes: Synthesis of (La, Ce)H$_9$ at 113 GPa showed a $T_c$ of 176 K, significantly higher than binary La/Ce-H hydrides at similar pressures. Similarly, (La, Y)H$_{10}$ and (La, Al)H$_{10}$ have been synthesized.
  • Ordered Ternary Achievement: The synthesis of LaBeH$_8$ at 110-130 GPa, a true stoichiometric ternary hydride, demonstrated a moderate $T_c$ of 110 K at a relatively low pressure of 80 GPa.
  • Theoretical Predictions: Theoretical work has predicted ternary hydrides like Li$_2$MgH$_{16}$ with estimated $T_c$ values as high as ~473 K at 250 GPa, and LaBeH$_8$ with a $T_c$ of ~185 K.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Challenges: The paper emphasizes the difficulty in definitively proving superconductivity due to multiphase samples and the lack of direct experimental determination of crystal structures and chemical compositions under megabar pressures.
  • Need for Advanced Techniques: Future work should focus on developing novel in-situ high-pressure techniques, such as advanced diffraction methods using synchrotron radiation for light-element compounds and micro-magnetic measurements for detecting the Meissner effect.
  • Rational Design and Stabilization: The ultimate goal is to develop strategies for the rational design and experimental stabilization of superhydrides with even higher $T_c$ values and/or at significantly reduced pressures, aiming for near-ambient RTSC.

Summary updated

Abstract

Focusing on the ternary hydrides, the new hope of Room-Temperature Superconductivity, this perspective delves into the research background, highlights current challenges, and illuminates promising avenues for future studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shan2024ternary,
  author = {Pengfei Shan and Liang Ma and Jinguang Cheng},
  title = {{Ternary superhydrides for high-temperature superconductivity at low pressures}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwae003},
}
Figure