Terminal arbors of single ON‐center and OFF‐center X and Y retinal ganglion cell axons within the ferret's lateral geniculate nucleus

Anna Wang Roe, Preston E. Garraghty, Mriganka SurThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 1989 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of retinal ganglion cell axons (X and Y) connect within the ferret's lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN). They found that X axons are highly specific, segregating ON and OFF signals into distinct sublaminae, forming a clear pathway for visual information. In contrast, Y axons are more divergent and less specific, suggesting a different role in visual processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The visual system is organized into parallel pathways that process different aspects of visual information. In mammals, retinal ganglion cells are broadly classified into X and Y types, which are known to have distinct physiological properties and project to different areas of the brain, including the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN). The LGN itself is organized into layers and sublayers, with specific layers receiving input from different eyes and sublayers containing cells with ON-center or OFF-center receptive fields. A key question is how the anatomical projections of X and Y axons within the LGN contribute to this functional organization, particularly the segregation of ON and OFF information. This paper aims to map the precise termination patterns of individual X and Y axons within the ferret's LGN to understand their role in maintaining this segregation.

Methods

The researchers used a combination of electrophysiology and neuroanatomy. They first identified and classified retinal ganglion cell axons in ferrets as either X or Y based on physiological criteria, such as their response linearity to visual stimuli, latency to optic chiasm stimulation, and receptive field size. Once identified, they injected these axons with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) to label their entire terminal arbor within the LGN. These labeled axons were then meticulously reconstructed using camera lucida drawings and high-power microscopy. The researchers analyzed the laminar and sublaminar distribution of these arbors, as well as their size, bouton density, and overall morphology.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses data collected from experiments on 15 normal adult ferrets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • X axons are the architects of ON/OFF segregation: The most striking finding is that X axons are remarkably precise in their targeting. ON-center X axons exclusively innervate the inner sublamina of their respective LGN layers, while OFF-center X axons target the outer sublamina. This anatomical segregation directly underlies the functional segregation of ON and OFF pathways within the LGN.
  • Y axons are the "broadcasters": Y axons, in contrast, exhibit much larger and more variable terminal arbors. They often innervate multiple regions within the LGN, including different laminae, interlaminar zones, and even the medial interlaminar nucleus. Crucially, Y axons frequently do not respect the ON/OFF sublaminae, often having boutons in both.
  • Divergence vs. Specificity: The study highlights a fundamental difference in the processing strategies of X and Y pathways. The X pathway is characterized by high specificity, ensuring clear segregation of visual information. The Y pathway, on the other hand, is characterized by high divergence, suggesting a role in integrating information or relaying it more broadly.
  • Potential for visual cortex ON/OFF segregation relies on X axons: The clear segregation of ON and OFF channels by X axons in the LGN is presented as the anatomical substrate for the continued segregation of these channels up to the visual cortex.
  • Ferrets as a model: The ferret's LGN structure, with its distinct ON/OFF sublaminae in layers A and A1, makes it a valuable model for studying the anatomical basis of visual processing segregation, similar to cats but with some unique features.

Key Results

  • X Axon Termination: Contralateral X axons terminate in lamina A, ipsilateral X axons in lamina A1. Within these laminae, ON-center X axons terminate in the inner sublamina, and OFF-center X axons in the outer sublamina. No X axon branches were found to innervate the medial interlaminar nucleus or the midbrain.
  • Y Axon Termination: Y axons have larger and more variable arbors. Generally, ON-center Y axons innervate the inner sublamina and OFF-center Y axons the outer sublamina within layers A and A1, but they frequently innervate both sublaminae and can have boutons in the "inappropriate" lamina. Y axons also terminate in dorsal C laminae, interlaminar zones, and the medial interlaminar nucleus. Branches of Y axons were observed to course towards the midbrain.
  • Segregation Index: X axons showed very high segregation indices (above 70 for most), indicating strict confinement to their appropriate sublamina. Y axons, however, generally had low segregation indices (less than 70), demonstrating a lack of strict sublaminar specificity.
  • Axon Diameter: Y axons had significantly larger parent axon diameters (mean 2.9 µm) compared to X axons (mean 1.6 µm).
  • Arbor Volume and Bouton Number: Y axon arbors occupied significantly larger volumes and contained more boutons than X axons.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sublaminar Border Ambiguity: The authors acknowledge that sublaminar borders in the ferret LGN are not always clearly discernible, which can lead to lower estimates of the segregation index for some axons.
  • Limited Ipsilateral Y Axons: The study had a very small sample of ipsilaterally projecting Y axons, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions about their termination patterns.
  • Potential for Subclasses of Y Cells: The significant variability in Y axon arbors suggests the possibility of multiple subclasses of Y cells in the ferret retina, which could lead to different projection patterns.
  • Developmental Plasticity: The authors propose that developmental factors and environmental influences might play a significant role in the observed variability of Y axon arbors, a phenomenon less pronounced in X axons. Future work could explore these developmental aspects in more detail.
  • Functional Implications of Y Axon Divergence: While the study provides the anatomical basis, further research is needed to fully elucidate the functional consequences of Y axon divergence and their role in visual processing compared to the more specific X pathway.

Summary updated

Abstract

The lateral geniculate nucleus of the ferret contains not only eye-specific layers, but a further subdivision of layers A and A1 into inner and outer sublaminae that contain, respectively, ON-center and OFF-center cells (Stryker and Zahs, '83). To study how the arbors of single retinal ganglion cell axons correlate with these cellular divisions, we have examined the morphology of physiologically classified retinal axons in the ferret's lateral geniculate nucleus. As in cats, we could classify retinal axons as X or Y on the basis of a number of physiological criteria. X and Y axons have distinct patterns of termination in the lateral geniculate nucleus. Contralateral X axons innervate lamina A and ipsilateral axons lamina A1. X axons are further segregated in these laminae so that ON-center axons terminate in the inner sublamina, and OFF-center axons in the outer sublamina. We did not observe any branches of X axons innervating the medial interlaminar nucleus or the midbrain. Y axons have much larger terminal arbors and exhibit greater variation in their terminations. Generally, within layers A and A1, ON-center Y axons innervate the inner sublamina and OFF-center Y axons innervate the outer sublamina. However, they often innervate both sublaminae, and occasionally have a few boutons in the inappropriate lamina as well. Y axons also terminate in the dorsal C laminae, the interlaminar zones, and the media interlaminar nucleus; branches of these axons course toward the midbrain, presumably to innervate the superior colliculus. Thus, whereas the Y pathway in the ferret is one of high divergence, the X pathway appears to be the substrate for segregated ON and OFF channels through the lateral geniculate nucleus.
BibTeX
@article{roe1989terminal,
  author = {Anna Wang Roe and Preston E. Garraghty and Mriganka Sur},
  title = {{Terminal arbors of single ON‐center and OFF‐center X and Y retinal ganglion cell axons within the ferret's lateral geniculate nucleus}},
  journal = {The Journal of Comparative Neurology},
  year = {1989},
  doi = {10.1002/cne.902880203},
}
Figure