Terahertz electrodynamics in a zero-field Wigner crystal

Su-Di Chen, Ruishi Qi, Ha-Leem Kim, Qixin Feng, Rong Xia, Dishan Abeysinghe, Jingxu Xie, Takashi Taniguchi, Kenji Watanabe, Dung‐Hai Lee, Rui WangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In clean two-dimensional (2D) systems, electrons are expected to self-organize into a regular lattice—a Wigner crystal—when their mutual Coulomb repulsion overwhelms their kinetic energy. While evidence for such crystals has been reported across various platforms, the AC conductivity of a zero-field Wigner crystal, a key observable characterizing its electrodynamics, has remained elusive. Here, we utilize an ultrasensitive on-chip terahertz (THz) spectroscopy technique to probe the AC conductivity in electrostatically gated monolayer $\text{MoSe}_2$ encapsulated in hexagonal boron nitride. We observe a sub-THz resonance corresponding to the pinning mode of a zero-field Wigner crystal, with frequencies orders of magnitude higher than those observed under high magnetic fields. Our findings reveal that moderate disorder stabilizes the Wigner crystal and that the transition to an electron liquid involves a coexistence of the pinning mode with a growing Drude component. This study elucidates the low-energy electrodynamics of zero-field Wigner crystals and establishes on-chip THz spectroscopy as a powerful tool for investigating correlated quantum phases.

Introduction

In 1934, Eugene Wigner predicted that at sufficiently low densities, electrons in a 2D plane would "freeze" into a rigid, triangular lattice to minimize their electrostatic potential energy. While this state, the Wigner crystal (WC), is a fundamental concept in condensed matter physics, observing it at zero magnetic field is exceptionally challenging. Magnetic fields typically help stabilize WCs by quenching the electrons' kinetic energy, but the zero-field crystal represents a more "intrinsic" state of electronic matter, closely linked to the density-driven metal-insulator transition.

Previous studies have provided static evidence of zero-field WCs through optical spectroscopy and microscopy. However, the dynamic response—how the crystal lattice vibrates or "jiggles" in response to an alternating electric field—has never been measured. This dynamic signature, known as the pinning mode, is essential for understanding the stability and melting of the electronic solid.

Experimental Methodology: On-Chip THz Spectroscopy

To capture the weak signals from a single atomic layer of $\text{MoSe}_2$, the researchers developed an ultrasensitive on-chip THz spectroscopy platform. Standard THz techniques lack the sensitivity required for microscopic samples, and microwave tools cannot reach the high frequencies expected for zero-field pinning modes.

The Device Architecture

The team integrated the $\text{MoSe}_2$ flake into a tapered coplanar stripline (CPS) waveguide. By tapering the waveguide down to a sub-micron gap, the THz electric field was concentrated directly onto the sample, significantly enhancing absorption. Photoconductive switches (emitter and detector) were fabricated directly on the chip to enable time-domain measurements of THz pulses.

To control electron density, the researchers employed an Indium Tin Oxide (ITO) backgate. ITO was chosen for its unique properties: it has an extremely fast electron scattering time (femtosecond scale), meaning its own THz response is "flat" and does not obscure the sample's signal. This setup achieved a conductivity sensitivity of $1\ \mu\text{S}$, a ten-fold improvement over previous on-chip methods.

Key Findings

Discovery of the Pinning Mode

The defining discovery of this research is a distinct resonance peak centered around 0.5 THz. This is the "pinning mode," where the electron lattice oscillates within the potential wells created by local disorder (impurities). Notably, this frequency is orders of magnitude higher than the pinning modes observed in magnetic-field-induced Wigner crystals. Without the Lorentz force to slow them down, the electrons in a zero-field crystal respond to the disorder potential with much higher stiffness.

Scaling Laws and Theory

The pinning frequency ($f_p$) was found to scale with electron density ($n$) according to a power law of $n^{0.37}$. This result is in remarkable agreement with the theoretical prediction of $3/8$ (0.375) for zero-field Wigner crystals in the presence of weak disorder. This scaling provides strong evidence that the observed resonance is indeed the collective oscillation of a Wigner lattice.

The Role of Disorder

By comparing two devices—one with moderate disorder (Device 1) and one with high mobility/low disorder (Device 2)—the researchers found that disorder actually acts as a stabilizer. In the cleaner Device 2, the Wigner crystal melted at a lower electron density than in the more disordered Device 1. This suggests that local impurities help "anchor" the crystal, allowing it to persist in regimes where it might otherwise melt into a liquid.

Phase Coexistence and Melting

As the electron density increases, the system undergoes a metal-insulator transition. The THz spectra revealed that this transition is not instantaneous. Instead, the pinning mode (representing the solid) coexists with a growing Drude component (representing the liquid). This observation supports the theory of a "microemulsion" phase—a slushy mixture of electronic solid and liquid—near the melting point. The transition occurred at a Coulomb-to-kinetic energy ratio ($r_s$) of approximately 25 for the disordered device and 43 for the cleaner device.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work provides the first look at the high-frequency electrodynamics of the zero-field Wigner crystal. By identifying the pinning mode and its scaling behavior, the researchers have confirmed long-standing theoretical predictions and revealed the complex nature of the electronic melting process.

Beyond Wigner crystals, the on-chip THz spectroscopy technique developed here offers a "universal probe" for other elusive quantum states. Future research may apply this method to study excitonic insulators, fractional Chern insulators, and other correlated phases in 2D materials that have previously been difficult to characterize dynamically.

Summary updated

Abstract

In clean two-dimensional (2D) systems, electrons are expected to self-organize into a regular lattice, a Wigner crystal, when their mutual Coulomb repulsion overwhelms kinetic energy. Understanding the Wigner crystal at zero magnetic field is a long-sought goal in physics, thanks to its fundamental simplicity and possible connection to the density-driven metal-insulator transition. To date, evidence for such a crystal has been reported across various platforms. However, the AC conductivity of a zero-field Wigner crystal, a key observable characterizing its electrodynamics, has never been measured. Here, we develop an ultrasensitive on-chip terahertz (THz) spectroscopy technique to probe the AC conductivity in electrostatically gated monolayer MoSe2 encapsulated in hexagonal boron nitride. We observe a sub-THz resonance corresponding to the pinning mode of a zero-field Wigner crystal, whose frequency is orders of magnitude higher than those under high magnetic fields. Using the pinning mode as an indicator, we reveal that moderate disorder notably stabilizes the Wigner crystal. With increasing density towards melting, we find that the pinning mode of the Wigner crystal coexists with a growing Drude component characteristic of an electron liquid, and the competition between these two components in the conductivity spectra leads to the insulator-metal transition of the 2D electron system. Our findings not only elucidate the low-energy electrodynamics of a zero-field Wigner crystal, but also establish on-chip THz spectroscopy as a powerful probe for correlated quantum phases in two-dimensional materials.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2025terahertz,
  author = {Su-Di Chen and Ruishi Qi and Ha-Leem Kim and Qixin Feng and Rong Xia and Dishan Abeysinghe and Jingxu Xie and Takashi Taniguchi and Kenji Watanabe and Dung‐Hai Lee and Rui Wang},
  title = {{Terahertz electrodynamics in a zero-field Wigner crystal}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2509.10624},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.10624},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure