Terahertz Attenuated Total Reflection Spectral Response and Signal Enhancement via Plasmonic Enhanced Sensor for Eye Drop Detection

Eugene Soh Jia Hao, Nan Zhang, Qiang Zhu, Xizu Wang, Karen Ke LinSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel terahertz (THz) attenuated total reflection (ATR) spectroscopy method enhanced by graphene oxide (GO) and carbon nanotube (CNT) hybrid sensors for the rapid, non-destructive detection of eye drop quality. By leveraging plasmonic effects at the sensor interface, the technique significantly amplifies spectral responses, enabling differentiation between various commercial eye drop formulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining the quality and stability of pharmaceutical products, especially eye drops, is crucial for patient safety and therapeutic efficacy. Chronic eye conditions necessitate long-term use of eye drops, making them susceptible to contamination and degradation due to environmental factors. Current analytical methods for assessing eye drop quality are often time-consuming, complex, and may require sample preparation, hindering rapid, on-site quality control. A significant challenge in developing new detection techniques is achieving a sufficient spectral response, particularly for aqueous samples like eye drops, where water's strong THz absorption can mask subtle signals.

Methods

The researchers employed Terahertz Attenuated Total Reflection (THz-ATR) spectroscopy, a technique well-suited for analyzing liquid samples due to its sensitivity to interface phenomena and minimal sample preparation requirements. The core innovation lies in the development of plasmonic enhanced sensors. These sensors consist of a high-resistivity silicon substrate coated with thin films of:

  • Graphene Oxide (GO): Known for its excellent dispersibility in water and functional groups that can be modified.
  • Carbon Nanotubes (CNTs): Possessing high carrier mobility.
  • A Hybrid GO+CNT composite: Designed to leverage synergistic plasmonic effects.

These modified substrates were used as the ATR prism interface. When an eye drop sample is placed on the sensor, the evanescent wave generated at the prism-sample interface interacts with the sample. The GO and CNT materials enhance this interaction through plasmonic effects, leading to amplified THz spectral signals. The researchers compared the performance of bare silicon substrates, GO-coated, CNT-coated, and GO+CNT-coated substrates for eye drop detection.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used commercially available eye drops (Optrex, Rohto, and Systane) and deionized water for their experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ATR's Advantage for Aqueous Samples: THz-ATR spectroscopy is superior to transmission mode for aqueous samples like eye drops due to water's strong THz absorption, which makes transmission measurements difficult.
  • Synergistic Plasmonic Enhancement: The combination of GO and CNTs in a hybrid sensor significantly enhances the THz spectral response compared to individual components or bare silicon. This synergy is attributed to improved field confinement and charge carrier transport at the interface.
  • GO+CNT as Optimal Sensor: The GO+CNT hybrid sensor demonstrated the highest contrast and strongest absorption/resonance signals, making it the most effective for differentiating eye drop samples.
  • Sensitivity to Formulation Differences: The technique successfully differentiated between various commercial eye drop brands, indicating its potential for quality control and composition monitoring.
  • Potential for Contamination Detection: Slight shifts in spectral peaks were observed, suggesting the possibility of detecting contamination at the ppm level.

Key Results

  • The GO+CNT hybrid sensor exhibited the highest reflection and lowest absorbance in the 1-3 THz range, indicating enhanced interaction with the sample.
  • When eye drops were applied to the sensors, significant absorption was observed on GO and GO+CNT films, with the GO+CNT showing even higher absorption for Rohto eye drops.
  • The THz absorption coefficient and refractive index spectra clearly distinguished between different commercial eye drop brands (Optrex, Rohto, and Systane) and deionized water.
  • The GO+CNT sensor showed stronger absorption efficiencies at 0.5–2.5 THz and a more pronounced change in refractive index at 0–2 THz compared to other sensors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimization of Sensor Parameters: The paper notes that the specific enhancement achieved by GO/CNT composites depends on factors like composition, arrangement, and concentration. Further experimental optimization is needed to maximize benefits.
  • Thickness Control: While a film thickness of 100 nm was found suitable, the paper mentions that optimizing layer thickness is crucial to avoid interference patterns and absorption losses.
  • Contamination Detection Specificity: While potential for ppm-level contamination detection is suggested, further research is required to establish the specificity and quantitative accuracy of this application.
  • Broader Application: The authors suggest that this rapid, non-destructive assay paves the way for future research into aqueous eye drops and other aqueous pharmaceuticals, implying a need for validation across a wider range of products.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{hao2023terahertz,
  author = {Eugene Soh Jia Hao and Nan Zhang and Qiang Zhu and Xizu Wang and Karen Ke Lin},
  title = {{Terahertz Attenuated Total Reflection Spectral Response and Signal Enhancement via Plasmonic Enhanced Sensor for Eye Drop Detection}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23198290},
}
Figure