Temporal trends of transport-related injuries on New Zealand roads

Siobhan Isles, Michael Kean, Joanna F. Dipnall, Ben BeckNew 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes transport-related injury trends in New Zealand from 2017-2021, revealing a concerning increase in motorcycle injuries while car, pedestrian, and cycling injuries remained stable. The findings underscore the need for targeted interventions for vulnerable road users, especially considering demographic disparities in injury rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Road safety is a critical public health concern, and New Zealand, like many countries, has seen fluctuating trends in road fatalities and serious injuries. While there was a historical downward trend, recent years have shown an increase. Existing road safety strategies focus on various transport modes and advocate for a "safe system" approach, emphasizing shared responsibility and minimizing crash impacts. However, a comprehensive understanding of how injury patterns are evolving across different transport modes, demographics, and geographical areas, especially in light of recent societal shifts like the COVID-19 pandemic, is crucial for effective policy-making. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating temporal trends in transport-related injuries, identifying specific population groups and localities with higher incidence, and assessing the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on these trends.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective observational study using hospital admission data from New Zealand's National Minimum Dataset (NMDS) and the New Zealand Trauma Registry (NZTR) for the period July 1, 2017, to June 30, 2021. Road traffic injuries were identified using ICD-10-AM codes, and major trauma was classified using the Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS). The analysis stratified injuries by mode of transport (car occupants, motorcyclists, pedestrians, pedal cyclists, and "other"), ethnicity, rurality, and population rates.

A key methodological component was the use of Interrupted Time Series (ITS) analysis to account for the significant disruption to traffic patterns caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdowns. This statistical technique allowed the researchers to model changes in injury rates before, during, and after the lockdown periods, comparing observed trends to a counterfactual scenario. For modes with sufficient data (cars and motorcycles), ITSA models were developed to assess the impact of the pandemic on injury counts.

Datasets

  • National Minimum Dataset (NMDS): This dataset contains all hospital admission data in New Zealand.
  • New Zealand Trauma Registry (NZTR): This population-based registry collects data on major trauma patients admitted to acute hospitals.
  • Statistics New Zealand Population Projections: Used for calculating population rates and stratifying by demographic groups.
  • 2013 Census Data: Used as the reference population for Māori ethnicity.
  • University of Otago's Geographic Classification of Health: Used for rural/urban classification based on domicile codes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Motorcycling is a growing concern: While car, pedestrian, and cycling injuries have remained relatively stable, motorcycle injuries have shown a concerning upward trend. This is particularly noteworthy given ongoing initiatives aimed at reducing motorcycle injuries.
  • Vulnerable road users need more focus: The stable rates for pedestrians and cyclists, despite potential increases in their usage, suggest that current interventions may not be sufficient, or that data capture for these modes might be incomplete.
  • Demographic disparities are significant: Māori individuals experience a disproportionately higher rate of transport-related injuries compared to other ethnic groups, highlighting inequities in road safety. Asian peoples, conversely, have a substantially lower rate.
  • Rurality matters: People living in more remote rural areas have a significantly higher rate of transport-related hospitalizations than those in urban areas, suggesting that rural road safety requires specific attention.
  • COVID-19's nuanced impact: While the initial COVID-19 lockdowns caused a sharp, temporary drop in transport-related injuries across the board, the longer-term trends for cars and motorcycles largely returned to pre-pandemic patterns, suggesting that the pandemic's impact was more of a disruption than a fundamental shift in underlying injury trends for these modes.

Key Results

  • Over the 4-year study period, there were 20,607 transport-related injury incidents resulting in hospital admission.
  • Car occupants accounted for the largest proportion of injuries (62%), followed by motorcyclists (23%), pedestrians (9%), and pedal cyclists (4%).
  • Motorcycle injury rates increased over the study period, being over 10% higher in 2020/2021 compared to 2017/2018.
  • Māori had an age-standardized incidence rate almost 3.5 times higher than Asian peoples.
  • People in the remotest rural areas (rural 3) had over twice the rate of hospitalisation compared to those in the densest urban areas.
  • The COVID-19 lockdown period saw a dramatic decrease in traffic volume (around 15% of usual rates) and a corresponding drop in injury rates.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • ICD-10-AM coding limitations: The coding system may not perfectly capture all relevant hospitalizations, particularly for pedal cyclists and pedestrians not involved in a collision with another vehicle, who might be misclassified as "non-traffic" events.
  • Exposure data: Robust exposure data (e.g., vehicle kilometers traveled, number of trips) for all modes of transport was unavailable, making it challenging to definitively attribute changes in injury rates to changes in usage. This is particularly important for understanding the increasing motorcycle injury rates.
  • Rural/urban classification: The classification is based on domicile, not necessarily where the injury occurred.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Enhanced exposure data: Collecting more detailed and accurate exposure data for vulnerable road users is crucial for better understanding trends and developing targeted interventions.
  • Linked data: Integrating data from various population-based datasets can provide a more comprehensive understanding of road traffic injuries and facilitate evidence-based countermeasures.
  • Targeted interventions: Developing and implementing effective, targeted initiatives for vulnerable road users is essential to support the goal of reducing deaths and serious injuries on New Zealand roads.

Summary updated

Abstract

The increases in motorcycling injuries and no changes in pedestrian and cycling injuries, as well as demographic variation, highlight the need to focus on vulnerable road users. Effective and targeted initiatives on vulnerable road users will support objectives to reduce deaths and serious injury on New Zealand roads. Enhanced exposure data is needed for vulnerable road users to account for mobility changes over time. Linked data across population-based datasets is an important asset that enhances our understanding of road traffic injuries and allows evidence-based countermeasures to be developed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{isles2024temporal,
  author = {Siobhan Isles and Michael Kean and Joanna F. Dipnall and Ben Beck},
  title = {{Temporal trends of transport-related injuries on New Zealand roads}},
  booktitle = {New},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.26635/6965.6342},
}
Figure