Temporal-Spatial Evolution of the Urban Ecological Footprint Based on Net Primary Productivity: A Case Study of Xuzhou Central Area, China

Yao Lu, Xiaoshun Li, Heng Ni, Xin Chen, Chuyu Xia, Dongmei Jiang, Huiping FanSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study applies an improved ecological footprint model (EF-NPP) to Xuzhou, China, revealing a concerning trend of increasing ecological footprint and decreasing ecological capacity between 2005 and 2014. The findings highlight an unbalanced ecological situation and provide crucial data for urban planning to achieve sustainable development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid urbanization worldwide is leading to significant ecological and environmental challenges, straining natural resources and impacting ecosystem services. While ecological footprint analysis is a valuable tool for assessing regional sustainability by quantifying human demand on natural capital, traditional methods have limitations in spatial analysis and precise measurement. This paper addresses the need for a more refined understanding of how urbanization affects ecological footprints, particularly in rapidly developing urban areas like Xuzhou, China. It aims to fill the gap in research by analyzing both the temporal trends and spatial patterns of the ecological footprint, ecological capacity, and ecological deficit to inform sustainable urban development strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed the Ecological Footprint based on Net Primary Productivity (EF-NPP) model. This approach refines the traditional ecological footprint method by using Net Primary Productivity (NPP) to calculate equivalence and yield factors. NPP, representing the rate at which plants convert atmospheric carbon into chemical energy, offers a more direct measure of bio-productive capacity than traditional methods relying on agricultural productivity.

Key methodological steps included:

  • Data Acquisition and Preprocessing: Utilizing MODIS data (MOD17A3 for NPP and MCD12Q1 for land cover) and statistical data from Xuzhou. Data was reprojected, clipped, and land cover types were reclassified.
  • EF-NPP Calculation:
    • Equivalence Factors ($\lambda_i$): Calculated based on the ratio of NPP for specific land types to the average NPP across all land types in the study area.
  • Yield Factors ($y_i$): Calculated as the ratio of NPP for a specific land type in the study area to the average NPP for that same land type across China.
  • Ecological Footprint (EF): Calculated by summing the area of bio-productive land required to support human consumption, adjusted by equivalence and yield factors.
  • Ecological Carrying Capacity (EC): Calculated based on the available bio-productive land area, adjusted by equivalence and yield factors.
  • Ecological Deficit: Calculated as the difference between the ecological footprint and ecological carrying capacity (EF - EC).
  • Ecological Pressure Index (EP): Calculated as the ratio of per capita ecological footprint to per capita ecological capacity (EF/EC).
  • Spatial Analysis: GIS was used to analyze the spatial distribution of the ecological footprint, capacity, and deficit.

Datasets

  • MODIS Data:
    • MOD17A3: Net Primary Production (NPP) data with a spatial resolution of 1 km × 1 km.
  • MCD12Q1: Land Cover Type data with a spatial resolution of 500 m × 500 m.
  • Statistical Data: Xuzhou Statistical Yearbook (2005-2014) for population, land area, and consumption/yield data for bio-productive land.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NPP as a Better Indicator: Using NPP for equivalence and yield factors provides a more nuanced and potentially more accurate assessment of ecological capacity and demand compared to traditional methods.
  • Urbanization's Growing Footprint: The study clearly demonstrates that Xuzhou's rapid urbanization is leading to an increasing demand on natural resources, as evidenced by the rising ecological footprint.
  • Declining Capacity: It's not just that demand is rising; the ability of the local environment to meet that demand is shrinking, indicated by the decreasing ecological capacity.
  • Grassland's Dual Role: Grassland emerged as a significant contributor to both the ecological footprint and the ecological deficit, suggesting that changes in grassland management or extent have a substantial impact. Conversely, cultivated land is crucial for ecological capacity.
  • Spatial Imbalance: The ecological footprint is not uniformly distributed. The study highlights specific areas (northeast and southwest) experiencing higher ecological pressure, indicating a need for targeted interventions.
  • Ecological Pressure is High and Increasing: The ecological pressure index consistently indicates an "extremely unsafe" situation, underscoring the urgency of addressing the ecological imbalance.

Key Results

  • Per Capita Ecological Footprint: Increased from 1.06 hm²/person in 2005 to 1.17 hm²/person in 2014.
  • Per Capita Ecological Capacity: Decreased from 0.10 hm²/person in 2005 to 0.09 hm²/person in 2014.
  • Per Capita Ecological Deficit: Increased from -0.96 hm²/person in 2005 to -1.09 hm²/person in 2014, indicating a growing imbalance.
  • Ecological Pressure Index: Increased from 6.87 in 2005 to 11.97 in 2014, consistently falling into the "Extremely unsafe" category.
  • Composition: Grassland was the largest contributor to the ecological footprint and deficit, while cultivated land dominated ecological capacity.
  • Spatial Evolution: The area with lower ecological footprint values expanded eastward and northeastward, while ecological capacity and deficit patterns showed less significant changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Resolution: The authors acknowledge that the MODIS data resolution (1 km for NPP, 500 m for land cover) is relatively coarse and could limit the precision of the spatial analysis.
  • Data Availability: The study was limited to data up to 2014 due to MODIS data availability.
  • Future Work:
    • Higher Resolution Data: Future studies should aim to use higher-resolution land use data (e.g., Landsat) to improve accuracy.
  • Model Refinement: Further improvements to the ecological footprint model are suggested to make it more comprehensive.
  • Policy Recommendations: The study strongly recommends policy measures to control the increase in ecological footprint, enhance ecological capacity, and balance the spatial ecological pattern for sustainable development in Xuzhou. This includes optimizing urban space and investing in ecological civilization construction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The urbanization process all over the world has caused serious ecological and environmental problems which have recently become a focus for study. Ecological footprint analysis, which is widely used to assess the sustainability of regional development, can quantitatively measure the human occupation of natural capital. In this study, the ecological footprint based on net primary production (EF-NPP) and MODIS data were used to measure the ecological footprint in Xuzhou central area from 2005 to 2014. The results showed that from 2005 to 2014, the per capita ecological footprint increased from 1.06 to 1.17 hm2/person; the per capita ecological capacity decreased from 0.10 to 0.09 hm2/person; the per capita ecological deficit increased from −0.96 to −1.09 hm2/person; and the ecological pressure index increased from 6.87 to 11.97. The composition of the ecological footprint showed that grassland contributed most to the ecological footprint and deficit, and cultivated land contributed most to the ecological capacity. The spatial distribution of the ecological footprint changed significantly, especially in the expansion of the area of lower value. The ecological capacity and deficit changed little. The ecological situation in Xuzhou central area was unbalanced. Based on this study, Xuzhou city was recommended to control the increase of the ecological footprint, improve the ecological capacity and balance the ecological pattern for sustainable development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2019temporal,
  author = {Yao Lu and Xiaoshun Li and Heng Ni and Xin Chen and Chuyu Xia and Dongmei Jiang and Huiping Fan},
  title = {{Temporal-Spatial Evolution of the Urban Ecological Footprint Based on Net Primary Productivity: A Case Study of Xuzhou Central Area, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11010199},
}
Figure