Temporal Cross-Correlations between air pollutants and outpatient visits for respiratory and circulatory system diseases in coastal area of China

Yu Jiang, Jiedong Chen, Chuancheng Wu, Xin Lin, Quan Zhou, Shumi Ji, Shuangfeng Yang, Xiaoyang Zhang, Baoying LiuResearch 2019 · DOI

Introduction

While the link between air pollution and severe health outcomes like mortality or hospitalization is well-documented, there is less data on outpatient visits, which represent a much larger portion of the public health burden. Furthermore, most Chinese air quality research focuses on heavily industrial inland megacities. Coastal areas, however, possess unique meteorological dynamics—such as sea breezes and high humidity—that significantly influence how pollutants disperse and react. This study addresses this gap by analyzing three years of data from Fuzhou, a major coastal city, to understand how specific pollutants and the "lag time" between exposure and symptoms affect daily hospital visits for respiratory and circulatory diseases.

Methodology

The researchers employed a Generalized Linear Model (GLM) with a Poisson distribution to analyze daily count data of outpatient visits from January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2018. The study integrated environmental data (NO₂, O₃, PM₁₀, PM₂.₅) and meteorological indicators from the Fuzhou Environmental Monitoring Center with health records from two major local hospitals (Jianxin and Kongjun Hospitals).

Key technical features of the analysis included:

  • Natural Spline Functions: Used to control for non-linear variables such as temperature, relative humidity, and long-term time trends.
  • Lag Models: Analysis of both single-day (0–5 days) and cumulative lags to identify delayed health responses.
  • Multi-Pollutant Models: Construction of "double pollutant" models to account for synergistic effects between different air components.
  • Seasonal Stratification: Data was split into "cold" (Nov–Mar) and "warm" (Apr–Oct) periods to account for seasonal variations in pollutant behavior.

Key Insights and Results

The Dominance of Nitrogen Dioxide (NO₂)

Nitrogen dioxide emerged as the primary driver of outpatient visits. In single-pollutant models, a 10 µg/m³ increase in NO₂ at "lag 0" (the same day of exposure) was associated with a 5.11% increase in total respiratory visits and a 4.75% increase in circulatory visits. The cumulative effect over five days was even more pronounced, showing a 9.43% increase for total respiratory visits. This suggests that vehicle emissions and combustion in coastal urban centers are critical public health targets.

Ozone Thresholds and Seasonal Shifts

Ozone (O₃) exhibited a distinct "threshold effect." When concentrations exceeded 100 µg/m³, the Excess Risk (ER) for circulatory and respiratory visits spiked significantly, reaching up to 3.06% for upper respiratory issues at lag 5. Seasonality also played a role: O₃ was positively associated with upper respiratory visits during the cold period, while its impact on general respiratory disease was more significant during the warm period.

Particulate Matter and Interactions

PM₁₀ was specifically linked to lower respiratory diseases during the warm season, with an ER of 1.68% at lag 0. Interestingly, the study found that adjusting for PM₂.₅ in multi-pollutant models actually increased the calculated risk for other pollutants, suggesting that fine particulate matter may mask or confound the observed effects of gaseous pollutants like NO₂ if not properly modeled.

Excess Risk (ER) of outpatient visits per 10 μg/m³ increase in pollutants across lag days 0-5.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings highlight that even in coastal regions with relatively better dispersion than inland industrial hubs, air pollution remains a significant trigger for outpatient medical consultations. However, the study notes several limitations:

  • Geographic Specificity: Results are specific to the coastal climate of Fuzhou and may not generalize to arid or high-altitude regions.
  • Demographic Data: The study did not stratify results by age or gender, though the elderly are presumed to be more susceptible.
  • Exposure Misclassification: The use of central monitoring stations assumes a uniform "personal dose" for all patients, overlooking variations in indoor air quality and individual movement patterns.

In conclusion, exposure to ambient NO₂, O₃, PM₂.₅, and PM₁₀ is significantly associated with increased respiratory and circulatory outpatient visits in coastal China, with NO₂ posing the most immediate and consistent threat.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Some previous studies have suggested that there is an association between air pollutants and circulatory and respiratory diseases. However, the association of air pollutants and outpatient visits considering mortality, hospitalization rates, etc. has been analyzed in relatively few studies.Methods We used a generalized linear Poisson model was constructed to study the association between air pollution and outpatient visits for respiratory and circulatory diseases during 2016-2018 in coastal area of China.Results In the single pollutant model, NO 2 had a significant effect. For lag day 0 to lag day 5, the effect decreased with every 10 µg/L increase in NO 2 . O 3 and upper respiratory outpatient visits were positively associated in the cold period [lag2, ER (95%CI): 1.68% (0.44%-2.94%)], while O 3 and respiratory disease were positively associated in the warm period [lag5, ER (95%CI): 1.10% (0.11%-2.10%) and lag4, ER (95%CI): 1.02% (0.032%-2.02%)]. Similarly, PM 10 and lower respiratory diseases were positively associated in the warm period [lag0, ER (95%CI): 1.68% (0.44%-2.94%)]. When the concentration of O 3 was higher than 100 μg/L, there was a positive effect on circulatory [lag5, ER (95%CI): 2.83% (0.65%-5.06%)], respiratory [lag5, ER (95%CI): 2.47% (0.85%-4.11%)] and upper respiratory [lag5, ER (95%CI): 3.06% (1.38%-4.77%)] outpatient visits. The variation in O 3 changed slightly when we adjusted for the other air pollutants, and after adjusting for O 3 , the ERs of the other air pollutants changed slightly. After adjusting for PM 2.5 , the ER of the other air pollutants increased, and after adjusting for NO 2 , the ER of particulate matter (PM) decreased.Conclusion Exposure to ambient NO 2 , O 3 , PM 2.5 and PM 10 was associated with an increase in respiratory and circulatory system outpatient visits in coastal area of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2019temporal,
  author = {Yu Jiang and Jiedong Chen and Chuancheng Wu and Xin Lin and Quan Zhou and Shumi Ji and Shuangfeng Yang and Xiaoyang Zhang and Baoying Liu},
  title = {{Temporal Cross-Correlations between air pollutants and outpatient visits for respiratory and circulatory system diseases in coastal area of China}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.16198/v1},
}
Figure