Temporal and Spatial Variation of Land Use and Vegetation in the Three–North Shelter Forest Program Area from 2000 to 2020

Cong Zhang, Xiaojun Yao, Guoyu Wang, Huian Jin, Te Sha, Xinde Chu, Juan Zhang, Juan CaoSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes land use and vegetation changes in China's Three-North Shelter Forest Program Area (TNSFPA) from 2000-2020 using MODIS data. It reveals widespread vegetation recovery driven by ecological restoration efforts, though precipitation remains a key limiting factor, and urbanization presents ongoing challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Three-North Shelter Forest Program (TNSFPA) is a massive ecological engineering project aimed at combating desertification and land degradation in northern China. Understanding how land use has changed and how vegetation has responded within this vast and ecologically sensitive region is crucial for assessing the program's effectiveness and informing future conservation strategies. While previous studies have examined land use and vegetation dynamics, a comprehensive, long-term analysis specifically for the TNSFPA, integrating both land use and vegetation productivity, was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a detailed spatiotemporal analysis of these changes and exploring their driving factors.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Land Use/Cover Change (LUCC) Mapping: They utilized MODIS MCD12Q1 land cover products from 2001-2020, reclassifying the original 17 land cover types into 6 broader categories for easier analysis. LUCC was mapped using a map algebraic operation on pixel data across different time periods (2000, 2010, 2020).
  • Vegetation Coverage (VC) Extraction: VC was calculated using the pixel dichotomy model based on MODIS NDVI data (MOD/MYD13A1). This method accounts for mixed pixels containing both soil and vegetation.
  • Vegetation Productivity Estimation: Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) data from MODIS MOD/MYD17A2H products was used as a proxy for vegetation productivity.
  • Trend Analysis: Both linear regression analysis and Sen's trend degree with Mann-Kendall significance tests were applied to assess the trends in land use, vegetation coverage, and productivity over time. This allowed for the identification of significant increases, decreases, or stability.
  • Correlation Analysis: Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated to investigate the relationships between vegetation growth indicators (coverage and productivity) and climate factors (temperature and precipitation).

Datasets

  • MODIS MCD12Q1 Land Cover Products: Used for land use/cover classification from 2001-2020.
  • MODIS MOD/MYD13A1 Vegetation Indices (NDVI): Used for calculating vegetation coverage.
  • MODIS MOD/MYD17A2H Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) Products: Used to assess vegetation productivity.
  • Meteorological Data: Gridded air temperature and precipitation data from 2000-2020, derived from 2472 national meteorological stations and spatially interpolated using the thin plate spline (TPS) method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dominance of Stability, but with Significant Change: While a large portion of the TNSFPA remained unchanged in land use (90.05%), the changes that did occur were significant, particularly the shift from barren land to other uses.
  • Vegetation is Recovering: The overwhelming trend across the TNSFPA is increasing vegetation coverage and productivity, a positive sign for ecological restoration efforts.
  • Precipitation is King: Climate plays a crucial role, but precipitation emerged as a more significant limiting factor for vegetation growth than temperature in this region.
  • Urbanization's Footprint: Despite widespread ecological improvements, the rapid growth of population and subsequent urbanization are exerting pressure on land use and potentially impacting localized vegetation ecosystems.

Key Results

  • Land Use: From 2001-2020, barren land decreased, while cultivated land and constructive land increased. "Later change" (2010-2020) was the dominant LUCC pattern.
  • Vegetation Coverage: Over 90% of the TNSFPA showed an increasing trend in vegetation coverage (0.41%·a⁻¹). Northeast China saw the highest increase rate (0.54%·a⁻¹).
  • Vegetation Productivity: 51.66% of the TNSFPA exhibited an increasing trend in vegetation productivity (3.41 gC·m⁻²·a⁻¹). Northeast China again showed the highest increase rate (7.34 gC·m⁻²·a⁻¹).
  • Climate Correlation: Both vegetation coverage and productivity showed positive correlations with temperature and precipitation. However, the correlation with precipitation was significantly stronger (e.g., 86.58% of the area showed positive correlation between vegetation coverage and precipitation, compared to 64.06% for temperature).

Limitations and Future Work

  • LUCC Complexity: The paper acknowledges that the impact and contribution of LUCC on vegetation coverage and productivity are complex and warrant further in-depth study, especially given the multi-land use type nature of the study area.
  • Human Activity Factors: While climate drivers were analyzed, the paper suggests that a more quantitative analysis and exploration of the driving mechanisms of human activity factors (beyond just urbanization) leading to land use and vegetation changes are needed.
  • Scale of Impact: The study notes that while ecological restoration is positive, the reclamation and development of barren land due to human activity can have a significant impact on small-scale vegetation ecosystems, indicating a need for localized management strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Three–North Shelter Forest Program Area (TNSFPA), covering the three subregions of Northwest, North and Northeast China, is an important green ecological barrier in northern China. Research on spatiotemporal variation of land use and vegetation in this area can help us understand the evolution of vegetation recovery. Based on MODIS image data, we built a dataset including land use/cover, annual and seasonal vegetation coverage and vegetation productivity in the TNSFPA from 2000 to 2020, then analyzed their spatiotemporal dynamics’ characteristics and further explored the driving factors. The results demonstrate that 90.05% of land area in the TNSFPA remained unchanged from 2001 to 2020. The area of barren decreased, whereas the area of all other land use types increased. From 2000 to 2020, the vegetation coverage generally presented a spatial pattern of high in the east and low in the west, and the interannual fluctuation of high coverage area was small. More than 90% of the TNSFPA had an increasing vegetation coverage (0.41%·a−1), with the change rates of 0.51%·a−1, 0.54%·a−1 and 0.37%·a−1 in Northeast, North and Northwest China, respectively. The spatial distribution of vegetation productivity was generally consistent with the vegetation coverage, and the interannual fluctuation in areas with low productivity was small. The area with an increasing vegetation productivity (3.41 gC·m−2·a−1) occupied 51.66% of the TNSFPA, mainly in the basic stable state and significantly increased state. The change rates in Northeast, North and Northwest China were 7.34 gC·m−2·a−1, 6.72 gC·m−2·a−1 and 2.10 gC·m−2·a−1, respectively. The vegetation coverage and productivity were positively correlated with climate factors, and the correlation with precipitation is significantly higher than that with temperature. The ecological protection and restoration activities in the TNSFPA have accelerated the recovery of the vegetation ecosystem. Meanwhile, the rapid growth of population has led to the acceleration of urbanization. The intensification of the interaction between humans and land has led to the reclamation and development of barren, which has a great impact on the small–scale vegetation ecosystem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022temporal,
  author = {Cong Zhang and Xiaojun Yao and Guoyu Wang and Huian Jin and Te Sha and Xinde Chu and Juan Zhang and Juan Cao},
  title = {{Temporal and Spatial Variation of Land Use and Vegetation in the Three–North Shelter Forest Program Area from 2000 to 2020}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142416489},
}
Figure