Temperature Effects on the Wind Direction Measurement of 2D Solid Thermal Wind Sensors

Bei Chen, Yanqing Zhu, Zhenxiang Yi, Ming Qin, Qing-An Huang2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how ambient temperature affects the accuracy of 2D solid thermal wind sensors in measuring wind direction. The authors developed a theoretical model and used simulations and experiments to show that despite individual output voltages being temperature-dependent, the sensor's symmetrical design makes the wind direction measurement largely independent of ambient temperature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Thermal wind sensors are crucial for applications in agriculture, industry, and meteorology. However, their performance can be significantly impacted by ambient temperature fluctuations, which can lead to inaccurate wind speed and direction readings. While previous research has addressed temperature effects on wind speed measurement, the specific impact on wind direction measurement in 2D solid thermal wind sensors remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a comprehensive analysis of how ambient temperature influences the wind direction measurement capabilities of these sensors.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Theoretical Modeling: A theoretical model was developed to describe the relationship between output voltages, wind speed, ambient temperature, and wind direction. This model incorporates parameters related to the sensor's thermophysical properties and airflow.
  • Finite Element Method (FEM) Simulations: A 2D FEM model of the thermal wind sensor was built using COMSOL Multiphysics. This allowed for detailed simulations of temperature distribution and flow velocity under various conditions, specifically to investigate the impact of temperature on sensor performance.
  • Experimental Validation: Fabricated 2D solid thermal wind sensors were tested in a wind tunnel across a range of ambient temperatures and wind speeds. The experimental results were then compared with the theoretical analysis and simulation outcomes.

The core of the sensor's operation relies on measuring temperature differences caused by airflow. For wind direction, this involves analyzing the output from two orthogonal sensing directions (north-south and east-west). The key innovation here is the detailed modeling and experimental verification of how temperature affects the combined output of these two directions for wind direction determination.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on simulations and experimental measurements using a fabricated sensor.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry is Key: The symmetrical structure of the 2D thermal wind sensor is the primary reason why wind direction measurement is largely insensitive to ambient temperature. While the individual north-south and east-west output voltages are temperature-dependent, these dependencies are very similar for both directions.
  • Individual Voltages vs. Direction: The paper clearly distinguishes between the temperature dependence of individual sensor outputs (which are significant) and the temperature independence of the derived wind direction (which is a key finding).
  • Substrate Conductivity Dominates: Simulations indicated that the thermal conductivity of the silicon and ceramic substrates plays a more dominant role in temperature effects than the thermophysical properties of the airflow.
  • Linear Temperature Dependence: Both simulation and experimental results show that the output voltages of the sensor are approximately linear functions of the ambient temperature.

Key Results

  • The theoretical analysis, FEM simulations, and experimental results all consistently show that the wind direction measurement of the 2D solid thermal wind sensor is approximately independent of the ambient temperature.
  • The output voltages in the north-south and east-west directions were found to increase linearly with ambient temperature. For example, one simulation showed a 26.4% increase in output voltage when the temperature increased by 80 °C due to substrate conductivity effects.
  • The constant phase shifts (Ens and Eew) in the wind direction calculation were found to be around 77.3° and 76.7°, respectively, and these were shown to be relatively stable.
  • The paper presents experimental data showing wind direction error remaining within a few degrees across a range of temperatures (5°C to 35°C), demonstrating the robustness of the measurement.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications in FEM: The authors acknowledge that some simplifications and approximations were made in the COMSOL simulation, which could contribute to minor discrepancies between simulation and experimental results.
  • Fabrication and Packaging Deviations: Minor deviations in the fabrication and packaging processes are also noted as potential sources of discrepancy.
  • Future Work: While not explicitly detailed as future work, the paper's findings lay the groundwork for designing more robust thermal wind sensors. Future research could explore optimizing sensor geometry or materials to further enhance temperature independence or investigate the performance in more complex environmental conditions (e.g., humidity, dust). The paper also implicitly suggests that the presented temperature compensation model for wind speed could be further refined or integrated with the direction measurement.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{chen2015temperature,
  author = {Bei Chen and Yanqing Zhu and Zhenxiang Yi and Ming Qin and Qing-An Huang},
  title = {{Temperature Effects on the Wind Direction Measurement of 2D Solid Thermal Wind Sensors}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s151229771},
}
Figure