Abstract
Ice nucleation on the surface plays a vital role in diverse areas, ranging from physics and cryobiology to atmospheric science. Compared to ice nucleation in the bulk, the water-surface interactions present in heterogeneous ice nucleation complicate the nucleation process, making heterogeneous ice nucleation less comprehended, especially the relationship between the kinetics and the structures of the critical ice nucleus. Here we combine Markov State Models and transition path theory to elucidate the ensemble pathways of heterogeneous ice nucleation. Our Markov State Models reveal that the classical one-step and non-classical two-step nucleation pathways can surprisingly co-exist with comparable fluxes at T = 230 K. Interestingly, we find that the disordered mixing of rhombic and hexagonal ice leads to a favorable configurational entropy that stabilizes the critical nucleus, facilitating the non-classical pathway. In contrast, the favorable energetics promotes the formation of hexagonal ice, resulting in the classical pathway. Furthermore, we discover that, at elevated temperatures, the nucleation process prefers to proceed via the classical pathway, as opposed to the non-classical pathway, since the potential energy contributions override the configurational entropy compensation. This study provides insights into the mechanisms of heterogeneous ice nucleation and sheds light on the rational designs to control crystallization processes.
Introduction
Heterogeneous ice nucleation (HIN) is a fundamental process where surfaces—such as atmospheric dust or biological proteins—catalyze the formation of ice. While Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) typically describes a straightforward one-step process where water molecules overcome a single energy barrier to form a stable crystal, real-world observations often suggest more complex, multi-step "non-classical" pathways. Understanding the atomistic details of these transitions is challenging because they occur on nanosecond timescales. This study utilizes advanced statistical modeling to bridge this gap, identifying how structural evolution and temperature dictate the preferred nucleation route.
Methodology
The researchers employed high-powered Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of 4,940 water molecules on a wurtzite-structured surface. To map the long-term kinetics, they utilized Markov State Models (MSMs), which stitch together numerous short simulations into a comprehensive kinetic map. The Spectral-oASIS algorithm was used to select optimal collective variables—such as the number of hexagonal versus rhombic ice molecules—to describe the system's slowest dynamics. Finally, Transition Path Theory (TPT) allowed for the calculation of the "flux," or the volume of traffic, through different nucleation pathways.
Structural Dynamics and Kinetic Pathways
A key discovery of this work is the coexistence of two distinct structural pathways at 230 K. The nucleation process involves a competition between hexagonal ice and rhombic ice structures.
At 230 K, the classical one-step and non-classical two-step pathways exist with comparable fluxes. The non-classical pathway is facilitated by a "disorder bonus": the mixing of rhombic and hexagonal ice creates high configurational entropy, which stabilizes the critical nucleus and lowers the initial barrier. In contrast, the classical pathway is driven by energetics, as hexagonal ice interacts more favorably with the wurtzite surface, providing a lower potential energy state.
Results and Temperature Sensitivity
The study reveals that the choice of pathway is highly sensitive to temperature. As the temperature rises, the entropic advantage of the disordered non-classical path becomes less significant compared to the potential energy advantages of the classical hexagonal route.
- At 230 K: The classical pathway accounts for 61.9% of the flux, while non-classical pathways (involving rhombic intermediates) account for 38.1%.
- At 240 K: The classical pathway's dominance increases to 88.5%.
- At 250 K: The system almost exclusively follows the classical route at 93.9%.
The calculated heterogeneous ice nucleation rate ($J_{het}$) at 230 K was approximately $3.5 \times 10^{30} \text{ s}^{-1}\text{m}^{-3}$, which is orders of magnitude faster than homogeneous nucleation in bulk water.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that heterogeneous ice nucleation is not a single-track process but a dynamic competition between energy-driven and entropy-driven pathways. By revealing that rhombic ice acts as a crucial intermediate in non-classical nucleation, the study provides a new framework for understanding complex crystallization. These insights into the temperature-dependent "tug-of-war" between energy and entropy offer a path toward the rational design of materials to control ice formation in fields ranging from climate science to cryopreservation.
Summary updated