TEMPAT RETRET KOTA

Vincent Y. F. Tan, Alvin HadiwonoJurnal 2020 · DOI

In an era defined by the relentless pace of globalization, the "millennial" generation (born 1981–2000) is facing a significant mental health crisis. Research from the Mental Health Foundation suggests this demographic is significantly more stressed than their predecessors, often struggling with the pressures of a hyper-productive age. While urban centers offer efficiency and entertainment, they frequently lack spaces designed for genuine spiritual and emotional recovery.

A recent research project by Vincent Tan and Alvin Hadiwono from Universitas Tarumanagara proposes a fascinating solution: The Urban Retreat Space. By blending architectural theory with spiritual psychology, the authors explore how buildings can act as narrative guides for self-release and healing, moving beyond mere function to facilitate psychological transcendence.

The Problem: Urban Stress and the Spiritual Gap

The authors identify a critical gap in modern urban planning: the lack of spaces that cater to the spiritual and mental well-being of the "productive age" population. In high-density cities like Jakarta, stress levels are skyrocketing—affecting roughly 14% of the population. Traditional retreat spaces often feel overly medical, formal, or rigid. The authors argue that millennials need a new type of "worship space" that is human-centric, multi-sensory, and aligned with modern psychological needs, specifically Maslow’s often-overlooked sixth level of hierarchy: self-transcendence.

Methodology: Thematic Narrative Architecture

The researchers employ a multi-disciplinary design methodology to create a space that "tells a story" of healing:

  • Thematic Narrative Architecture: This core approach treats a building as a storyteller. The design follows a sequence that reflects a journey of spiritual awakening.
  • The Seven Steps to Soul: Based on the work of Suzan Carroll, the authors structure the building's program into seven distinct stages: Childhood, Emotions, Thoughts, Relationships, Creativity, Imagination, and Freedom.
  • Spatial Gestalts: Borrowed from psychology, this method uses visual grouping (like 'L' or 'W' shapes in floor plans) to create cohesive, intuitive environments that the mind perceives as a whole rather than a collection of parts.
  • Phenomenology (Sensuality): Drawing on the theories of Juhani Pallasmaa, the design prioritizes "the eyes of the skin" over the "hegemony of the eye," emphasizing touch, sound, and smell to ground the user in the "here and now."

Results: The Urban Retreat Matrix

The paper culminates in a conceptual framework that translates abstract spiritual steps into concrete architectural programs. This matrix integrates sensuality, sustainability, and humanity into a cohesive spatial experience.

The conceptual matrix for the Urban Retreat Space, mapping spiritual experience to architectural elements.

The proposed Urban Retreat Space is divided into seven thematic zones derived from the "Seven Steps to Soul":

  1. Childhood: Spaces designed to trigger awareness of one's past.
  2. Emotions: Environments focused on healing and expressing suppressed pain.
  3. Thoughts: Quiet zones that encourage "thinking from within" and internal listening.
  4. Relationships: Spaces that foster self-love and connection to the planet.
  5. Creativity: Areas designed to remove limitations and encourage self-renewal.
  6. Imagination: Portals between the inner and outer worlds to open the mind to possibilities.
  7. Freedom: The final stage, a space for total release of the mind and soul.

Key Insights and Future Directions

  • Architecture as Storytelling: A building shouldn't just be a container; it should be a process. By using "narrative devices," architects can guide a user through a sequence of emotional states, from acknowledging past pain to achieving a sense of freedom.
  • Biophilic Necessity: Integration with nature (biophilia) isn't just an aesthetic choice; it is a functional requirement for emotional release. The "greenery" acts as a catalyst for calming the mind.

While the paper presents a theoretical and design-based proposal, it sets the stage for future empirical testing. Potential next steps include post-occupancy evaluations to measure physiological stress levels (heart rate, cortisol) of users before and after entry, and exploring how these retreat spaces can be woven into high-density commercial districts rather than remaining isolated "destination" buildings.

Summary updated

Abstract

This world has created major changes, this is considered as the impact of the current globalization that cannot be stopped anymore. This stream of globalization has caused stress for the millennial generation. Millennials are those that are affected by this current, the largest - with their birth in 1981-2000. They are also people of productive age. Research from the Mental Health Foundation (MHF, 2018) found millennials were more stressed than other older age groups such as generation X. This attracted attention to mental and physical health, especially spiritual issues to overcome this. The purpose of this project is to introduce a new type of place of spirituality in the millennial generation, to open new understandings and thoughts about spirituality in architecture, to produce architectural works that support new changes in the millennial generation, and to increase awareness in the millennial pre-post architectural direction future spirituality. Theoretical study that underlies this design project is taken from Suzan Caroll's book entitled Seven Steps to Soul and the method used is Thematic Narrative Architecture. Thematic Approach Narrative Architecture is a design approach by telling a process that considers the application of themes as elements in a building. This approach is supported by other sub-methods, namely Spatial Gestalts, Experiential Archetypes and Reference. This design project brings users into a spiritual experience that aims to become a place of self-release for all people, especially millennials. Abstrak Dunia ini telah menciptakan perubahan besar, hal ini dianggap sebagai dampak dari arus globalisasi yang sudah tidak dapat dibendung lagi. Arus globalisasi ini mengakibatkan stress bagi generasi milennial. Milennial adalah mereka yang terkena dampak arus ini terbesar -dengan kelahirannya pada tahun 1981-2000. Mereka juga adalah orang-orang dengan usia produktif. Penelitian dari Mental Health Foundation (MHF, 2018) menemukan generasi milenial lebih stres dibandingkan kelompok usia lain yang lebih tua seperti generasi X. Hal ini menarik perhatian akan hal kesehatan mental serta fisik khususnya spiritual untuk menanggulangi ini. Adapun tujuan dari proyek ini yaitu mengenalkan tipe baru tempat spiritualitas pada jaman generasi milennial, membuka pengertian dan pemikiran baru tentang spiritualitas dalam arsitektur, menghasilkan karya arsitektur yang mendukung perubahan baru pada jaman generasi milennial, dan meningkatkan awareness pada generasi sebelum-sesudah millennial akan arahan arsitektur spiritualitas kedepan. Kajian Teori yang mendasari proyek desain ini diambil dari buku Suzan Caroll yang berjudul Seven Steps to Soul dan metode yang digunakan adalah Thematic Narrative Architecture.Pendekatan Thematic Narrative Architecture adalah pendekatan desain dengan menceritakan sebuah proses yang memperhatikan penerapan tema sebagai unsur-unsur pada bangunan. Pendekatan ini didukung oleh sub-metode lainnya yaitu Spatial Gestalts, Experiential Archetypes dan Reference. Proyek rancangan ini membawa pengguna kedalam sebuah pengalaman spiritual yang bertujuan untuk menjadi tempat pelepasan diri bagi semua orang khususnya millennial.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2020tempat,
  author = {Vincent Y. F. Tan and Alvin Hadiwono},
  title = {{TEMPAT RETRET KOTA}},
  booktitle = {Jurnal},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.24912/stupa.v1i2.4407},
}
Figure