Technostress Among University Teachers in Higher Education: A Study Using Multidimensional Person-Environment Misfit Theory

Xinghua Wang, Bo LiFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a multidimensional framework to understand "technostress" – the stress caused by technology – among university teachers. It reveals that organizational factors, rather than just technology itself, are key drivers of this stress, significantly impacting job performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in higher education, while offering benefits, also creates new sources of stress for university teachers. This "technostress" arises from the mismatch between teachers and the technological, organizational, and social environments they operate in. Existing research often focuses on single aspects of this mismatch, leading to an incomplete understanding. This paper aims to address this by proposing and validating a comprehensive, multidimensional framework for technostress in higher education, specifically examining its impact on job performance.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach using a survey administered to 343 university teachers in China. They utilized a multidimensional Person-Environment (P-E) misfit framework, breaking down technostress into three key dimensions:

  • Person-Organization (P-O) misfit: Mismatch between teachers and university policies, demands, and resources related to ICT.
  • Person-Technology (P-T) misfit: Mismatch between teachers and the ICT itself, including its complexity, suitability, and the demands it places on their skills.
  • Person-People (P-P) misfit: Mismatch related to social support from colleagues and supervisors in navigating ICT.

These misfits were further categorized into Abilities-Demands (A-D) misfit (where a person's skills don't meet environmental demands) and Needs-Supplies (N-S) misfit (where environmental resources don't meet a person's needs). The researchers used Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to analyze the relationships between these dimensions and their impact on job performance. They also conducted multi-group comparisons based on teachers' grade levels.

Datasets

The study used data collected from 343 university teachers across five public universities in mainland China. This dataset was collected via self-report surveys. No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on validating existing theoretical frameworks with empirical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Organizational Management is Key: The study strongly suggests that technostress is not solely a technological problem. Instead, organizational management practices related to ICT implementation and support play a foundational role in creating or mitigating technostress.
  • Nested Misfits: P-O misfit (organizational level) significantly predicts P-T and P-P misfits, indicating that how universities manage ICT and support teachers is a primary driver for other types of technostress.
  • Job Performance Impact: While technostress is a concern, the study found that specific aspects of P-O misfit (organizational demands) and P-T misfit (suitability of ICT) have a direct, negative impact on job performance.
  • Grade Level Matters: Teachers in higher grade levels are more susceptible to technostress stemming from organizational demands and supplies, suggesting a need for tailored support strategies.

Key Results

  • The multidimensional P-E misfit framework (P-O, P-T, P-P) was validated and found to capture technostress effectively.
  • P-O misfit (both ADO and NSO) significantly predicted P-T misfit (ADT and NST) and P-P misfit (PPF), supporting most of the initial hypotheses (H1-H3, H5-H6).
  • ADO (Abilities-Demands misfit on the organizational level) negatively predicted job performance (H7 supported).
  • NST (Needs-Supplies misfit on the technological level) negatively predicted job performance (H10 supported).
  • The overall R² for job performance was 0.17, indicating a moderate explanatory power for technostress.
  • Multi-group comparisons revealed that ADO had a greater influence on ADT for higher-grade teachers, and NSO had a greater influence on PPF for higher-grade teachers, highlighting their increased vulnerability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits the ability to establish definitive causal relationships. A longitudinal design is recommended for future research.
  • Self-Report Data: Reliance on self-report data introduces potential biases related to human perception. Future studies could benefit from triangulating data with clinical diagnostic tests or in-depth interviews.
  • Cultural Generalizability: The findings are based on Chinese universities, and cultural differences might influence technostress experiences. Validation in Western universities is suggested.
  • Gender Distribution: The sample had a higher proportion of female participants, which could limit generalizability. Future research should aim for a more balanced gender distribution.
  • Tailored Support: The authors emphasize the need for universities to move beyond one-size-fits-all ICT support, particularly for senior teachers and those teaching higher-grade courses, suggesting the development of tailored strategies.
  • Teacher Self-Regulation: Future work could explore how teachers can develop self-regulation skills to manage technostress and improve their coping mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

To investigate the phenomenon of technostress among university teachers in higher education, a multidimensional person-environment misfit framework of technostress was proposed and validated by 343 teachers from universities in China. The findings indicate that person-organization (P-O) misfit, person-technology (P-T) misfit, and person-people (P-P) misfit largely captured how university teachers interact with multiple dimensions of the higher education environment in an imbalanced way that causes technostress. P-O misfit predicted P-T misfit and P-P misfit. Relationships between multidimensional technostress and job performance were investigated. It was found that university requirements related to the use of ICT and the suitability of ICT for university teachers' work were critical factors affecting their job performance. In addition, a comparison was made among university teachers from different grade levels, revealing that university management related to ICT use tended to affect university teachers of higher-grade levels more than those of lower-grade levels in generating technostress.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019technostress,
  author = {Xinghua Wang and Bo Li},
  title = {{Technostress Among University Teachers in Higher Education: A Study Using Multidimensional Person-Environment Misfit Theory}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01791},
}
Figure