Technology and Workforce: Comparison between the Information Revolution and the Industrial Revolution

Mathias HumbertInfoscience 2007

TL;DR

This paper draws a historical parallel between the First Industrial Revolution and the Information Revolution, arguing that both eras of rapid technological advancement triggered massive productivity growth alongside "technological unemployment" and social instability. It posits that while technology creates long-term wealth, the displacement of the workforce by "thinking machines" requires a fundamental rethinking of the social contract, education, and wealth distribution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The author tackles the paradox of "technological unemployment": why does exponential growth in global wealth and productivity often coincide with increased misery, job insecurity, and inequality for the working class?

The paper explores the gap between the promise of "trickle-down technology"—the idea that productivity gains eventually create more jobs than they destroy—and the reality of the "Information Age." By comparing current trends in Information and Communications Technology (ICT) with the 18th-century transition to steam power, the author seeks to understand if the current displacement of the middle class and low-skilled workers is a temporary adjustment or a systemic shift requiring new political and social solutions.

Methods

This paper is a comparative historical and economic analysis. It utilizes several key theoretical frameworks:

  • Kondratiev Waves: The theory of long-term (45-60 year) economic cycles driven by major innovations.
  • Schumpeterian "Creative Destruction": The process by which industrial mutation incessantly revolutionizes the economic structure from within.
  • Marxist and Keynesian Perspectives: Analyzing the struggle between labor and capital, and the concept of technological unemployment.
  • Sociological Synthesis: Combining historical accounts (Hobsbawm, Thompson, Engels) with contemporary sociological observations (Rifkin, Wacquant) to compare the "factory proletariat" of the 1800s with the modern "precariat."

Datasets

The paper relies on secondary data and historical statistics rather than original experimental datasets. Key sources include:

  • US Bureau of Labor Statistics & Census Bureau: Data on unemployment rates, wage stagnation, and sector-specific job losses (e.g., the decline of agricultural and manufacturing labor).
  • International Labor Organization (ILO): Statistics on global manufacturing trends and the steel industry.
  • Historical Economic Texts: Data from 18th and 19th-century Britain regarding real wages and working conditions during the First Industrial Revolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • From Muscle to Mind: While the Industrial Revolution replaced human muscle with machines, the Information Revolution replaces "conceptual, managerial, and administrative functions" with "thinking machines." This threatens not just blue-collar workers, but the middle-class service sector.
  • The Failure of "Trickle-Down Technology": The author argues that the classical economic cycle—where lower production costs lead to lower prices, higher demand, and more jobs—is breaking down. Instead, productivity gains are increasingly captured by a "small cosmopolitan elite" of knowledge workers and stockholders.
  • The Rise of the "Precariat": Borrowing from Loïc Wacquant, the paper identifies a new class defined by the "trinity of sans": job-less, home-less, and paper-less. This group faces "advanced marginality" in both the US and Europe.
  • Historical Rhyming: The author compares modern social unrest (like the 2005 French riots) to 19th-century Luddism and the revolutions of 1848, suggesting that social violence is a recurring symptom of workforce marginalization during technological shifts.
  • The Knowledge Barrier: Retraining is often "naive" because a significant portion of the displaced workforce lacks the foundational education required for the high-skill "knowledge sector," which is the only sector currently seeing job growth.

Key Results

  • Sectoral Shifts: In 1900, 36% of Americans worked in agriculture; by 2007, it was <3%. Manufacturing followed a similar path, dropping from 34% of the US workforce in 1960 to a projected 5% by 2020.
  • Wage Stagnation: Despite massive productivity gains, the average weekly wage in the US dropped from $387 in 1979 to $335 in 1989 (in constant dollars).
  • Global Job Loss: Between 1995 and 2002, 31 million manufacturing jobs were eliminated across the world’s 20 largest economies.
  • Union Decline: The "main weapon" of the workforce—unions—has seen a drastic membership drop (from post-WWII highs to 12% in the US and 8% in France by 2006), leaving workers with little leverage to claim a share of productivity gains.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is a high-level synthesis and does not provide a primary empirical study or a specific algorithmic model for predicting job loss. It was written in 2007, just before the 2008 financial crisis, which likely intensified many of the trends discussed.

The author suggests that "possible solutions" include:

  • A complete remaking of education policy to prepare workers for the knowledge economy.
  • The development of a "social sector" (non-profit/community work).
  • A reduction of the work week (e.g., the French 35-hour week) to share available work more broadly.
  • A redefinition of the "social contract" to ensure production gains are distributed more equitably. However, the paper leaves the specific implementation of these radical changes as a challenge for future policymakers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since around 1750, global wealth has risen in an exponential way 1 The Industrial Revolution, which began in Britain in the 18 th century, is the direct consequence of a major invention, the steam engine. Its use in cotton mills involved a dramatic increase in production capacities. Thanks to the growth of productivity underpinned
BibTeX
@inproceedings{humbert2007technology,
  author = {Mathias Humbert},
  title = {{Technology and Workforce: Comparison between the Information Revolution and the Industrial Revolution}},
  booktitle = {Infoscience},
  year = {2007},
}
Figure