Techno-Economic Analysis and Optimization of a Compressed-Air Energy Storage System Integrated with a Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Plant

Pavitra Senthamilselvan Sengalani, Md Emdadul Haque, Manali S. Zantye, Akhilesh Gandhi, Mengdi Li, M. M. Faruque Hasan, Debangsu BhattacharyyaEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a techno-economic optimization of integrating Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES) with Natural Gas Combined-Cycle (NGCC) power plants. The study demonstrates that this integration consistently yields higher Net Present Value (NPV) across various electricity market conditions, suggesting a viable pathway for enhancing grid flexibility and renewable energy integration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing reliance on intermittent renewable energy sources like solar and wind necessitates robust energy storage solutions to ensure grid stability and reliability. While various energy storage technologies exist, long-term storage options like CAES are crucial for managing diurnal and seasonal variations. However, the optimal design and operation of CAES systems, especially when integrated with existing power generation infrastructure like Natural Gas Combined-Cycle (NGCC) plants, remain complex challenges. This paper specifically addresses the gap in understanding the techno-economic feasibility and optimal operational strategies for such integrated systems, considering real-world electricity market price fluctuations.

Methods

The researchers developed detailed first-principles dynamic models for both the NGCC plant and the CAES system. A key innovation is the integration of these models, allowing for air extraction from the NGCC's gas turbine compressor during low demand/price periods and injection into the combustor during high demand/price periods. This integration aims to leverage existing NGCC infrastructure to reduce capital costs.

To tackle the computational complexity of optimizing this integrated system over a full year, they employed a reduced-order modeling (ROM) approach for the NGCC plant. The core of the optimization was a dynamic optimization problem formulated to maximize the Net Present Value (NPV) of the integrated system. This optimization was performed using the Python/Pyomo platform, considering 14 different regions with varying Locational Marginal Price (LMP) data over a year at hourly intervals. Design variables (storage capacity, pressure) and operational variables (plant load, air injection/extraction rates) were simultaneously optimized.

Datasets

The study utilized year-long Locational Marginal Price (LMP) data for 14 different regions/cases. These datasets were sourced from:

  • National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL): Including regions like CAISO, ERCOT, MISO, PJM, and NYISO.
  • Princeton: Including scenarios like Base Case, High Solar, High Wind, and Winter NYT.

The paper also references data from the U.S. Department of Energy's National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) for the NGCC plant's process configuration and design conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Integration: The core idea is that CAES isn't just an add-on; it can actively enhance the operation of an NGCC plant by allowing it to operate more flexibly and profitably, especially in markets with volatile electricity prices.
  • LMP is King: The study strongly emphasizes that the electricity market's price profile (LMP) is the most critical factor determining the economic viability and operational strategy of an integrated CAES-NGCC system.
  • Leveraging Existing Assets: Integrating CAES with an NGCC plant can bypass the need for separate compressors, combustors, and expanders in the CAES system by utilizing the NGCC's existing components, significantly reducing capital expenditure.
  • Cavern Storage Advantage: The study focuses on cavern storage, highlighting its cost-effectiveness compared to above-ground vessels, provided suitable geological formations are available.

Key Results

  • Consistent NPV Improvement: The integrated CAES-NGCC system consistently showed a higher NPV than the NGCC-only system across all 14 studied regions. This indicates the general economic benefit of such integration.
  • Levelized Cost of Storage (LCOS): The LCOS for cavern storage was found to be in the range of $136–145/MWh, with some regions showing slightly higher costs (up to $176/MWh).
  • Roundtrip Efficiency (RTE): The calculated RTE for the integrated system ranged from 74.6% to 82.5%.
  • LMP Impact: Sensitivity analysis revealed that LMP has a significant impact on air injection/extraction rates. A favorable LMP profile (non-zero most of the time with substantial price differences) leads to higher utilization and NPV.
  • CAPEX Insignificance: Reductions in capital expenditure (CAPEX) had a negligible effect on the overall economics and operational strategies of the integrated CAES system, suggesting that market price dynamics are far more influential.
  • Regional Differences: While integration is beneficial everywhere, the optimal design and operating conditions varied significantly between regions, particularly in terms of cumulative air injection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cavern Availability Assumption: The study assumes the availability of suitable caverns in close proximity to NGCC plants. The economic feasibility is contingent on this geological prerequisite.
  • Model Simplifications: While a sophisticated dynamic model was developed, the ROM approach, though necessary for computational tractability, might introduce some discrepancies, especially at low-load conditions.
  • External Grid Interaction: The model treats the integrated system as isolated, meaning it doesn't consider interactions with the broader grid demand or the possibility of consuming power from the grid.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the development of ROMs that can achieve high accuracy across the entire load range, potentially by using a bank of linear models. Further investigation into the impact of CAPEX reduction and exploring other storage configurations (e.g., above-ground vessels) could also be valuable. The study also hints at the potential for further optimization by considering more complex thermal integration strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

To address the rising electricity demand and greenhouse gas concentration in the environment, considerable effort is being carried out across the globe on installing and operating renewable energy sources. However, the renewable energy production is affected by diurnal and seasonal variability. To ensure that the electric grid remains reliable and resilient even for the high penetration of renewables into the grid, various types of energy storage systems are being investigated. In this paper, a compressed-air energy storage (CAES) system integrated with a natural gas combined-cycle (NGCC) power plant is investigated where air is extracted from the gas turbine compressor or injected back into the gas turbine combustor when it is optimal to do so. First-principles dynamic models of the NGCC plant and CAES are developed along with the development of an economic model. The dynamic optimization of the integrated system is undertaken in the Python/Pyomo platform for maximizing the net present value (NPV). NPV optimization is undertaken for 14 regions/cases considering year-long locational marginal price (LMP) data with a 1 h interval. Design variables such as the storage capacity and storage pressure, as well as the operating variables such as the power plant load, air injection rate, and air extraction rate, are optimized. Results show that the integrated CAES system has a higher NPV than the NGCC-only system for all 14 regions, thus indicating the potential deployment of the integrated system under the assumption of the availability of caverns in close proximity to the NGCC plant. The levelized cost of storage is found to be in the range of 136–145 $/MWh. Roundtrip efficiency is found to be between 74.6–82.5%. A sensitivity study with respect to LMP shows that the LMP profile has a significant impact on the extent of air injection/extraction while capital expenditure reduction has a negligible effect.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sengalani2023techno,
  author = {Pavitra Senthamilselvan Sengalani and Md Emdadul Haque and Manali S. Zantye and Akhilesh Gandhi and Mengdi Li and M. M. Faruque Hasan and Debangsu Bhattacharyya},
  title = {{Techno-Economic Analysis and Optimization of a Compressed-Air Energy Storage System Integrated with a Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Plant}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16134867},
}
Figure