TL;DR
This paper introduces PlanLearn, a novel framework that teaches Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate and learn from abstract "plans" for problem-solving, rather than just concrete solutions. This approach significantly improves LLMs' generalization capabilities across diverse reasoning tasks, outperforming existing methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in various tasks, but their ability to generalize to unseen problems, especially in complex reasoning scenarios, remains a challenge. Current methods often rely on reinforcement learning (RL) with self-generated data, but this approach is hindered by the scarcity of accurate reward signals and the tendency to overfit to specific domains or tasks. Existing techniques often focus on learning to produce correct solutions directly, which can limit the model's ability to adapt to new problems. The paper argues that learning high-level problem-solving strategies (plans) is key to fostering transferable reasoning skills and achieving better generalization.
Methods
PlanLearn combines two main components:
- Plan-based MCTS (Monte Carlo Tree Search): Instead of searching for concrete solutions, PlanLearn uses MCTS to explore diverse abstract plans. These plans are natural language descriptions of high-level reasoning strategies (e.g., "break down the problem," "identify key information"). This allows for a broader exploration of problem-solving approaches.
- Step-APO (Step-level Advantage Preference Optimization): This is a novel preference learning method built upon Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Step-APO leverages advantage estimates from MCTS to learn preferences not just between complete solutions, but between individual steps within a plan. This allows the model to identify and prioritize critical steps that lead to better outcomes, enabling more effective optimization of plan learning.
The training process is iterative: MCTS generates plan data, which is then used to train the policy and value models using Step-APO.
Datasets
The paper uses the following datasets:
- In-domain Training: GSM8K and MATH.
- Out-of-domain Evaluation: HumanEval, ARC-C, GPQA, BBH, and MMLU-STEM.
The authors exclusively use the question-answer pairs from the training sets of GSM8K and MATH for training, omitting human-annotated solutions.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Plans over Solutions for Generalization: The core insight is that teaching LLMs to generate and learn from abstract plans, rather than just concrete solutions, is crucial for improving generalization. Plans represent transferable problem-solving strategies, while solutions are often task-specific.
- MCTS for Plan Exploration: Using MCTS to explore the space of abstract plans, rather than concrete solution steps, allows for a more diverse and effective search for high-level reasoning strategies.
- Step-level Optimization is Key: Learning preferences at the step level, and specifically identifying critical steps that provide significant advantages (as done by Step-APO), is more effective than simply learning preferences between entire solutions or using heuristic-based step-level methods.
- Data Construction Matters: The way preference data is constructed for training is important. The paper finds that emphasizing plan pairs over solution pairs leads to better performance, especially on out-of-domain tasks.
Key Results
- Significant In-domain Improvement: PlanLearn, trained exclusively on GSM8K and MATH, significantly improves performance on these datasets.
- Substantial Out-of-domain Gains: PlanLearn demonstrates impressive generalization capabilities, achieving average improvements of:
-
+12.2% on HumanEval
- +8.6% on GPQA
- +4.0% on ARC-C
- +2.2% on MMLU-STEM
- +1.8% on BBH These gains are compared to baseline models like DeepseekMath-Base, STaR, Self-Explore-MATH, and AlphaMath.
-
Effectiveness of Plan-based Learning: Experiments show that MCTS-based searching for high-level abstract plans consistently outperforms searching for concrete solutions on out-of-domain benchmarks.
- Step-APO Superiority: Step-APO outperforms other preference learning methods like Instance-DPO and Step-DPO, highlighting the benefit of incorporating advantage estimates for step-level preferences.
- Generalizability: PlanLearn shows strong performance improvements when applied to different LLM architectures (Qwen2.5-3B and Llama-3-8B), demonstrating its broad applicability.
Limitations and Future Work
- Math-Centric Training: The current evaluation primarily focuses on PlanLearn trained on mathematical reasoning tasks. Future work should explore whether PlanLearn's benefits extend to training data from other domains (e.g., code, commonsense reasoning) to assess its generalizability across different training paradigms.
- Ethical Considerations: The authors acknowledge that advancements in LLM reasoning capabilities, while beneficial, could be misused. They encourage future work and deployment to adhere to ethical guidelines and consider societal implications.
- Broader Domain Applicability: Investigating PlanLearn's effectiveness when the training data comes from domains beyond mathematics is a key future direction.
Summary updated