Tau Neutrinos in the Next Decade: from GeV to EeV

Roshan Mammen Abraham, Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz, C. Argüelles, A. Ariga, T. Ariga, A. Aurisano, Dario Autiero, M. Bishai, N. Bostan, Mauricio Bustamante, Austin Cummings, Valentin Decoene, André de Gouvêa, G. De Lellis, A. De Roeck, Peter B. Denton, A. Di Crescenzo, M. Diwan, Yasaman Farzan, Anatoli Fedynitch, Jonathan L. Feng, L. Fields, Alfonso Garcia, Maria Vittoria Garzelli, Julia Gehrlein, Christian Gläser, K. Grzelak, S. Hallmann, Jeremy Hewes, D. Indumathi, Ahmed Ismail, Sudip Jana, Yu Seon Jeong, Kevin J. Kelly, S. R. Klein, Felix Kling, T. Kosc, U. Köse, D. J. Koskinen, John Krizmanic, Jeff Lazar, Yichen Li, Ivan Martínez-Soler, Irina Mocioiu, Jiwoo Nam, V. Niess, A. N. Otte, Sameer H. Patel, R. Petti, Remy Prechelt, Steven Prohira, M. Rajaoalisoa, Mary Hall Reno, I. Safa, Carlos Sarasty-Segura, R. Thiru Senthil, Juliana Stachurska, Oleksandr Tomalak, Sebastian Trojanowski, R. A. Wendell, Dawn Williams, Stephanie Wissel, B. Yaeggy, E. Zas, Pavel Zhelnin, Jingyu ZhuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Tau neutrinos are the least studied particle in the Standard Model. This whitepaper discusses the current and expected upcoming status of tau neutrino physics with attention to the broad experimental and theoretical landscape spanning long-baseline, beam-dump, collider, and astrophysical experiments. This whitepaper was prepared as a part of the NuTau2021 Workshop.

Introduction: The "Final Frontier"

Tau neutrinos ($\nu_\tau$) represent the "final frontier" of the Standard Model’s lepton sector. Despite being predicted decades ago, they remain largely unprobed due to the extreme difficulty of their production and detection. In the Standard Model, neutrinos come in three flavors: electron, muon, and tau. While millions of electron and muon neutrinos have been detected, the global collection of tau neutrinos historically numbered only in the dozens.

This scarcity stems from two primary factors: the "threshold problem," where high energies are required to produce a tau lepton, and the fact that the resulting tau lepton decays almost instantly. These decays leave signatures that are notoriously difficult to distinguish from background noise. This data gap is a major blind spot; without precise $\nu_\tau$ measurements, we cannot fully test Lepton Flavor Universality or confirm the unitarity of the PMNS neutrino mixing matrix. A non-unitary matrix would be a "smoking gun" for new physics, such as sterile neutrinos or extra dimensions.

The landscape of tau neutrino physics across energy scales, showing cross-sections, relevant physics topics, and detection techniques.

Experimental Frontiers

To address these challenges, the community is pursuing a multi-pronged strategy across four main frontiers:

  1. Long-Baseline Accelerators: High-intensity beams, such as those planned for DUNE, will observe $\nu_\mu \to \nu_\tau$ oscillations over hundreds of kilometers.
  2. Beam-Dump & Fixed Target: Experiments like SHiP and DsTau (NA65) aim to produce $\nu_\tau$ directly by smashing protons into heavy targets, using high-resolution emulsion detectors to identify the characteristic "kink" of a tau decay.
  3. Collider Neutrinos: The "forward" region of the LHC (e.g., FASER$\nu$, SND@LHC) is being utilized to detect TeV-scale neutrinos produced in primary collisions, a relatively new and cost-effective window into high-energy neutrino physics.
  4. High-Energy Astrophysics: Ultra-high-energy (UHE) neutrinos from deep space can strike the Earth, producing tau leptons that "skim" the surface. These create massive particle showers detectable by large-scale radio and optical arrays like IceCube-Gen2, GRAND, and POEMMA.

Current Status and Future Projections

The field is currently at a turning point. Historically, the DONuT experiment provided the first direct detection with 9 candidate events, followed by OPERA's confirmation of $\nu_\mu \to \nu_\tau$ oscillations with 10 events. More recently, Super-Kamiokande and IceCube have provided larger samples (hundreds to ~1,800 events) through statistical extractions.

The cumulative number of $\nu_\tau$ detections is now doubling approximately every two years. Future projections are even more promising: DUNE is expected to record ~1,000 $\nu_\tau$ events per year, and the Forward Physics Facility at the LHC could collect thousands more, transitioning the field into a high-precision era.

Physics Potential and Key Insights

Precision $\nu_\tau$ data is essential for several key scientific goals:

  • Unitarity Tests: The "tau row" of the PMNS mixing matrix is currently the least constrained. Precision data is the only way to check if the matrix "leaks" into hidden sectors.
  • Regeneration: A unique phenomenon in UHE physics is that $\nu_\tau$ can travel through the Earth more effectively than other flavors. While $\nu_e$ and $\nu_\mu$ are absorbed, $\nu_\tau$ undergo a "regeneration" cycle ($\nu_\tau \to \tau \to \nu_\tau$), allowing them to emerge from the far side of the planet.
  • New Physics Constraints: $\nu_\tau$ are uniquely sensitive to certain Dark Matter models and Non-Standard Interactions (NSI) that are nearly invisible to electron and muon neutrino experiments.

Challenges and Theoretical Needs

Despite the experimental progress, several hurdles remain. Theoretical uncertainties in predicting $\nu_\tau$ flux are limited by our understanding of charm quark production in proton collisions, requiring better QCD modeling. Furthermore, at GeV energies, the $\nu_\tau$ cross-section is complex and necessitates more sophisticated nuclear physics simulations. Finally, to manage the expected flood of data, the community must transition from traditional manual identification techniques to automated Machine Learning approaches (such as GNNs and CNNs) for identifying tau signatures in Liquid Argon and Cherenkov detectors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tau neutrinos are the least studied particle in the Standard Model. This whitepaper discusses the current and expected upcoming status of tau neutrino physics with attention to the broad experimental and theoretical landscape spanning long-baseline, beam-dump, collider, and astrophysical experiments. This whitepaper was prepared as a part of the NuTau2021 Workshop.
BibTeX
@misc{abraham2022tau,
  author = {Roshan Mammen Abraham and Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz and C. Argüelles and A. Ariga and T. Ariga and A. Aurisano and Dario Autiero and M. Bishai and N. Bostan and Mauricio Bustamante and Austin Cummings and Valentin Decoene and André de Gouvêa and G. De Lellis and A. De Roeck and Peter B. Denton and A. Di Crescenzo and M. Diwan and Yasaman Farzan and Anatoli Fedynitch and Jonathan L. Feng and L. Fields and Alfonso Garcia and Maria Vittoria Garzelli and Julia Gehrlein and Christian Gläser and K. Grzelak and S. Hallmann and Jeremy Hewes and D. Indumathi and Ahmed Ismail and Sudip Jana and Yu Seon Jeong and Kevin J. Kelly and S. R. Klein and Felix Kling and T. Kosc and U. Köse and D. J. Koskinen and John Krizmanic and Jeff Lazar and Yichen Li and Ivan Martínez-Soler and Irina Mocioiu and Jiwoo Nam and V. Niess and A. N. Otte and Sameer H. Patel and R. Petti and Remy Prechelt and Steven Prohira and M. Rajaoalisoa and Mary Hall Reno and I. Safa and Carlos Sarasty-Segura and R. Thiru Senthil and Juliana Stachurska and Oleksandr Tomalak and Sebastian Trojanowski and R. A. Wendell and Dawn Williams and Stephanie Wissel and B. Yaeggy and E. Zas and Pavel Zhelnin and Jingyu Zhu},
  title = {{Tau Neutrinos in the Next Decade: from GeV to EeV}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.05591},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.05591},
}
Figure