Taste Attributes of the “June Hairy Crab” Juveniles of Chinese Mitten Crab (Eriocheir sinensis) in Yangcheng Lake, China—A Pilot Study

Hongbo Liu, Junren Xue, Jing Tang, Tao Jiang, Xiubao Chen, Jian YangFishes 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses an electronic tongue to quantitatively analyze the taste profiles of "June hairy crab" juveniles, revealing umami as the dominant taste. The findings highlight significant differences in taste attributes between male and female crabs, suggesting a potential link to consumer preference.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Chinese mitten crab (Eriocheir sinensis) is a highly valued delicacy, particularly in China. While mature crabs are typically consumed in autumn, there's a growing market for immature "June hairy crabs" due to their high hepatopancreas lipid content and the desire for off-season availability. However, the specific taste profiles of these juveniles, especially when sourced from different culture environments (lake vs. pond), have not been well-characterized. This study aims to fill this knowledge gap by quantitatively assessing the taste attributes of June hairy crabs and exploring how these attributes differ between sexes and culture types.

Methods

The researchers employed an SA402B Taste Sensing System, an electronic tongue equipped with five liquid membrane sensors and two reference electrodes. This system is designed to mimic human taste perception by detecting various taste components.

Key steps included:

  • Sample Preparation: June hairy crabs were collected from both lake enclosure and pond culture areas. Their hepatopancreas (the organ rich in lipids and considered a delicacy) was extracted after steaming.
  • Homogenization and Centrifugation: The hepatopancreas was homogenized with deionized water and then centrifuged to obtain a clear supernatant for analysis.
  • Taste Sensing System Analysis: The supernatant was analyzed using the electronic tongue. The system measures taste intensities for umami, bitterness, and astringency, as well as their respective aftertastes (aftertaste-U, aftertaste-B, aftertaste-A). Saltiness was found to be unreliable due to the high lipid content of the samples.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Mann-Whitney U test was used to compare taste differences between male and female crabs.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) were applied to visualize and differentiate taste profiles based on culture type and sex.

Datasets

The study utilized June hairy crab hepatopancreas samples collected in July 2021 from two distinct culture environments in Yangcheng Lake, China:

  1. Lake Culture: Crabs from a net enclosure culture area.
  2. Pond Culture: Crabs from aquaculture ponds near Yangcheng Lake.

Both male and female crabs were sampled from each culture type. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study generated its own data from these specific crab samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Umami Dominance: Umami is the most prominent basic taste in June hairy crab hepatopancreas, suggesting it's a key driver of its perceived deliciousness. This aligns with the high content of glutamic acid, a known umami enhancer, found in crab tissues.
  • Aftertaste-U as a Key Indicator: The aftertaste of umami (aftertaste-U) was significantly higher in male crabs and generally higher than other aftertastes in both sexes. This strong aftertaste-U is considered a desirable trait in food and may contribute significantly to the overall appeal of June hairy crabs.
  • Sex-Based Taste Differences: The electronic tongue and subsequent statistical analyses (PCA and LDA) were highly effective at distinguishing between male and female June hairy crabs based on their taste profiles. This suggests that sex plays a more significant role in shaping the taste of the hepatopancreas than the culture environment.
  • Saltiness Measurement Challenges: The high lipid content of the hepatopancreas interfered with the saltiness sensor, rendering its readings unreliable. This highlights a common challenge when using electronic tongues for high-fat foods and suggests the need for specialized sensor adaptations or sample pretreatments for such analyses.
  • Cultural Significance: The study underscores the importance of the "June hairy crab" as a commercially relevant off-season product, driven by consumer demand and farmer innovation.

Key Results

  • Predominant Tastes: Umami was the strongest basic taste, followed by bitterness and then astringency.
  • Aftertaste Differences: Male crabs showed significantly higher aftertaste-U compared to aftertaste-B and aftertaste-A. Female crabs lacked aftertaste-B and had higher aftertaste-U than aftertaste-A.
  • Sex Discrimination: PCA and LDA successfully distinguished between male and female crabs with high accuracy (100% for LDA in preliminary classification).
  • Culture Discrimination: The study found no significant differences in taste attributes between lake-cultured and pond-cultured crabs, suggesting that culture method had a less pronounced impact than sex.
  • Saltiness Unreliable: The saltiness intensity values were aberrant and could not be reliably determined.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Saltiness Measurement: The inability to reliably measure saltiness due to the high lipid content is a significant limitation. Future research could explore modified sensor technologies or sample preparation techniques to overcome this.
  • Culture Type Comparison: While the study found no significant differences between lake and pond cultures, this was a pilot study. Further investigation with larger sample sizes or different culture parameters might reveal subtle differences.
  • Consumer Preference Correlation: The study focused on objective taste measurements. Future work could directly correlate these taste profiles with consumer sensory evaluations and preferences to confirm the link between specific taste attributes (like high aftertaste-U) and perceived deliciousness.
  • Broader Geographic Scope: This study focused on Yangcheng Lake. Expanding the analysis to crabs from other regions could provide a more comprehensive understanding of regional taste variations.

Summary updated

Abstract

This is the first report on the use of a taste sensing system to quantitatively evaluate the taste attributes of two groups of native “June hairy crab” juveniles (commonly referred to as “Liu-Yue-Huang”) of the Chinese mitten crab (Eriocheir Sinensis H. Milne Edwards, 1853) from a net enclosure culture area in Yangcheng Lake (lake culture) and aquaculture ponds near the lake (pond culture). We showed that umami was the predominant basic taste of steamed June hairy crabs, followed by bitterness and astringency. The intensity value of saltiness was aberrant and could not be determined using this system. The average values of aftertaste-U reached 8.7 and 10.7 in the male June hairy crabs from the lake and pond cultures, respectively, which was significantly higher than their respective aftertaste-B and aftertaste-A values (p < 0.01). Female crabs did not have aftertaste-B, while their aftertaste-U was significantly higher than aftertaste-A (p < 0.01). Although principal component analysis and linear discriminant analysis were not able to completely distinguish among crabs from different cultures, they could robustly distinguish between male and female crabs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022taste,
  author = {Hongbo Liu and Junren Xue and Jing Tang and Tao Jiang and Xiubao Chen and Jian Yang},
  title = {{Taste Attributes of the “June Hairy Crab” Juveniles of Chinese Mitten Crab (Eriocheir sinensis) in Yangcheng Lake, China—A Pilot Study}},
  booktitle = {Fishes},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/fishes7030128},
}
Figure