This paper successfully demonstrates the application of CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing in ryegrass, a crucial forage crop. They achieved targeted mutations in two genes, LpDMC1 and LpCENH3, leading to male sterility and meiotic defects in LpDMC1 mutants, paving the way for precise trait improvement in this economically important plant.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Ryegrass is a cornerstone of global agriculture, vital for dairy and meat production. Despite its economic significance, breeding advancements have been slow, largely due to the challenges posed by gametophyte self-incompatibility and the laborious nature of traditional selection methods. While CRISPR/Cas9 has revolutionized genetic engineering in many crops, its application in ryegrass remained unexplored. This paper addresses the critical need for a precise and efficient genetic manipulation tool in ryegrass to accelerate trait improvement, focusing on understanding and potentially manipulating meiotic processes and other agronomic traits.
Methods
The researchers employed the CRISPR/Cas9 system for targeted mutagenesis. They designed single-guide RNAs (sgRNAs) to target specific exons in two genes: LpDMC1 (involved in meiosis) and LpCENH3 (involved in chromosome transmission).
Key methodological steps included:
Protoplast Transient Expression: Initial testing of sgRNA activity was performed in ryegrass protoplasts using PEG-mediated transformation. This allowed for rapid assessment of CRISPR/Cas9's ability to induce indel mutations at the target sites, confirmed by PCR/Restriction Enzyme digestion (PCR/RE) assays.
Stable Transformation: For generating whole plants, sgRNA expression cassettes and the Cas9 nuclease were delivered into embryogenic callus (EC) lines of Italian and perennial ryegrass via gold particle bombardment. This was coupled with a hygromycin resistance gene for selection of transformed cells.
Gene Targeting: They specifically targeted exon 5 of LpDMC1 and exon 3 of LpCENH3. The sgRNA for LpDMC1 was designed with an adjacent restriction enzyme site (XceI) to facilitate mutation detection.
Mutation Detection: Indel mutations at the target sites were identified using PCR/RE assays and confirmed by Sanger sequencing.
Off-Target Analysis: Putative off-target sites were predicted using the Lolium perenne draft genome, and selected sites were analyzed by PCR and sequencing in the generated mutants.
Phenotypic Analysis: Meiotic chromosomes were visualized using DAPI staining, and pollen viability was assessed using iodine-potassium iodide (I2-KI) staining.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing genomic resources for Lolium perenne for off-target prediction.
Key Insights and Ideas
CRISPR/Cas9 is effective in ryegrass: This is the foundational insight, demonstrating that this powerful gene-editing tool can be successfully applied to ryegrass, overcoming previous limitations.
Targeting meiotic genes has significant consequences: The disruption of LpDMC1, a crucial meiotic recombinase, led to complete male sterility and severely disordered meiosis. This highlights the potential for using CRISPR/Cas9 to study and manipulate reproductive processes in ryegrass.
Off-target effects appear minimal: Despite careful prediction and analysis, no off-target mutations were detected in the analyzed sites, suggesting a high degree of specificity for the designed sgRNAs in this system.
Rapid generation of mutants: Compared to traditional breeding methods, CRISPR/Cas9 offers a significantly faster route to generating genetically modified plants with specific traits.
Key Results
Successful gene editing: The researchers successfully introduced targeted mutations in LpDMC1 and LpCENH3 in both Italian and perennial ryegrass.
LpDMC1 mutants exhibit male sterility: T0 null mutants of LpDMC1 showed complete male sterility, with pollen grains appearing shrunken and empty.
Meiotic defects observed: Analysis of LpDMC1 mutants revealed severely disordered meiosis, characterized by the presence of univalents and multivalents at diakinesis, unlike the regular bivalent formation in wild-type plants.
Generation of homozygous and heterozygous mutants: The study successfully generated both homozygous and heterozygous T0 mutants for LpDMC1.
Transformation efficiencies: Mean transformation efficiencies for the three selected EC lines ranged from 2.66% to 4.50%.
No detectable off-target mutations: Analysis of predicted off-target sites did not reveal any mutations in the generated mutants.
Limitations and Future Work
Difficulty in obtaining homozygous T1 mutants: Due to gametophyte self-incompatibility and different vernalization requirements in ryegrass, obtaining homozygous T1 mutants was challenging and time-consuming.
Future Work: The authors express their intention to use genome editing tools to improve other agronomic traits in ryegrass, anticipating that this method will become a routine tool for this economically important forage crop. They also highlight the potential for studying conserved meiotic genes like DMC1 to understand fertility and genetic diversity.
Summary updated
Abstract
Ryegrass is one of the most important forage crops worldwide. It is the basis for 80% of milk production and 70% of meat production and has major economic importance. Breeding programmes for ryegrass started in the 1920s, and breeders have mainly relied on repeated phenotypic and recently genotypic selection of elite individuals. Although this approach has led to significant improvements in several characters including rust resistance, spring growth and aftermath heading, it tends to be laborious, expensive and time-consuming, mainly due to gametophyte self-incompatibility in most ryegrass species (Sampoux et al., 2011). In order to overcome some of the limitations of traditional introgression and selective breeding, modern methods of mutation induction offer attractive opportunities to target specific genes of interest and directly introduce allelic variability. In the last decade, the Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats/CRISPR-associated endonuclease 9 (CRISPR/Cas9) system has been extensively used in most crops and is paving the way to precision trait improvements in factors including yield, quality, biotic- and abiotic stress resistance and breeding rate (Chen et al., 2019; Ran et al., 2017; Wang et al., 2014). However, this powerful tool for genome editing has not yet been used in ryegrass. Meiosis arose early during the evolution of eukaryotes and is vital for sexual reproduction, not only in relation to genomic stability but also to genetic diversity. Meiotic studies of plants in the areas of crop fertility and genetic variation have important potential agronomical applications. DMC1 (DISRUPTED MEIOTIC cDNA1), initially identified in yeast (Bishop et al., 1992) as a homolog of the bacterial strand exchange protein RecA, is a crucial meiotic recombinase. Here, we describe the use of the CRISPR/Cas9 system to introduce mutations in LpDMC1 in two species: Italian ryegrass (Lolium perenne ssp. multiflorum) and perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne). We succeeded in obtaining both T0 homozygous and heterozygous mutants, and the T0 null mutants of Italian ryegrass exhibited complete male sterility and severely disordered meiosis with univalents and multivalents appearing at diakinesis. To see whether mutations could be introduced into ryegrass using the CRISPR/Cas9 system, we generated a sgRNA (TS-LpDMC1) targeting exon 5 of LpDMC1, with an XceI restriction enzyme site near the protospacer-adjacent motif (PAM) for ease of analysis (Figure 1a). Because plant tissue culture and genetic transformation are time-consuming, we tested the activities of sgRNA in a protoplast transient expression system as described by Shan et al. (2013). TS-LpDMC1 promoted by TaU6 was co-introduced with SpCas9 into ryegrass protoplasts by PEG-mediated transformation. After 40- to 48-h incubation, analysis of genomic DNA using a PCR restriction enzyme digestion assay (PCR/RE) demonstrated the occurrence of indel mutations at the target site (Data not shown). To determine whether the CRISPR/Cas9 method was applicable to other ryegrass genes, we targeted the ryegrass orthologue of centromere-specific histone H3 variant (CENH3). In Arabidopsis thaliana, CENH3 ensures faithful transmission of the genome at cell division, and when cenh3 null mutants producing altered CENH3 proteins are crossed with wild type, many haploid Arabidopsis plants are generated (Ravi and Chan, 2010). When we co-transformed a sgRNA targeting exon 3 of LpCENH3 along with SpCas9 into protoplasts (Figure 1d), PCR/RE analysis revealed frameshift mutations at the target site (Figure 1e). These results show that CRISPR/Cas9 can be used to generate mutations in ryegrass. Next, the sgRNA expression cassette was combined with SpCas9 in a single DNA construct by GIBSON Assembly and introduced along with a hygromycin-resistant plasmid into preconditioned embryogenic callus (EC) lines of ryegrass by gold particles bombardment. To generate these EC lines, seeds of Italian ryegrass cultivar Gepetto and perennial ryegrass cultivar Goyave were de-husked and sterilized, and somatic EC lines were established as described (Ran et al., 2014). Three separate lines designated Gepetto-8, Gepetto-66 and Goyave LMG LDF-Lp3711 (provided by DLF Seeds) with outstanding regeneration ability were selected for transformation. After bombardment, the EC was transferred to hygromycin medium. Surviving calli were obtained after 4 weeks’ induction and sub-culture. Thereafter, they were regenerated for 8 weeks; and plantlets with established roots were transferred to potting mix for mutants’ identification. The mean transformation efficiencies of these three lines were 3.83%, 4.50% and 2.66%, respectively. The entire experimental cycle took approximately 10 months from target design to mutant identification. Compared with conventional methods, CRISPR/Cas9 provides a rapid and straightforward method for genetic manipulation of ryegrass. T0 generation LpDMC1 knockout mutants were identified by PCR/RE using the same primers as in the protoplast assays (Figure 1b), followed by Sanger sequencing. In total, we obtained eight mutants in two species: seven of Italian ryegrass and one of perennial ryegrass. G8-12 was a homozygous mutant with a 9 bp in-frame deletion in one allele. The other non-wild-type plant G8-16 was a mosaic, with three mutations: −1 bp, −33 bp deletions and −10/+37 bp deletion/insertion. The other six were heterozygotes (Figure 1c). The genome editing efficiencies of LpDMC1 in Gepetto-8, Gepetto-66 and Goyave LMG LDF-Lp3711 were 11.63%, 11.11% and 5.88%, respectively. To detect off-target events, putative off-target sites of TS-LpDMC1 were predicted using the draft genome sequence of the forage grass Lolium perenne (Byrne et al., 2015) (Figure 1f). Two non-mismatch off-target sites, LpOff3 and LpOff4, with highly similar surrounding sequences, which could produce mutations in two different non-coding regions, were selected for further study. PCR products that included LpOff3/LpOff4 from the eight mutants were sequenced, but no mutations were detected (Figure 1g). The next-closest match was LpOff5, which had an imperfect PAM, suggesting that off-target events would be unlikely (Figure 1f). Because Italian and perennial ryegrass are both gametophyte self-incompatibility and have different vernalization requirements, it was difficult and time-consuming to obtain homozygous T1 mutants. Since disruption of DMC1 in Arabidopsis, rice and barley usually leads to reduced fertility, we examined the pollen grains produced by wild type and the T0 Lpdmc1 mutant G8-16. Upon iodine-potassium iodide (I2-KI) staining, the pollen grains from the wild type appeared mostly round, while those from G8-16 were empty and shrunken (Figure 1h,i). This phenotype points to complete male sterility, as in the Osdmc1a Osdmc1b Tos-17 double insertion mutant of rice (Wang et al., 2016). The wild type pollen grains did not stain as strongly as those of rice, probably due to the difference in starch content between Italian ryegrass and rice. To clarify what happened during Lpdmc1 meiosis, we stained meiotic chromosomes with 4’,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI). The meiotic chromosomes of the Lpdmc1 mutant behaved normally at leptotene (Figure 1j,m). However at diplotene, whereas circular or figure-of-eight shapes of the chromatids were observed in wild type (Figure 1k), in the Lpdmc1 mutant the chromatids were stuck together, mostly due to the existence of multivalents (Figure 1n). At diakinesis, unlike the wild type, which formed 7 bivalents (Figure 1l), condensed univalents and multivalents were scattered throughout the mutant nuclei (Figure 1o). These results point to a meiotic defect in the Lpdmc1 mutant. In summary, we were able to introduce mutations in two genes, LpDMC1 and LpCENH3, of ryegrass in vivo using the CRISPR/Cas9 system. We obtained eight T0 knockout mutants of LpDMC1 in Italian and perennial ryegrass. The Lpdmc1 null mutants were completely male sterile with severely disrupted meiosis, indicating that DMC1, a highly conserved protein, plays a pivotal role in meiosis in many species. We are now using genome editing tools to improve other agronomic traits in ryegrass. We anticipate that this method will come to be used routinely in this economically important forage crop. We thank Professor Zhukuan Cheng's group for helping with meiotic chromosome preparation. This work was supported by grants from the National Transgenic Science and Technology Program of China (2019ZX08010-001, 2019ZX08010-003 and 2018ZX0801002B), the Scientific Program of Beijing Municipal Commission of Science and Technology (Z171100001517001) and Innovation Fund Denmark (6150-00020B). The authors declare no conflict of interest. Y.Z., J.-L.Q., C.S.J. and C.G. designed the experiments; I.N. and T.A. provided genomics and bioinformatics support; Y.R. performed the genetic transformation of ryegrasses; I.L. and C.S.J. provided the ryegrass seeds; Y.Z. performed the molecular and cytologic experiments; C.G supervised the project; and Y.Z., Y.R. and C.G. wrote the manuscript.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020targeted,
author = {Yunwei Zhang and Yidong Ran and István Nagy and Ingo Lenk and Jin‐Long Qiu and Torben Asp and Christian S. Jensen and Caixia Gao},
title = {{Targeted mutagenesis in ryegrass (<i>Lolium</i> spp.) using the CRISPR/Cas9 system}},
booktitle = {Plant},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1111/pbi.13359},
}