Targeted hand hygiene audits and training: an effective tool for improvement in hand hygiene compliance

Ankita Chaurasia, Sujit Bharti, Vijeta Bajpai, Anwita Mishra, Avinash Sharma, Ranjeet Singh, Rahul SarodeInternational Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health 2024 · DOI

This study, published in the International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health, explores how a combination of targeted audits and phased training can significantly boost hand hygiene (HH) compliance in high-risk hospital settings. By comparing "overt" (visible) and "covert" (hidden) observations, the researchers quantified the "Hawthorne effect" and demonstrated that regular, workstation-specific feedback is a cost-effective way to reduce hospital-acquired infections.

TL;DR

Researchers implemented a two-phase intervention of audits and motivational training in a cancer hospital, resulting in a significant increase in hand hygiene compliance (e.g., ICU compliance jumped from ~52% to ~70%). The study highlights that while health care workers change their behavior when watched (the Hawthorne effect), consistent, decentralized auditing is the most effective tool for long-term behavioral change.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hospital-acquired infections (HAIs) and multidrug-resistant organisms (MDROs) are a primary cause of morbidity, particularly for immunocompromised patients in cancer wards and ICUs. While hand hygiene is the simplest and most effective way to prevent these infections, global compliance remains stubbornly low.

The authors identify a specific gap: in many developing regions, minimal effort is directed toward continuous HH monitoring. Furthermore, measuring compliance is difficult because of the Hawthorne effect—the tendency of individuals to improve their behavior specifically because they know they are being observed. This paper seeks to determine if a structured, phased training program can create lasting improvements and how the presence of an auditor influences different types of healthcare workers (HCWs).

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective observational study at a tertiary care cancer center in Varanasi, India, divided into two phases (Sept–Dec 2021 and March–May 2022).

The study utilized a dual-observation strategy:

  • Overt Observation: A trained senior resident (the "HH auditor") performed 30-minute audits in plain sight.
  • Covert Observation: An Infection Control Nurse (ICN) performed separate 30-minute observations secretly to establish a baseline of "natural" behavior.

Observations were based on the WHO "5 Moments for Hand Hygiene":

  1. Before touching a patient.
  2. Before an aseptic procedure.
  3. After body fluid exposure risk.
  4. After touching a patient.
  5. After touching patient surroundings.

Between the two phases, the hospital implemented monthly workstation-specific training where HH compliance data was shared directly with the staff to motivate improvement.

Datasets

The "dataset" for this study consisted of 3,977 hand hygiene opportunities observed across three high-risk areas:

  • Intensive Care Unit (ICU)
  • Haemato-lymphoid (HL) ward
  • Paediatric ward

A total of 2,168 observations were overt, and 1,809 were covert. Sample size was calculated using a standard formula for 95% confidence intervals, resulting in a target of at least 1,067 observations to ensure statistical power.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Moment 5" Breakthrough: The most significant improvement across all locations occurred in "Moment 5" (after touching patient surroundings). This suggests that HCWs often underestimate the risk of contamination from bed railings or bedside tables, but are highly responsive to training on this specific point.
  • The Shifting Hawthorne Effect: Interestingly, the Hawthorne effect wasn't uniform. In the first phase, nurses actually showed higher compliance during covert observation (61.96% vs 52.45%). By the second phase, doctors showed the classic Hawthorne effect, with significantly higher compliance when they knew they were being watched (67.01% overt vs 54.73% covert).
  • Decentralization is Key: The authors argue that having workstation-specific auditors (rather than a single centralized team) is the most cost-effective approach for developing countries to maintain high adherence.
  • Auditor Efficiency: The study noted that regular auditing doesn't just improve the staff; it improves the auditor’s ability to identify missed opportunities, creating a more robust surveillance system over time.

Key Results

The intervention led to statistically significant improvements across the board:

  • ICU: Compliance rose from 52.24% to 70.08% ($p < 0.001$).
  • HL Ward: Compliance rose from 59.34% to 68.48% ($p = 0.028$).
  • Paediatric Ward: Compliance rose from 43.42% to 53.46% ($p = 0.006$).
  • Profession-Specific Gains: Doctors in the ICU showed the most dramatic improvement, jumping from 40% to 74.49% compliance between the two sessions.
  • Overall Compliance: When combining all observations, the covert compliance (60.20%) was slightly higher than overt (57.43%), though the gap narrowed as training progressed.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Duration: The audits were conducted over specific 30-minute windows, which may not capture the full variability of a 24-hour hospital cycle.
  • Observer Bias: Even with covert observation, the presence of an ICN in a ward might eventually be noticed, potentially tainting the "covert" nature of the data.
  • Long-term Sustainability: The study does not track whether these improvements persist after the formal six-month study period ends.

Future Work: The authors suggest that future studies should link HH compliance rates directly to actual infection rates (HAIs) in the wards to quantify the clinical impact of the improved compliance. They also recommend investigating the use of automated or electronic monitoring systems to eliminate observer bias entirely.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Hand hygiene (HH) is the simplest, but most effective infection prevention and control measure. This study was aimed to determine HH compliance among health care workers (HCWs) in a cancer hospital and the impact of targeted and phased training over changes in HH compliance and determination of Hawthorne effect among HCWs. Methods: Prospective observational study conducted in two phases by HH trained auditor (Overt observer) and ICN (Covert observer) performing 30 minutes HH audit at ICU, haemato-lymphoid (HL) ward and paediatric ward to observe the pattern of HH compliance among HCW for HH moments and its impact over Hawthorne effect for HH compliance. Results: Highest compliance for HH was observed at HL ward (59.34%) in first phase and at ICU (70.08%) in second phase. Gradual and significant improvement in HH compliance was observed for ICU (52.24% to 70.08%), HL ward (59.34% to 68.48%) and paediatric ward (43.42% to 53.46%). Profession specific Hawthorne effect was observed for nurses with higher compliance in covert observation in first phase and for doctors with higher compliance in overt observation in second phase of the study. Conclusions: Regular targeted HH audit with motivational training is the better influential tool for improving HH compliance. Regular audits also improve efficiency of auditor for effective HH compliance supervision. Decentralization and availability of workstation specific HH auditor is the most of effective cost saving approach for achieving significant progressive improvement in HH adherence.
BibTeX
@article{chaurasia2024targeted,
  author = {Ankita Chaurasia and Sujit Bharti and Vijeta Bajpai and Anwita Mishra and Avinash Sharma and Ranjeet Singh and Rahul Sarode},
  title = {{Targeted hand hygiene audits and training: an effective tool for improvement in hand hygiene compliance}},
  journal = {International Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18203/2394-6040.ijcmph20240671},
}
Figure