Targeted cortical stimulation reveals principles of cortical contextual interactions

Shen Wang, Agostina Palmigiano, Kenneth D. Miller, Stephen D. Van HooserBiorxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses optogenetics to precisely stimulate specific cortical columns in ferrets, revealing that while cortical circuits contribute to visual processing normalization, they are not the primary driver of cross-orientation suppression. The findings suggest that cortical circuits exhibit weaker normalization than previously thought and highlight the complex interplay between excitation and inhibition in shaping neural responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Visual cortex neurons don't just respond to the stimulus directly in front of them; their responses are heavily influenced by surrounding stimuli. A classic example is "cross-orientation suppression," where a stimulus at a neuron's preferred orientation elicits a weaker response when an orthogonal stimulus is also present. While this phenomenon is well-documented, the exact cortical mechanisms responsible for it have been debated. Some theories point to feed-forward inputs from the thalamus (LGN), while others suggest internal cortical circuits play a significant role. This paper aims to disentangle these contributions by using optogenetics to directly stimulate specific cortical columns and compare these responses to visual stimulation, thereby probing the role of cortical circuits in normalization.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated technique called ProjectorScope 2, which combines intrinsic signal imaging (to map orientation preferences of cortical neurons) with patterned optogenetic stimulation. This allowed them to precisely target and activate specific orientation columns with light. They then recorded neural activity using electrodes to observe how neurons integrated these optogenetic inputs with visual stimuli. To investigate the role of inhibitory neurons, they used a virus to express a light-sensitive channel (ChR2) specifically in inhibitory cells and then stimulated them with light. They also developed quantitative measures like the Linearity Index (LI) and Marginal Orthogonal Drive Angle (MODA) to characterize the non-linear interactions between different stimuli. Finally, they built computational models of cortical circuits to test hypotheses about the observed responses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from adult ferrets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cortical circuits are not the main driver of cross-orientation suppression: The most striking finding is that when orthogonal stimuli are delivered optogenetically to cortical columns, the suppression observed is significantly weaker than when the same orthogonal stimulus is presented visually. This suggests that much of the cross-orientation suppression seen in visual cortex originates from earlier processing stages, like the LGN.
  • Integration of visual and optogenetic signals is context-dependent: Neurons integrate visual and optogenetic inputs differently. At low firing rates, the integration is largely linear, but it becomes sublinear at higher firing rates. This suggests that simple single-neuron saturation isn't the sole explanation for sublinearity.
  • Inhibitory neurons exhibit diverse and sometimes paradoxical responses: Optogenetically stimulating inhibitory neurons revealed a spectrum of responses. Some showed expected increases in activity, while others exhibited "paradoxical" responses where increased stimulation led to a decrease in their firing rate. This is a hallmark of inhibition-stabilized networks, where strong recurrent excitation is balanced by inhibition.
  • Cortical normalization is present but weaker than expected: While cortical circuits do contribute to normalization, the observed level of suppression from stimulating orthogonal columns was not sufficient to explain the full phenomenon of cross-orientation suppression. This implies that the normalization mechanisms within cortex are more subtle or operate differently than a direct suppression mechanism.

Key Results

  • Optogenetic stimulation of orthogonal orientation columns resulted in significantly less suppression compared to visual stimulation of orthogonal columns.
  • The integration of visual and optogenetic signals was linear at low neuronal firing rates and became sublinear at higher firing rates.
  • A subset of inhibitory neurons showed paradoxical responses, where optogenetic stimulation led to a decrease in their firing rate, consistent with inhibition-stabilized network dynamics.
  • Computational models that incorporated weaker cortical normalization and relied more on feed-forward inputs better matched the experimental data.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their optogenetic stimulation, even when patterned, caused activity to spread non-specifically to neighboring columns, making it challenging to isolate the precise effects of stimulating individual columns. They also note that their model of inhibitory neurons was simplified and that future experiments should investigate the roles of specific interneuron subtypes. They suggest that future work could explore how these findings apply to other cortical areas and different visual computations, as well as investigate the precise mechanisms within the LGN that contribute to cross-orientation suppression. The development of more targeted optogenetic tools for specific interneuron populations is also highlighted as a crucial next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cross-orientation suppression is a classic form of contextual normalization in visual cortex, yet the degree to which cortical circuits participate in the normalization computation is unclear. We visualized orientation maps of individual ferrets, and provided patterned optogenetic stimulation to both excitatory and inhibitory cells in orientation columns that either matched or were orthogonal to the preferred visual orientation of neurons recorded with electrodes. When visual or optogenetic stimulation of columns preferring one orientation was combined with optogenetic stimulation of columns preferring the orthogonal orientation, we observed less suppression than when orthogonal stimulation was provided visually, suggesting that cortical circuits do not provide a large fraction of visual cross-orientation suppression. Integration of visual and optogenetic signals was linear when neurons exhibited low firing rates and became sublinear when neurons exhibited higher firing rates. We probed the nature of sublinearities in cortex by examining the influence of optogenetic stimulation of cortical interneurons. We observed a range of responses, including evidence for paradoxical responses in which interneuron stimulation caused a decrease in inhibitory firing rate, presumably due to the withdrawal of recurrent excitation. These results are compatible with cortical circuits that exhibit strong recurrent excitation with stabilizing inhibition that provides normalization, albeit normalization that is too weak across columns to account for cross-orientation suppression.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022targeted,
  author = {Shen Wang and Agostina Palmigiano and Kenneth D. Miller and Stephen D. Van Hooser},
  title = {{Targeted cortical stimulation reveals principles of cortical contextual interactions}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.06.22.497254},
  howpublished = {Biorxiv},
}
Figure