Taking Action against Anti-Healthcare Violence in China

Zhiyi Zhang, Weiyan Wang, Yue ZhangJournal of Nuclear Medicine & Radiation Therapy 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Medical doctors and nurses are the key endpoints of delivery for our service of medicine and therapy. However, similar to gun violence in the US, the virulent anti-healthcare violence (AHcV) has rampaged like a type of "virus" in China for a while and is a public healthcare problem worldwide as well. Fortunately, although we lagged behind other countries during the last century, China would now like to catch up with their counterparts in innovation and leadership in many aspects. On August 20, 2016 President Xi, Jin-Ping initiated an action against AHcV in the State Council Congress of China Central Government. Like or even better than the US in some aspects, we stand with our relatives, friends, colleagues and patients, and we also learn from the resilience of our community, which has demonstrated the power of a fast-responding and well-organized humanitarian movement to transform our society, our laws and our culture. Hopefully, actions against the AHcV in China will become exemplary in the near future.

Introduction

The epidemic of anti-healthcare violence (AHcV) in China has reached a critical point, characterized by physical assaults on medical staff and organized harassment. Unlike isolated workplace aggression, AHcV in China has evolved into a systemic "virus" that threatens the very foundation of the healthcare system. This crisis encompasses direct assaults, aggression against nurses, and the phenomenon of "yi-nao"—where individuals or organized groups disrupt hospital operations to make irrational financial demands.

A disturbing social rift was exposed following the 2012 murder of Dr. Wang Hao, when an online poll revealed that 65% of respondents were "pleased" by the event. This hostility is fueled by the perceived commercialization of healthcare, media misrepresentation, and a deep-seated mistrust in the medical system. This violence is not merely a security concern; it is a public health crisis requiring urgent intervention.

A Multi-Dimensional Framework for Action

To address this crisis, a five-part framework for action is proposed:

A "zero-tolerance" policing policy is essential. Furthermore, legal measures should forbid the media from misrepresenting medical disputes in ways that inflame public opinion. Reporting must be objective to prevent the further erosion of public trust.

2. Technological Intervention

Implementing rapid-response systems, such as covert "WeChat" codes for staff to signal distress, can improve immediate safety. Additionally, physical security measures, including airport-style X-ray scanners at hospital entrances, are necessary to deter the carriage of weapons.

3. Economic and Salary Reform

The current compensation model for physicians often fails to reflect their performance and expertise. Adjusting salaries to 3–5 times the societal average could reduce the reliance on "hidden bribes" and commercialized practices. Simultaneously, reducing the cost of imported medical goods can lower the financial burden on patients, easing systemic tension.

4. Professional Transparency

Restoring the "saving face" culture to one of professional integrity requires combatting corruption and hidden bribes. Transparency in medical practices and billing is vital to rebuilding the moral standing of the profession.

5. Data-Driven Conflict Resolution

Utilizing well-kept, transferable biomedical records provides objective evidence during disputes. This data-driven approach can help distinguish between genuine clinical errors and opportunistic harassment.

Contextual Evidence and Policy Momentum

Data suggests that the root causes of violence are largely social and economic rather than clinical; medical treatment problems account for less than 28% of patient-physician conflicts.

The efficacy of technological intervention was demonstrated during a pilot X-ray security program in Hangzhou, which detected seven knives in a single hospital on its first day. Furthermore, the need for high-quality, patient-centered research is highlighted by publication metrics: while there are 50,000 articles on osteoarthritis in the Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), only 1,500 appear in PubMed, suggesting a gap in globally recognized, evidence-based clinical practice.

The mandate for change is clear. President Xi Jinping’s 2016 initiation of action against AHcV represents a critical turning point for transforming the legal and cultural landscape of Chinese medicine.

Discussion: The "Yi-Nao" Economy and Cultural Barriers

The "yi-nao" phenomenon illustrates that violence is often a calculated tactic for financial gain rather than a spontaneous outburst of grief. This necessitates a legal framework that treats such disturbances as criminal acts rather than mere "medical disputes."

The disconnect between doctor salaries and societal expectations contributes to a cycle of mistrust. Low base pay often leads to practices that patients perceive as exploitative. Reforming this economic structure is fundamental to restoring the patient-provider relationship. However, cultural barriers like the concept of "saving face" can lead to non-transparent practices. A shift toward "zero-tolerance" for unethical behavior is required to rebuild public confidence.

Challenges and Future Directions

Implementing these reforms presents significant hurdles. Widespread X-ray scanning raises concerns regarding patient privacy and radiation risks, particularly for pregnant patients. Specialized protocols and ethical oversight are required.

Furthermore, scaling high-tech security and significantly increasing physician salaries across a massive national healthcare system is a daunting financial challenge. Future work must focus on developing better assessment tools to identify at-risk patients and fostering societal solidarity. The creation of a "national day against AHcV" could serve as a powerful symbol of this commitment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Medical doctors and nurses are the key endpoints of delivery for our service of medicine and therapy. However, similar to gun violence in the US [1], the virulent anti-healthcare violence (AHcV) has rampaged like a type of "virus" in China for a while and is a public healthcare problem worldwide as well. Fortunately, although we lagged behind other countries during the last century, China would now like to catch up with their counterparts in innovation and leadership in many aspects. On August 20, 2016 President Xi, Jin-Ping initiated an action against AHcV in the State Council Congress of China Central Government Like or even better than the US in some aspects, we stand with our relatives, friends, colleagues and patients, and we also learn from the resilience of our community, which has demonstrated the power of a fast-responding and well-organized humanitarian movement to transform our society, our laws and our culture Hopefully, actions against the AHcV in China will become exemplary in the near future.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2016taking,
  author = {Zhiyi Zhang and Weiyan Wang and Yue Zhang},
  title = {{Taking Action against Anti-Healthcare Violence in China}},
  journal = {Journal of Nuclear Medicine \& Radiation Therapy},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.4172/2155-9619.1000e116},
}
Figure